Mattress toppers are a simple, cost-effective way to give your bed a dream makeover. We test and unbox bulky sleep products for a living, so take it from us: mattress toppers are the easiest to set up and the most enjoyable to review. It's genuinely a lot of fun to see how a slab of memory foam or latex can completely transform our beds, and the best mattress toppers always have that magic touch for less.
If your current mattress is getting too old and unsupportive, we always reccomend taking a look at our best mattress guide as it will need to be replaced. However, if your mattress is a little too hard or soft, or just needs cooling down, then all you'll need is the right mattress topper to completely alter your bed. While there are a lot of premium mattress toppers for bigger budgets, there are just as many bed toppers under $100 for a queen in this month's mattress sales. That's why our best mattress topper picks encompass every budget and sleep position, so you'll find the right option for you.
Our top picks at a glance
Why you can trust Tom's Guide Our writers and editors spend hours analyzing and reviewing products, services, and apps to help find what's best for you. Find out more about how we test, analyze, and rate.
Best mattress topper overall
Quick summary
The Tempur-Adapt Mattress Topper is the best mattress topper around, offering the the signature luxe feel of a Tempur-Pedic mattresses for a fraction of the price. The Adapt topper contains 3 inches of NASA-developed Tempur material, which will mold to your shape when side sleeping and help alleviate hip pain and joint aches.
While there are plenty of other memory foam toppers that provide excellent comfort to side sleepers (such as the Lucid Gel Memory Foam Topper at #2 and the Casper Comfy Topper at #7), the Tempur-Adapt takes the No 1 spot due to its great features: hypoallergenic materials, stretchy straps to keep the topper in place, and a removable, machine-washable cover.
At MSRP, the starting price of a Tempur-Adapt is $319, while a queen size is $419. However, there's a 40% off deal on this topper that comes and goes, appearing sporadically and without warning.
If you happen to catch this discount, the starting price becomes $191.40 and a queen is reduced to $251. There's also a generous 10-year warranty included all year round, but be aware that this bed topper is non-returnable and no sleep trials are available.
Read what we liked, didn't like, and how to buy it ▼
If the non returns policy is a deal breaker, however, we suggest going for a pressure-relieving topper with a long trial, such as the Saatva High Density Foam Mattress Topper (#3) — which has a 180-night trial. However, it's never on sale, so a queen Saatva is always stuck at $295, while a queen Tempur-Adapt is $251.40 whenever it's discounted.
Our Review: In more detail
When reviewing the Tempur-Adapt Topper, our tester found it delivered plush, luxurious cushioning, and recommend it for side sleepers of light or average weight who like to be cradled by their mattress. A browse through the other user reviews for the Tempur-Adapt topper reveal plenty of enthusiastic customers. Multiple customers comment that it has helped ease or even eliminate their back pain, as well as preventing achy shoulders and hips.
Memory foam can sometimes trap body heat, and we found the Tempur-Adapt topper did sleep slightly warm for hot sleepers. If you're prone to sleeping really hot, there's the option to upgrade to a specialist cooling version; the Tempur Adapt+ Cooling costs $100 more, and features a phase-changing cover that's designed to stay cool to the touch. We didn't test it out ourselves, but plenty of customer reviews say it works impressively well to prevent night sweats. Hot sleepers can also choose the Casper Comfy Topper (#7) instead for both cushioning comfort and temperature control (but it doesn't have anchor straps and the cover is spot-clean only).
Although we loved the cloud-like comfort and soothing pressure relief of the Tempur-Adapt topper, we wouldn't necessarily recommend it to back sleepers or stomach sleepers, as the soft sleep surface won't provide the support needed in these positions. We also think it'll be too soft for heavier bodies.
Another potential sticking point is the lack of sleep trial despite a high MSRP. This might be the best memory foam mattress topper around, but the benefits are lacking – unless it's damaged upon delivery, the topper can't be returned. That's a bit of a risk to take if you're unfamiliar with the feel of the mattress. On the other hand, it is far cheaper than going for the full mattress (which you can read about in our Tempur-Adapt mattress review), but still delivers the same sleep feel and level of quality.
What we like about it...
✅ A luxury Tempur-Pedic feel for less: The Tempur-Adapt Topper offers the signature pressure relief of a luxury Tempur-Pedic mattress for a fraction of the price.
✅ Soothing pressure relief: When testing the Tempur-Adapt Topper, our reviewers compared its ample cushioning to sleeping on a cloud or a five-star hotel bed. Its plush sink-in feel soothes achy joints and hip pain, and provides deep pressure relief to side sleepers.
✅ Removable, washable cover: The removable, washable cover means it's easy to keep both the topper and your mattress clean. Did we also mention the cover's anchor straps that keep the bed topper firmly in place on your mattress?
What we don't like about it...
❌ No returns or sleep trials: At MSRP, this topper sits in the premium price bracket, so we understand that it's a lot of money to buy blind. Most mattress toppers come with a sleep trial so you can test it out before committing to your purchase, but the Tempur-Adapt has no at-home trial and is non-returnable.
❌ Too soft for back and stomach sleepers: While its cloud-like softness and plush cushioning may appeal to a lot of side sleepers, back and front sleepers will need something firmer and more supportive.
Where, when and how to buy
You can buy the Tempur-Adapt Topper at Tempur-Pedic, Amazon, Home Depot, and other retailers, but we recommend buying directly from the brand to ensure you get your 10-year warranty. At Tempur-Pedic, the Tempur-Adapt Topper is usually sold at either full retail price or with a 40% discount when using the code TOPPERS40.
Our advice: simply use the TOPPERS40 promo code. If the code doesn't work for you (although, it should) a 40% off sale pops up seemingly at random, and we have noticed that it tends to appear during major holiday events, too
While the absence of a sleep trial would have ordinarily knocked any other mattress topper off the top spot, the Tempur-Adapt's soothing pressure relief and cloud-like comfort outweighs any negatives. If you're a side sleeper looking to add cushioning comfort and softness to a hard mattress, I strongly recommend the Tempur-Adapt mattress topper.
Learn more: Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt Topper review
Our review score: ★★★★½
The best cheap mattress topper
Quick Summary
The Lucid Gel Memory Foam mattress topper is a low-budget model and an Amazon best-seller that provides a thick bed surface with decent cooling at a lower price. While Amazon is full of cheap cooling gel mattress toppers, this is our favorite cheap bed topper thanks to its ability to transform a bed on a budget.
At 4 inches deep, there's lots of cushioning for maximum pressure relief, and it's chunky enough to mask an uncomfortable sleep surface, too. While memory foam does have a reputation for trapping heat, this budget-friendly topper features a ventilated design infused with cooling gel to keep you feeling refreshed throughout the night.
Another big draw here is the price. A queen retails for $120 (based on the 4-inch, no-cover version), which is over $130 cheaper than a discounted queen-size Tempur-Adapt (#1). Since multiple retailers sell it, you'll be able to shop around for a good deal, too. If you buy directly from Lucid (which we recommend) you'll get a 30-night sleep trial, a 3-year warranty, and free shipping. Plus, Lucid has a habit of throwing 30% off flash sales every so often, which brings a queen-size down from $119.99 down to $84.
Read what we liked, didn't like, and how to buy it ▼
In the budget arena, it's also worth checking out the Linenspa topper – our Linenspa vs Lucid mattress topper comparison feature breaks down the differences between the two.
Our review: in more detail
Although there are actual cooling memory foam toppers out there if you're willing to pay a bit more (such as the Molecule CopperWELL at #4), our reviewers were surprised at how well the Lucid topper regulated body temperature. While we only tested out the foam-only version, you can opt to add on a polyester-blend cover that can be machine-washed. The cover also features a non-slip rubberized base, although there are no straps to anchor your topper in place.
In terms of comfort and support, we feel this is definitely a memory foam bed topper for side sleepers. We felt the most comfortable sleeping on our side, thanks to the topper's soft pressure relief which cushions key side-sleeping pressure points, such as the shoulders and hips.
This topper has a high star rating of 4.4 out of 5 on Amazon with over 28k reviews. Many happy customers sing its praises, commenting on how it transformed their sleep and improved their current firm mattress. Of those who didn't like it, the main complaints were mainly about it being too squishy and unsupportive.
We wouldn't recommend this topper to back or stomach sleepers, who need a supportive sleep surface, and you might find it's too unstable if you experience back pain. Note, that there are shallower versions (choose from the cheaper 2 inch or 3 inch models), which might address the issue.
What we like about it...
✅ Cheap price: If you're looking for a cost-effective way to boosts your bed's comfort, the Lucid Gel Memory Foam Topper is perfect for softening a hard mattress on a tight budget.
✅ Generous thickness: At 4 inches tall, this mattress topper reaches our maximum recommended height for a topper. This ample amount of thickness will make a significant impact on any mattress, completely changing its feel.
✅ Good temperature control for the price: This may not be a cooling mattress topper per se, but we found this budget-friendly topper sleeps relatively cool when considering the price and materials.
What we don't like about it...
❌ Cover costs extra: Due to its lower price, this mattress topper has a simple design. This means that a cover is sold separately, so the basic model comes as just a slab of memory foam. This may be off-putting to some who want a topper that's protected by washable cover.
❌ Too squishy for some: If you're a stomach or back sleeper, you may find that the 4" height is too thick and squidgy to support your hips and lower back. While you can try the shallower (and cheaper) versions of this model, you may be better off with something firmer such as the Saatva Graphite (#5) or the ViscoSoft Active Cooling (#6).
When, where and how to buy
As mentioned above, this is an Amazon best seller, but it's not always on sale at the retail giant. Other retailers that stock the Lucid Gel Memory Foam Topper are Walmart and Macy's. You can, of course, buy directly from Lucid's official website. We reccomend buying directly from the brand, as this guarantees you a better deal which includes a 30-night trail and a 3-year warranty.
Mattress toppers can be expensive, especially if you're looking for a quick stopgap to fix an older mattress while saving up for a new one. This is where the Lucid 4" Memory Foam Topper comes in handy. At a lower price, even at full retail, you can add comfort to a hard or aging mattress without having to spend a small fortune.
Learn more: Lucid Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper review
Our review score: ★★★½
The best luxury mattress topper
Quick Summary
The Saatva Foam Mattress Topper is the brand's least expensive topper, making it the quickest way to add the premium brand's signature luxury to your bed. It's also the thinnest in Saatva's topper line with a 1.5-inch profile, but its high-dense foam makes up for its slim build by providing ample cushioning for people who otherwise like the feel of their mattress. This high-density foam topper has a medium-firm feel to gently cradle your body.
While there are plenty of other luxury mattress toppers in this guide (such as the Naturepedic at #10), the Saatva High Density Foam Topper is the best luxury topper thanks to it's relative affordability. It's a great choice if you want a taste of Saatva's signature luxury comfort at a fraction of the cost of its full-fledged mattresses, as queen size retails at $295 ($150 cheaper than a queen Saatva Graphite at #5 and a whopping $456 cheaper than a queen Naturepedic Adagio). You also can take your time trying it out, as it comes with a 180-night sleep trial. However, discounts are virtually non-existent on this topper (as with all of Saatva's mattress toppers), so you're unlikely to find them in the Saatva mattress sales.
Read what we liked, didn't like, and how to buy it ▼
If you want a chance of scoring a discount on a luxe topper that adds a premium brand's signature feel to your bed, you may want to look to the Tempur-Adapt Topper (#1).
Our review: in more detail
Our lead tester for the Saatva Foam Mattress Topper review placed the bed topper on a mattress she found a little too firm for side sleeping. After adding the topper, she experienced the pressure relief along her shoulders that the Tempur-Pedic wasn't giving her. However, she did find the Saatva topper wasn't supportive enough for her midsection when sleeping on her front, so stomach sleepers will probably want to look for something firmer, such as the ViscoSoft Active Cooling Topper at #6).
Although the Saatva Foam Topper isn't a cooling model, she barely broke a sweat when sleeping on it, which she chalks up to the breathable, moisture-wicking organic cotton cover. Still, if you deal with chronic hot flashes or night sweats, a proper cooling topper like the Molecule CopperWELL (#4) will be a better choice for you.
There are a few flaws to this topper, however. The straps didn't do a good job of keeping the topper in place, as our tester had to adjust it most mornings. (This could also depend on how flat or smooth your mattress is – but we were disappointed, nonetheless.) Also, the warranty is only valid for a year, which is shockingly short for a brand that's known for its lifetime mattress warranties.
What we like about it...
✅ Excellent cushioning for side sleepers: Our lead tester found the high-density foam's medium-firm feel is ideal for side sleeping, and found it made a significant improvement in pressure relief around her shoulders.
✅ Sleeps relatively cool: Our reviewers never felt warm on this mattress topper, with the lead tester noticing it had eliminated her night sweats. We credit the above-average temperature regulation to the breathable organic cotton cover.
✅ Offers Saatva luxury for less: This is the most affordable of Saatva's topper line-up, and so it's one of the easiest and cheapest ways to experience Saatva's trademark luxury.
What we don't like about it...
❌ Unsupportive for stomach sleepers: The mattress topper provides excellent comfort to side sleepers but doesn't provide enough support for stomach sleepers. In fact, our main tester preferred to sleep without the topper on the bed when lying on her stomach.
❌ Prone to shifting: While anchor straps are included in the design, we found the topper still moved on top of the mattress. This meant our main tester had to constantly shift the topper back into the correct position when making the bed every morning.
When, where and how to buy
It used to be that Saatva's mattresses, topper, and other accessories could only be purchased directly through Saatva's website. However, we now notice that many of their products are available to buy on Amazon through the retailer's Saatva store.
That said, you won't be able to find a discount on the Saatva High-Density Foam Mattress Topper whether you buy from Saatva or Amazon. With that in mind, we strongly recommend buying from the brand directly as this guarantees you their benefits, such as a 180-night sleep trial and a 1-year warranty.
While we always reccomend choosing a topper that's at least 2 inches thick, the Saatva High Density Foam Topper makes up for its relatively thin frame by using ultra-cushioning, ultra-dense foam. It's also one of the cheapest ways to experience Saatva's trademark luxury, and side sleepers will be able to overlook the minor faults thanks to the deep pressure relief it provides.
Learn more: Saatva Foam Mattress Topper review
Our review score: ★★★★½
Best cooling mattress topper
Quick Summary
We named the CopperWELL as the best cooling mattress topper after we scored this cooling copper-infused memory foam topper 5 out of 5 in the temperature regulation department. To put that award into context, the other cooling mattress topper (#6) in this guide only got 4 out of 5 in that department. While testing the CopperWELL, we never felt any trapped heat (usually associated with memory foam) and the copper has anti-microbial properties, so it's also a great choice for those with allergies.
The medium-firm sleep feel should suit a wide array of sleepers, but we found it to be most comfortable for side sleeping. However, if you want a cooling mattress topper with a good amount of firmness for back and front sleepers, we recommend checking out the ViscoSoft Active Cooling Mattress Topper at #6.
That said, the CopperWELL is cheaper than the Active Cooling Topper; a queen CopperWELL is priced at $249.99 at MSRP, while a queen Active Cooling is $299.95 when discounted. While for the price you would expect a cover, Molecule justifies its lack of a cover by suggesting one would prevent sleepers from fully experiencing the zoned support and airflow benefits.
Read what we liked, didn't like, and how to buy it ▼
However, no matter how much bedding we added to the topper, it's cooling performance remained unaffected.
Our review: in more detail
Our lead tester was impressed with the Molecule CopperWELL Mattress Topper’s ability to combine cooling prowess with pressure relieving comfort. This is achieved largely due to its unique construction. Its 3" profile includes open-cell memory foam that's infused with copper and topped with a 7-zoned surface. What does that mean? This is a topper that’s firmer in some places, such as the head, waist and legs for correct spinal alignment, and softer in others, like around the shoulders, hips and knees.
This body cradling support means it’s a great option for side sleepers, but will also appeal to back and stomach sleepers who favor a sleep surface with a little sink (if you're looking for something firmer, opt for the ViscoSoft Active Cooling Mattress Topper at #6).
The open-cell structure and copper infused foam provides reliable temperature regulation. During the two week testing period, our reviewer didn’t overheat once despite testing it during a relatively warm spell. The benefits of the copper-infused foam are twofold; it’s cooling and antimicrobial, which means it’s a safe option for hot sleepers and those prone to allergies.
While there aren't any anchor bands on the Molecule CopperWELL Mattress Topper, our tester reported that it felt secure on the bed regardless. It’s also worth noting that it doesn’t come with a cover so it’s spot-clean only. Without a cover, it's a tad annoying to keep clean, so we recommend finding a machine-washable mattress protector that'll safeguard it from spills without compromising its cooling capabilities while also holding it securely in place.
What we like about it...
✅ Excellent temperature regulation: This cooling bed topper's open-cell design infused with copper provides a breathable, moisture-wicking sleep. Awarding the topper 5 out of 5 for temperature control, our reviewers reccomend this topper to any hot sleepers who aren't able to buy the best cooling mattress.
✅ Suits side and back sleepers: Made from body-contouring memory foam, the bed topper provided cushioning pressure relief to our side-sleeping main tester. Its balance between cushioning and firmness also means it's great for back sleepers, too.
✅ Targeted support: The body-cradling mattress topper features seven zones with varying softness and firmness. It's softer along the shoulders, hips, and knees (key side-sleeping pressure points) while firmer along the head, waist legs and feet.
What we don't like about it...
❌ No cover: The Molecule CopperWELL's design deliberately does not include a cover. The brand says a cover is not included as it may interfere with the cooling design and zoned support. However, we found adding bedding to the topper doesn't affect these features, and the lack of a cover makes it difficult to clean.
❌ Too soft for stomach sleepers: While it supplies a nice mixture of cushioning comfort and firm support for both side and back sleepers, stomach sleepers will find the softer zones to be unsupportive.
When, where and how to buy
The CopperWELL topper is available to buy from retailers such as Amazon and Wayfair, but you can also buy directly from Molecule. While discounts on this topper are rare wherever you buy, we reccomend purchasing the CopperWELL directly from Molecule as it guarantees you a 5-year limited warranty, a 30-night sleep trial, and free shipping and returns.
In terms of the best time to buy, there doesn't seem to be one. While there has been discounts on this topper to coincide with some sales events such as Presidents' Day, a discount during a holiday isn't always a given.
While discounts on this topper are rare, the CopperWELL is still the top choice if you're looking for an easy, cost-effective way to cool down your bed. Its copper-infused foam offers a heat-dissipating, antimicrobial feel while its open-cell design adds breathability to a stuffy mattress. Plus, its seven-zone design means it's perfect for side-sleeping hot sleepers looking for cooling pressure relief.
Learn more: Molecule CopperWELL Mattress Topper review
Our review score: ★★★★½
The best mattress topper for back pain
Quick Summary
The Saatva Graphite Mattress Topper is our top recommendation for back sleepers who need medium-firm support. It includes 3" of body hugging foam for a soothing feel when sleeping on your back or side, while the graphite infusion provides a cooling touch. The organic cotton cover also provides extra breathability and features anchor straps to keep the topper from shifting.
Sitting in the premium price bracket, a queen is typically priced at $445. Saatva toppers aren't usually discounted, but it's worth checking before you buy, just in case. When it comes to extras, there's a 180-night home trial – the longest of any brand on this list. On the other hand, it's only backed by a 1-year limited warranty, which is very short considering the premium price tag.
Read what we liked, didn't like, and how to buy it ▼
Torn between the Saatva and the Tempur-Pedic at #1? We talk you through it in our Saatva vs Tempur-Pedic mattress topper comparison.
Our review: in more detail
Our lead tester was suffering from a back injury when testing out the Saatva Graphite, and this topper provided her with effective relief and support when lying on her back. Chalk this relief up to the topper's 3" of memory foam, which delivers loads of pressure relief, especially in the lumbar (lower back) region. The medium-firm sleep feel (we'd rate it a 6 out of 10) will suit any sleep position, but we'd especially recommend it to those who like to sleep on their back. We sank into it but also felt well-supported in this position.
The graphite layer is designed to draw heat away from your body, and in our Saatva Graphite Mattress Topper review, we were very impressed with its temperature regulation. This topper stayed cool to the touch throughout our test period, making it a great choice for anyone prone to sleeping warm.
The build quality here is excellent, as we'd expect from Saatva. Stretchy, elasticated bands anchor the topper in place – it somehow fared better in this area than the Saatva Foam Topper (#3), which we've also reviewed. One slight downside is that the cover cannot be removed, so this model is spot-clean only.
What we like about it...
✅ Excellent back support: Its medium-firm feel provides excellent support and even weight distribution for back sleepers. It's also a great choice for those suffering from lower back pain as it keeps the region well supported and relieved.
✅ Great temperature regulation: The graphite infusion is designed to regulate temperature by drawing away body heat. Plus the organic cotton cover is breathable and moisture-wicking, keeping you cool and dry throughout the night
✅ High-quality design: Saatva, famed for their luxury designs, provides top quality with this topper. With stretch anchor straps to keep the bed from shifting and a 3" thick frame, this topper is a great way to add Saatva's signature luxury to your mattress.
What we don't like about it...
❌ Non-removable, spot-clean cover: While this topper comes with a breathable organic cover that's been treated with an antimicrobial treatment for a clean, hypoallergenic sleep, it's non-removable and spot clean only.
❌ Too soft for stomach sleepers: The Saatva Graphite provides a body-hugging foam feel to side sleepers and medium-firm support to back sleepers, but we wouldn't recommend this to those who sleep on their front. If you're a stomach sleeper seeking a firm topper with a cooling infusion, we suggest going for the ViscoSoft Active Cooling Topper at #6.
When, where and how to buy
There's never really an optimal time to buy any Saatva mattress topper, as they never seem to be on sale. Even when Saatva throws site-wide sales for holidays such as Memorial Day and Black Friday, knocking hundreds of dollars off their mattresses, their toppers always remain at full retail price. This means you never have to be too strategic about when you buy the Saatva Graphite.
Up until recently, you could only purchase a Saatva product through the Saatva website, but you can now buy a Saatva topper from Amazon's Saatva store. However, we reccomend buying directly from the brand as it guarantees a 180-night sleep trial, and it's unlikely that you'll find a price drop no matter where you buy.
The Saatva Graphite Topper is ideal for back sleepers and those suffering with lower back pain thanks to its soothing support and its crowd-pleasing medium-firm feel. A major plus is its temperature regulation, with the graphite infusion and breathable organic cotton cover providing a refreshingly cool sleep. As with the High Density Foam Topper at #3, there's never a discount on this cooling mattress topper.
Learn more: Saatva Graphite mattress topper review
Our review score: ★★★★½
The best firm mattress topper
Quick summary
If you want to make your mattress firmer and supportive, the ViscoSoft Active cooling topper is the best option. This 4-inch thick, medium-firm option offers gentle pressure relief alongside more solid support, and it's perfect for back sleepers. As you'd guess from the name, it also offers good temperature regulation. Although the phase-change cover wasn't cold-to-the-touch for us, the copper-infused foam kept our testers comfortably cool on even the warmest nights.
Officially, there's no trial period for this topper, although if you buy direct from ViscoSoft, there's a 90-day money-back guarantee, during which time the brand will refund you if you're not satisfied with your purchase. You'll also get a 5-year warranty. Price-wise, this is the most expensive of ViscoSoft's topper line-up, with a queen going for $399.95 at MSRP. However, there's a 25% of evergreen deal on toppers at ViscoSoft, which regularly takes a queen size down to $299.95.
Read what we liked, didn't like, and how to buy it ▼
The downside is that sizes are frequently out of stock. If you're in need of a new topper now, but your chosen size is out of stock, we reccomend going for the Saatva Graphite (#5) for a cooling foam topper or the firm version of the Puffy Deluxe (#8) to make your mattress firmer.
Our review: in more detail
We rated this cooling topper 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale, the perfect balance of gentle cradling and support that should suit a lot of sleep styles, especially back. However, our reviewers did feel their hips dip slightly when resting on their stomach, and lighter side sleepers might find this topper a touch too solid for comfort (it's slightly firmer than the Saatva Graphite at #5).
While this topper's main selling point is its cooling properties, it isn't the most cooling topper we've slept on (that distinction goes to the CopperWELL at #4) as we didn't find its phase-changing cover to be that cool-to-the-touch. That said reviewers still felt comfortably cool even during a testing period that coincided with a dreadfully hot Mid-Atlantic summer
While the ViscoSoft Active Cooling Copper Topper is at the pricier end of our best mattress toppers list, it is a high-quality option. Other customers agree, with this topper getting an average of 4.4 out of 5 stars (171 reviews, as of November 2024) on the company website. The reviews highlight the topper’s comfort and luxurious feel. What's more, regular discounts will drop the price into a more affordable bracket for most, although stock can be hard to come by for some sizes.
In terms of design, this ViscoSoft topper features elastic anchor straps to attach to your mattress securely with easy-to-fit elastic straps. The cover, which is made from a breathable mesh with an airy feel, has anti-slip properties too. We were pleased to find that the cover can be removed and washed, but did find it a little bit tricky to get on and adjust. Our tester also noted some potent off-gassing, which shouldn't be a deal-breaker but is worth being aware of before you buy.
What we like about it...
✅ Great temperature regulation: While it may not be as cool-to-the-touch as you'd imagine, its copper infusion and Phase Change Material cover does a great job at keeping you cool and comfy even on the warmest of days.
✅ Ideal for adding firm support to a too-soft bed. With a score of 7/10 on the firmness scale, this mattress topper is great for back sleepers in need of some body-contouring yet firm support.
✅ Removable, washable cover: Available in two colors (black or ivory), the breathable mesh cover is removable and machine-washable for an easy clean. For an extra hygienic touch, the topper also has antimicrobial properties through the copper infusion.
What we don't like about it...
❌ Lacks plushness for side sleepers: If you're a lightweight side sleeper looking for ultra-plush pressure relief, the Active Cooling Topper is going to be too firm for your body type and sleep style.
❌ Frequently out of stock: This is a popular topper, and so often you may find that your preferred size is out of stock. While you can check back again to see if your size has been restocked, it can be a pain if you're in need of a topper now.
When, where and how to buy
As there's an evergreen 25% off discount on this topper at ViscoSoft, you don't need to be too strategic about when you buy. Our only caveat is that this topper is frequently out of stock in certain sizes (especially the smaller ones), so you may have to wait for fresh stock to find your preferred size.
Apart from buying directly from the brand, you can also find the topper at retailers such as Amazon and Wayfair. However, it's slim pickings when finding certain sizes at these retailers, too. As always, we reccomend buying directly from the brand to get your full benefits, such as the 90-day money back guarantee and the 5-year warranty.
A great choice if you dislike a sink-in soft bed and want to make it less stuffy, the Active Cooling Topper will add both firmness and decent temperature control to your mattress. While it can be hard to find certain sizes due to frequent unavailability, it's worth the money if you manage to get your hands on one.
Learn more: Viscosoft Active Cooling Mattress Topper review
Our review score: ★★★★
The best mattress topper for side sleepers
Quick summary
A favorite among side sleepers, the Casper Comfy Mattress Topper is the perfect way to add some softness to a hard bed. This 3" tall topper topper is luxuriously cushiony and it feels like adding a giant pillow to your bed, thanks to its body-cradling top layer of foam and a supportive layer on the bottom. Its perforated foam design also means it sleeps incredibly cool for a memory foam mattress topper that isn't billed as cooling, making it a cheaper and cooler alternative to the Tempur-Adapt (#1)
Price-wise, we're at the lower end of mid-range here. Casper sales and deals aren't super common, but you can often catch a 10% or 20% discount at the brand from time to time. It's also available at Target and you can often save big when buying the topper from Amazon. However, if you want to be certain that you'll get a 30-night trial and 5-year warranty, buy directly from Casper, where a queen typically costs $299 at full retail price or $269.10 when on sale.
Read what we liked, didn't like, and how to buy it ▼
If you're a side sleeper on a tight budget, we reccomend the Lucid Gel Memory Foam Topper (#3), which is 1" thicker and $150 cheaper for a queen than a discounted Casper Comfy Topper.
Our review: in more detail
Our lead tester found that the Casper Comfy Topper delivered excellent comfort and good support in a side sleeping position, although stomach or back sleepers might need something slightly firmer to promote healthy spinal alignment. One area in which this topper particularly impressed us is temperature regulation. The foam is perforated to encourage movement of air, and in our tests, we found it worked well – our testers didn't overheat when trying out this topper, even with a heavy duvet added.
There's a removable knit cover made from partly recycled materials, although the benefits of that are somewhat undermined by the fact that it's not machine washable (spot-clean only). It can be a bit of a pain to get on and off, and there are no straps to keep it in place.
What we like about it...
✅ Superb pressure relief for side sleepers: Reviewers found that the Casper Comfy Topper felt the most comfortable when they slept on their side thanks to a plush top layer.
✅ Impressive temperature regulation: While not billed as a cooling topper, the Casper Comfy provided great temperature control and breathability through airflow-boosting perforated memory foam.
✅ Ideal for hard mattresses: If your mattress feels to hard or your experiencing sore joints and a tingling arm when side sleeping, placing this topper on your bed will provide the cushioning you need.
What we don't like about it...
❌ Cover is not machine-washable: Even though the soft-knit cover is removable, it's bafflingly spot clean only. This make its particularly difficult if you want to give the cover an easy, deep clean. The cover also has no anchor straps to stop the topper from shifting at night.
❌ May be too soft for some sleepers: While our lead tester felt comfortable sleeping on this topper in all positions, this is definitely a side-sleeper topper and will likely be too soft for front and back sleepers.
When, where and how to buy
The topper is often sold at MSRP at Casper, but you can frequently catch a 10% discount. The brand has also been known to throw 20% to 25% off sales, but these are hard to predict and don't seem to coincide with major holiday sales events.
Over at Amazon, you'll find bigger savings, especially on a twin size which is usually 40% off at $120. However, the discounts frequently change and are different for each size, so you may want to compare the price of your chosen size on both Casper and Amazon.
The Casper Comfy Topper is ideal if your current mattress is too firm, or if your dorm bed feels too hard. The temperature regulation is a huge bonus, too, with a ventilated design keeping you cool. I recommend shopping around for this topper, as there are some pretty good deals to catch at both Casper and Amazon.
Learn more: Casper Comfy Mattress Topper review
Our review score: ★★★★½
Best memory foam mattress topper
Quick summary
The Puffy Deluxe is our top choice for best memory foam topper as it's the only memory foam bed topper in this guide that comes with two adjustable firmness options (soft or firm), so this 2.5" mattress topper is perfect for providing customized comfort. This gives you a little more freedom in adjusting your bed feel so you can make it cozier or more supportive as needed. Plus, good news if you deal with allergies — this topper comes with a hypoallergenic bamboo rayon/polyester cover you can throw in the washing machine.
Puffy includes a 101-night trial and a lifetime warranty with its mattresses — and offers those same extras with its mattress toppers. Sleep companies usually truncate the warranty and trial periods for their toppers, so it's nice to see Puffy go against the norm. (No other topper on this list comes with a lifetime warranty, either.)
Read what we liked, didn't like, and how to buy it ▼
In terms of price, Puffy have kept their 25% discount but recently bumped up their MSRPs, meaning a queen is now $288 at full retail and $245 when on sale. This may not be as cheap as our budget foam option at #2, but it is still cheaper than the Casper at #7 (which usually goes for $270 for a queen and $299 at full retail) and a $295 queen Saatva High Density Foam Topper (#3).
Our review: in more detail
We tested the firm version of the Puffy Deluxe Mattress Topper – which we placed atop a super firm innerspring bed. It has that classic memory foam sensation; our tester could feel it gradually mold to her shape like the best memory foam mattresses. We found it comfortable in any sleep position – though we reckon the soft version will be better for side sleepers who crave a plusher bed feel, as well as lighter bodies who don't like anything too firm.
Unlike most mattress toppers that exclusively use anchor straps, you'll also find a grippy lower cover and a full elasticated skirt, akin to what you'd find on a mattress pad. If you're a fidgety sleeper, you can expect this mattress topper to stay in place.
Just be careful if you sleep warm, as this memory foam mattress topper traps heat. Go for the Molecule CopperWELL Mattress Topper (#4) if you're looking for a memory foam topper with great cooling features. Also, if you're over 250lbs, the Puffy Deluxe Mattress Topper may not be supportive enough for you, regardless of the feel. We'd recommend a durable latex topper such as the Naturepedic Adagio (#10).
What we like about it...
✅ Customizable firmness options: Available in two firmness options, go for the firm if you want something more supportive, while side sleepers should spring for the soft version for a plush, body-hugging feel.
✅ Generous extras: The Puffy Deluxe Mattress Topper is the only entry on this list to boast a lifetime warranty. It also comes with free shipping and a 101-night sleep trial to test it out at home.
✅ Great for restless sleepers: A cover that includes anchor straps, a grippy base, and elasticated skirt, this mattress will not budge even if you're prone to restless sleeping and fidgeting at night.
What we don't like about it...
❌ Sleeps warm: Our lead tester noticed that the memory foam topper (which can be prone to trapping heat) did sleep slightly warm during the reviewing period, so hot sleepers should look to the Casper Comfy Topper at #7 for a memory foam topper with better temperature control.
❌ Too soft for heavyweight sleepers: If you're over 250lbs, the Puffy Deluxe Mattress Toper may not be supportive enough for you, regardless of the feel.
When, where and how to buy
You can buy the Puffy Deluxe Mattress Topper directly from the brand's website, where you'll find an evergreen 25% off deal. However, in terms of when to buy, you'll need to be strategic. While the 25% off sale is a permanent fixture at Puffy, the MSRPs have recently changed to coincide with the summer months.
For example, in spring 2024, the starting MSRP was $179, while the sale price was $152. The starting MSRP has now increased to $238 and the sale price is now $202. While we can't know for certain if the MSRP will change again, we do predict it will.
Choose the Puffy Deluxe Topper if you want to customize your firmness feel and add a signature hug of memory foam to your mattress. However, as it sleeps warm, I suggest hot sleepers should either choose the Casper Comfy Topper at #7 or add a cooling mattress protector.
Read more: Puffy Deluxe Mattress Topper review
Our review score: ★★★★½
The best dorm mattress topper
Quick summary
What better mattress topper for a dorm bed than one brought to you by a sleep brand designed especially for college students? The Sleepyhead Cooling Copper Topper, featuring a 3" thick slab of antimicrobial copper-infused foam and a washable cover, is designed to add a dense, hygienic comfort layer to uncomfortable, germy dorm beds.
The standard 3" version comes in a medium-soft, which we feel is best for side sleepers. However, a twin XL (standard dorm bed size) also comes in a cheaper, firmer 2" version. A 3" twin XL, meanwhile is priced at $399 (a 2" is $399), but students can get up to 20% off at Sleepyhead. It's also the perfect mattress topper to see you through your studies, as it comes with a five-year "good-til-graduation" warranty.
Read what we liked, didn't like, and how to buy it ▼
If you're not a student, but like the sound of the Cooling Copper Topper, you can also buy a Sleepyhead Cooling Copper Topper from Amazon, where you'll often find discounts during sale events. However, keep in mind that you may not have access to the same warranty and sleep trial.
Our review: in more detail
When testing out the Cooling Copper Topper, we placed it on a too-firm-for-side-sleeping latex bed. However, adding the topper gave the mattress much more pressure relief, especially around the hips and knees,when side sleeping. Most back and stomach sleepers will find it too soft, but side sleepers will love the body-molding feel. While there is a firmer 2" version for back and front sleepers, it's unfortunately only available in a twin XL
While we slept comfortably cool most nights, we didn't feel it did a phenomenal job of regulating temperature considering it's billed as a cooling topper. In fact, there were some nights when we felt a build-up of body heat.
Despite the cooling technology being a let-down, there were a lot of things to love about this topper. The machine-washable, removable cover featured an anti-slip base and adjustable corner straps, which helped to anchor the topper in place and prevented it from shifting in the nights. Its 3" height is also thick enough to alter the feel of even the hardest, thinnest, or worn-out beds.
What we like about it...
✅ Adds a thick, hygienic layer to old mattresses and dorm beds: The 3" thick design features mite-resistant and resistant memory foam infused with antimicrobial copper, making it ideal for adding hygienic protection to germy dorm beds and aging mattresses.
✅ Great for side sleepers: Testers felt comfortable and supported when sleeping on their sides, as it offers the right balance between pressure relief and support.
✅ Removable, machine-washable top: The mattress topper comes with a removable cover, which is machine-washable and ideal for keeping dorm beds clean.
What we don't like about it...
❌ Too plush for stomach sleepers: While this bed topper provides the right amount of support to side sleepers, it's still remarkably plush, which is bad news for front sleepers who need a lot more support.
❌ Not the most cooling: Despite being billed as a cooling topper, we felt that it did retain some heat on warmer nights.
When, where and how to buy
You can buy the ViscoSoft Lux Hybrid at the brand's website or on Amazon, but you'll find deals in both places. However, we suggest buying directly from the brand as it comes with a 90-day money-back guarantee and a 5-year warranty. Plus, with a permanent 25% off discount, you won't have to be too strategic about when you buy.
I was one of the testers who slept on the Sleepyhead Cooling Copper Topper, and found it ideal for adding a thick layer of comfort and protection to a dorm bed or an old mattress that's seen better days. The anchor straps and machine-washable were also excellent touches, but be aware that it wasn't as cool as its name suggests.
Learn more: Sleepyhead Cooling Copper Mattress Topper review
Our review score: ★★★★
Mattress toppers we've also tested and reccomend
How we test mattress toppers
The mattress topper review process at Tom's Guide is editorially independent and not influenced by third parties. Our expert testers sleep on each mattress topper for at least three weeks, which is the recommended amount of time needed to truly gauge whether a mattress topper is right for you.
We test out the latest mattress toppers in all key areas — delivery and set-up, pressure relief, temperature regulation, and support and comfort — to create recommendations that are honest, helpful, and unbiased. We then give each area a score out of 5.
When scoring delivery and set-up, we review how quick and hassle-free the delivery was, how easy it is to unbox and install the topper, and if the new mattress topper gives off any strong off-gassing. For pressure relief, support, and comfort, our panel sleeps on each topper in different sleep positions (back, stomach, and side) to see how comfortable and supportive it feels in those positions. Temperature regulation is also an important area, so we also pay attention to how we feel throughout the night and in the mornings.
However, we know one person's experience sleeping on a mattress topper can be different to another person's experience. That's why we also asked a trusted and experienced testing panel, made up of people with different sleep preferences, to rate each mattress by following our performance criteria.
In addition to first-hand testing, we also research each bed topper we test by trawling through verified customer reviews. We do this to give a more well-rounded review, as some areas that can't be gauged from a month of testing, such as durability or the bed topper's affect on certain sleep and health issues.
Best mattress toppers: Buying advice
How to choose the right mattress topper for you
When choosing a mattress topper, the first thing you need to consider is why your current bed needs one. Is your mattress too hard or too soft? Does it trap heat? Does it simply need a refresh after years of use? Whatever issue you're facing with your current bed, your mattress topper should provide the right features to fix it. That's why there are a number of things you should consider before buying a mattress topper:
- Firmness: If you find your mattress too firm, you need to look for a mattress topper that's designed to offer cushioning comfort and pressure relief, such as a memory foam one. Likewise, if your mattress is too soft or squidgy, look for a bed topper such as the Puffy Deluxe Mattress Topper (#8 in this guide) that offers a line-up of firmness options so you can find one that’s more suitable.
- Sleep position and body type: Make sure that your mattress topper suits your preferred sleep style, otherwise problems such as back pain can arise. For example, a lightweight side sleeper will feel comfortable on the Tempur-Adapt Topper (#1), but a heavyweight stomach sleeper will need something firmer to keep their hips supported and spine properly aligned.
- Temperature: Does your memory foam mattress feel as if it's trapping your body heat? Do you suffer from night sweats? Well, you may want to invest in a cooling mattress topper such as #4 and #6 in this guide, as well as bed toppers with excellent temperature regulation such as #5 and #8.
- Materials and durability: Materials are also important when considering what mattress to buy, as they often dictate how long a mattress topper is likely to last. For example, a latex or wool topper is highly durable and can last a decade. Memory foam toppers need to be replaced every two to five years (depending on quality), while a feather or down topper lasts only one to two years.
- Budget: While a luxury organic mattress topper can offer advanced cooling, high durability, and premium comfort, they can be outside a lot of budgets and even cost as much as an inexpensive mattress. Look for cheaper toppers, such as the Lucid at #2, if you're on a tight budget.
- Hygiene: Mattress toppers are a great way to add extra protection to your mattress, so finding one with a removable, washable cover is a great way to keep both the mattress and mattress topper clean. If you suffer from allergies, there are also plenty of mattress toppers made from clean, hypoallergenic materials. For example, all Saatva mattress toppers (such as #3 and #5) are covered in antimicrobial treatment to keep mold, mildew, and dust mites away.
- Height: Always choose a mattress topper that's between 2" and 4". Any shorter, the topper will make no difference to the feel of your mattress. On the other hand, a thicker mattress topper will make your bed surface feel too squidgy. The only exception in this guide is the 1.5" Saatva High-Density Foam Mattress Topper (#3) as the incredibly dense foam makes up for its short stature.
- Extras: We reccomend buying a mattress topper that comes with a warranty and a sleep trial that's at least 30 nights long, which allows you to sleep on your bed topper for an allotted time before deciding whether you'd like to return it.
When is the best time to buy a mattress topper?
Good value mattress topper deals come up regularly throughout the year. Usually at least one of the toppers in our guide will have a discount at any given time. That said, there are some key periods that tend to offer slightly bigger discounts. November is when we normally see some of the best mattress topper deals from the biggest names in sleep, and these usually form part of the wider Black Friday mattress sales.
In February, there are big discounts in the Presidents Day mattress sales; and in May there's always a wide variety of toppers on sale during Memorial Day. We also tend to see decent deals during the summer sales, on Labor Day in September, and in early December with Cyber Monday.
Mattress topper materials guide: foam, gel, latex
There is a countless number of mattress toppers available, so it can be difficult to know what to choose. Here’s a quick guide to the three main materials that you’ll find in bed toppers and the benefits of each.
Memory foam — a popular material used to make many of the best mattresses in a box, memory foam bed toppers are a cheap and easy way to change up your mattress, making it softer or firmer depending on what you need. If you get chilly, then memory foam is a cozier option as it tends to retain heat, although there are some cooling options too.
Gel — if you sleep hot then bed toppers made with cooling gel-infused foam are designed to keep your body temperature at a cooler level as you sleep. These are often cool to the touch, which is total bliss for hot sleepers. Look out for gel-infused toppers that also have washable and antimicrobial covers, which is essential for keeping your bed topper hygienic if you sweat.
Latex — natural latex is extremely durable, nicely springy, and breathable making it ideal if you’re looking for something long-lasting and hard-wearing on top of the comfort. Latex mattress toppers are often a good choice for RVs/campervans.
Best Mattress Toppers: FAQs
What are the benefits of a mattress topper?
If your mattress is still in good condition, but isn’t quite right — maybe it’s too soft, too firm, or not cooling enough — then there will be a mattress topper to help. Bed toppers are a simple way to transform any mattress, instantly, cheaply, and easily, with just a few inches of memory foam, latex, or feathers providing that little extra something you need.
If you’re looking to bring the temperature down, try a bed topper with cooling qualities such as a gel-infused top or a sweat-wicking cover. Many come with covers that can be removed and washed too, making it easier to keep fresh.
Most mattress toppers are around 3" thick, but there are many that are deeper if you need extra support or stability beyond your existing mattress. If you need more relief for pressure points, then a memory foam topper is ideal.
How thick should a mattress topper be?
Mattress toppers can range in thickness greatly, from just an inch or two to eight inches or more. However, a happy medium for most is around four inches, and those under two inches should probably be avoided.
A thin topper is unlikely to actually provide much extra support or cushioning, and in use you're likely to 'bottom out', meaning your pressure points won't really be feeling any difference compared to your mattress alone.
Those that are too thick, however (especially standard memory foam toppers), will have you sinking deeply into the topper. While some might enjoy this, it can prove problematic when it comes to moving around in bed. You might find yourself feeling a little trapped, and if it doesn't spring back into shape immediately you could also struggle to get comfy when you change position.
While it all depends on your preference and what material you've chosen, we think between two to four inches is the best for a mattress topper. For more information, head to our guide on how thick a mattress topper should be.
Are mattress toppers good for back and hip pain?
If you suffer from back ache and suspect it could be caused by your mattress, it could just take adding a mattress topper to help relieve the pain. Side sleepers, for instance, should be properly supported along the spine and at the pressure points, something a memory foam topper can help with.
If you’re sinking too much into your mattress, that can push your spine out of alignment, so a firmer topper will help even straighten things out. The same is true for a mattress that is too firm, which can quickly cause soreness. A mattress topper with a softer surface, such as a plush top, will soon transform your sleep and make it less painful at pressure points too.
If your pain is severe or persistent then check with a healthcare professional, who should be able to advise you further.
How long do mattress toppers last?
There are key signs that your mattress topper needs replacing, such as a stained or damaged cover or a noticeable decline in comfort and support. However, sometimes a mattress topper may not show these signs, so its helps to know its life expectancy.
A mattress's lifespan depends on both its quality and materials. Cheaper mattress toppers will have a low life expectancy, while expensive bed toppers with a high-quality design tend to last much longer. There's also the type of mattress topper you buy. Most mattress toppers are made of one of the four following materials: memory foam, latex, wool, or feather/down. Here's the average lifespan of each kind:
Material | Average topper lifespan |
|---|---|
Feather/Down | 1-2 years |
Memory Foam | 2-5 years |
Latex | 5-15 years |
Wool | 10 years |
Feather or down toppers are great for small budgets but have the lowest life expectancy, needing to be replaced every two years. Memory foam, the most popular topper material, has a slightly longer lifespan of up to five years. Latex and wool topper are natural and durable, so are much more expensive. However, they can be a good investment as they can last over a decade.
How much should you pay for a good mattress topper?
The popularity of mattress toppers stems from their prices. They are a much cheaper way to transform your bed without having to splurge on a new mattress. However, some premium bed toppers don't come cheap, and even cost more than some of the best cheap mattresses.
Here's a breakdown of the average costs of each type of mattress topper:
Material / type | Average sale price (Queen) |
|---|---|
Memory foam mattress topper | $299 |
Latex mattress topper | $575 |
Cooling mattress topper | $375 |
Affordable mattress topper | $55 |
Is Memorial Day a good time to buy a mattress topper?
The Memorial Day mattress sales are synonymous with rock-bottom prices, bedding freebies, and bigger savings. However, mattress topper deals don't tend to come with freebies (complimentary bedding bundles seem to only come with mattresses) and a lot of Memorial Day topper deals are just standard, evergreen deals disguised as exclusive special discounts.
Then there's the high demand, which can lead to back orders, cancellations, and shipping delays. For instance, ViscoSoft's ultra-popular mattress toppers are constantly selling out fast, with many sizes requiring pre-orders.
Our advice? Do your research. If you need a topper soon, check how long it takes for a potential mattress topper to be shipped to you. If buying it during Memorial Day means it won't arrive in time, buy now or look elsewhere.
Also, look up how often a mattress topper is on sale by using price-tracking tools such as Wayback Machine or Camel, Camel, Camel. Wayback Machine allows you to see snapshots of the brand's website during different times of the year, so you can see when a sale has been thrown before. Meanwhile, Camel, Camel, Camel allows you to track the prices of items on Amazon over the last 12 months.
