Another Take, A Different Road
Source: Tom's Guide US | Keywords: pc, repair, diagnostic | Themes: Software
6. Another Take, A Different Road
Just for grins, we priced out the items that we could in the PC-Doctor Service Center 6 kit, with an eye toward seeking items of comparable value and capability. Table 1 shows what we came up with:
| Item | Description | Possible replacement | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| POST Card | Displays PC POST codes & status | Shentech Star Empery PT063 | 5.00 |
| PC Diagnostic FlipPOST | 90.00 | ||
| PSU tester | Tests various PSU outputs | FrozenCPU ATX 2.0 | 15.00 |
| FrozenCPU ATX 2.0 Ultimate | 28.00 | ||
| USB Flash drive | 128 MB drive for storage | Corsair 1GB USB Flash drive | 10.00 |
| MUD | Bootable drive w/dongle, status LEDs | Not available for separate purchase | N/A |
| Diagnostics software | Suite of test & diagnostic programs | PC-Diagnostics Novice | 30.00 |
| Lavalys Everest Ultimate Edition | 35.00 | ||
| PC-Diagnostics Professional | 150.00 | ||
| Loopback adapters | Hardware testers for ports & audio | Loopback adapters (low price) | 25.00 |
| Loopback adapters (high price) | 50.00 |
If you factor in a number of other, readily available freeware programs (which we cover in Table 2 a little later on) what Table 1 suggests is that for a cost of between $85 on the low end, and up to $328 on the high end, you can match nearly all of the functionality that the PC-Doctor Service Center 6 delivers, with the possible exceptions of the depth and breadth of video and memory testing that the packaged product provides.
This raises a possibly thorny question: “What price convenience?” It’s inarguable that PC-Doctor puts all of its components together into a usable package at a premium price. If you’re inclined to take the higher-cost road anyway, the difference between $328 and $400 isn’t that great. Mind you, it does leave enough change to purchase a reasonably capable multimeter-like the V&A Auto/Manual Ranging Digital Multimeter with USB Interface (Model VA18B), which can measure all the voltages accurately inside a PC that the FrozenCPU PSU testers only read to within ±0.2V or so.
On the other hand, if you’re inclined to take the lower-cost route, there’s no question that you can get close to matching what you might need PC-Doctor for-not including low-level video and memory testing-for less than 25% of what the Service Center 6 kit will cost you. If you’re on a tight budget and balk at spending $400, you can still put together a reasonable trouble-shooting kit for under $100. We’d recommend Everest Ultimate Edition over the PC-Diagnostics Novice software ourselves, though you can get good results from either package. You’ll also want to grab all the items listed in Table 2 as well, and add them to your toolkit.
| Item | Description | URL |
|---|---|---|
| Memtest86+ | GPL memory testing utility | www.memtest.org |
| Drive Fitness Test | Freeware HD test utility from Hitachi (works with all drives) | www.hitachigst.com/hdd/ technolo/dft/dftnew.htm |
| CPU-Z | CPU & memory information analyzer | www.cpuid.com |
| PC Wizard 2008 | System information analyzer and benchmarking tool | www.cpuid.com |
| Prime95 | Free multi-platform prime number search tool doubles as CPU torture test | www.mersenne.org/freesoft.htm |
- Previous page Exploring the PC-Doctor Interface
- Next page Summary and Conclusions
This seems like a great product and fortune smiles for the inventer. Unfortunatly this mess costs the consumer millions in the long run, just to have a half broken machine until the end of mankind.