Every January, a familiar thought creeps into the minds of many: This is the year I finally write the novel.
If you’ve ever tried to follow through on that promise and thought about using AI to support your endeavor, you've probably started with tools like ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude. They’re great at brainstorming ideas, fixing awkward sentences or helping you push through writer’s block. But once you move past a few chapters, cracks start to show.
That’s the moment many writers realize: general-purpose chatbots can help you start a novel — but they’re not built to help you finish one.
That’s where purpose-built AI writing tools come in. I tested two of the most talked-about options for long-form fiction writers: Sudowrite and Novelcrafter. They both promise to help you write a book. They just do it in completely different ways. Here's why you shouldn't rely on general chatbots, what to expect from two AI creative writing tools and how they compare.
Why regular chatbots struggle with novel writing
General-purpose chatbots like ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude are incredibly useful — just not in the way novel writing actually demands. They’re designed for conversation, not continuity. That distinction matters more than most first-time novelists realize.
Chatbots are generally good at early-stage writing and outlining. They’re excellent at:
- Brainstorming plot ideas and character concepts
- Helping you rephrase awkward sentences
- Offering quick feedback on tone or pacing
- Talking through “what if” scenarios
- Nudging you past momentary writer’s block
If you’re staring at a blank page, they can feel magical. But anything more than an outline or first draft and things start to break down. Perhaps even worse, you might even be in the zone, breezing along because the problems usually don’t show up right away. But then, they'll emerge gradually — often after a few chapters — when your story becomes more complex.
That’s because regular chatbots struggle with:
- Long-term memory across chapters
- Consistent character arcs and motivations
- Tracking relationships, timelines and world rules
- Maintaining tone over tens of thousands of words
- Managing multiple plot threads at once
Sure, you could remind the AI what happened earlier — but the burden is always on you to restate, correct and course-correct. Unfortunately, this happens even when memory is enabled.
But a novel isn’t a collection of good paragraphs. It’s a system. Characters evolve, decisions have consequences, details introduced early are supposed to echo later. When an AI can’t reliably remember or reason over that accumulated context, the story starts to fray and untangle. That’s why so many writers hit the same wall and the story feels “off,” even if the prose is fine.
At that point, better prompting doesn’t fix the problem — the tool itself isn’t built for the job.
Why purpose-built tools exist
Sudowrite and Novelcrafter don’t replace human creativity. They support it differently. They’re designed around the core requirement chatbots lack: persistent story memory — whether that’s emotional continuity inside a scene or structural consistency across an entire book or series.
That’s the real shift writers need to understand going into 2026: Chatbots can help you start a novel, but they're definitely not designed to help you finish one. Sudowrite and Novelcrafter exist to solve that problem, but they approach it from opposite directions.
What Sudowrite does best
What I noticed right away about Sudowrite is that it feels like writing with an imaginative partner sitting beside you. You write a scene, highlight a paragraph or drop in a note, and Sudowrite responds with suggestions — richer descriptions, emotional beats, alternate phrasings or expanded passages. It’s designed to help you stay in the creative flow, not pull you out of it.
And, I want to stress this, it does not write for you, it writes with you. It makes suggestions, offers solutions when you're stuck trying to determine which direction to go and it offers feedback from a variety of perspectives.
Where Sudowrite shines:
- Expanding scenes without losing voice
- Adding sensory detail and emotion
- Helping with “show, don’t tell”
- Overcoming blank-page paralysis
- Making prose feel more alive
The experience is reactive and intuitive. You don’t need to map out your entire story upfront. Sudowrite works best when you already know roughly what happens next but need help writing it.
Who Sudowrite is for:
- Discovery writers and pantsers
- Writers who enjoy drafting but struggle with momentum
- Authors who want help inside scenes
- Anyone who wants AI to feel inspiring rather than mechanical
- Sudowrite doesn’t try to manage your novel. It helps you write better pages.
What Novelcrafter does best
I immediately noticed that Novelcrafter takes the opposite approach. It’s less concerned with lyrical prose and more focused on making sure your story actually holds together.
Instead of jumping straight into scenes, Novelcrafter encourages you to build the underlying framework of your book: characters, relationships, worldbuilding, plot beats and timelines. The AI then works within that structure.
Where Novelcrafter shines:
- Plot architecture and story logic
- Character bibles that persist across chapters
- Tracking motivations, relationships and continuity
- Planning long or complex novels
- Managing multi-book series
Novelcrafter feels more like a creative spreadsheet commanding the direction. It's not like a writing partner, but more of an assistant that helps you keep things in order.
There’s more setup involved, which might be a turnoff for creatives that want to just get started, but the payoff is control. Once everything is in place, the AI becomes remarkably consistent and reliable.
Using Novelcrafter helped me stay more organized than I've ever been while writing a novel. I'll be honest, I did not like setting everything up. But, it was a great exercise in patience and not jumping into a novel only to stop due to lack of momentum or disorganization later. It really set me up for success.
Who Novelcrafter is for:
- Plotters and planners
- Series writers
- Worldbuilders
- Writers who think in systems and outlines
- Anyone burned by continuity errors halfway through a draft
Novelcrafter helps you avoid breaking your story later. Here’s the simplest way to think about it: Sudowrite optimizes for language. Novelcrafter optimizes for structure.
That’s why Sudowrite often feels more magical out of the gate, while Novelcrafter can feel intimidating at first. One feeds creativity. The other enforces discipline. They suit very different writing styles, so the "best" one really depends on your personal preference.
Where ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude still fit
Even after testing both tools, I still use general-purpose chatbots — just not as my primary novel engine. They’re great for early brainstorming, research, testing alternative ideas and titles and getting unstock on specific problems.
But beyond that, they no longer carry the weight of a manuscript. You simply cannot rely on them for heavy-lifting. Think of ChatGPT-style tools as flexible assistants — and Sudowrite or Novelcrafter as your actual writing infrastructure.
Bottom line
Choose Sudowrite if you want help writing better scenes or if you struggle with momentum more than planning. You'll get more out of Sudowrite if you write intuitively and want AI to feel creative and collaborative.
Choose Novelcrafter if you’re writing a long or complex novel or are planning a series. If you want control over story logic and care deeply about continuity, you'll get more out of Novelcrafter.
The good news is, both are around $20/month (or even cheaper if you pay for a year) and you can cancel at anytime. And the honest truth? Some writers use both — drafting with Sudowrite, then switching to Novelcrafter once structure matters more than speed.
If you’re serious about writing a novel this year, AI can absolutely help — but only if you choose the right tool. Chatbots are great training wheels but Sudowrite and Novelcrafter are more like actual engines.
Follow Tom's Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds.
More from Tom's Guide
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.
