Club Benefits
As AI chatbots evolve at a breakneck pace, the tools built into them are advancing just as quickly.
Google Gemini users can now generate original music with Lyria 3 while ChatGPT offers an app store for seamless integrations. Both platforms — along with a growing list of AI competitors — can create images in seconds. Multimodal models like Gemini and ChatGPT turn simple photo prompts into stylized visuals so polished that some are nearly indistinguishable from artwork created by professional animators.
In a five-round showdown, I pitted ChatGPT-5.2 against Nano Banana 2 to see which tool delivers the most impressive images — and which one comes out on top.
1. A photorealistic portrait
Prompt: An ultra-realistic portrait of a woman standing in soft-golden hour light, shallow depth of field, 85mm lens, and detailed skin texture
ChatGPT-5.2 generated an image of a woman with model-like features, bathed in sunlight. The background wasn’t very prominent, however.
Nano Banana 2 generated an image of a woman standing in the middle of a nature trail, with sunlight illuminating her and the background littered with trees and grass.
Winner: Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 earns the nod here for making the background in its image more prominent while also doing a good job of focusing on natural and more human elements.
2. A cinematic landscape
Prompt: A sweeping cinematic landscape of New York City, captured at night, with dramatic backlighting and long shadows, a detailed foreground, shot with a wide-angle lens, ultra-high resolution, rich color grading, subtle film grain, and an epic, atmospheric mood
ChatGPT-5.2 produced an image reminiscent of a live-action rendition of Gotham City. I could totally envision Batman standing atop the roof of the building in the leftmost corner, gazing upon all the lit-up skyscrapers.
Nano Banana 2 produced an image that looks like a postcard for the “Big Apple.” The element of an elevated walkway, shadows emerging from multiple objects, a granite sidewalk, and a gorgeous evening landscape with all the bright buildings on full display. The one iffy element I spotted was the sun poking out from behind the clouds, even though it’s supposed to be nighttime.
Winner: ChatGPT-5.2
ChatGPT-5.2 notched ahead of the competition this time, as the image it created did two applause-worthy things: it showcased the evening outlook perfectly and properly highlighted all the elements I included in my prompt.
3. A store mockup with visible text
Prompt: A modern coffee shop storefront with a sign that reads ‘Sunnyside Brew’ in bold black letters
ChatGPT-5.2 cooked up an evening shot that showed the front of my custom coffee shop, with beautiful lighting set up inside its interior and the welcome addition of two tables set up on the outside.
Nano Banana 2 opted to set up its shot in the daytime, as the coffee shop sat in the middle of a sidewalk where people could be seen walking, and a man was spotted relaxing on a nearby bench. The inside of the shop features human activity, while the outside displays the aforementioned group, a menu sign, and parked bicycles.
Winner: Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 came out on top this time, thanks to its reliance on sunlight with realistic shadows and additional elements, such as actual people and accents you’d expect to see inside and outside a coffee shop. Nano Banana 2 brought the prompt to life in the best ways possible.
4. An anime character
Prompt: A dynamic male anime warrior mid-battle, holding his glowing red katana with dramatic lighting in a detailed cel-shaded style
ChatGPT-5.2 adopted a traditional anime-art style to create a pretty cool-looking animated fighter, who looked fearsome as he wielded his katana and prepared to land a decisive blow on his latest foe.
Nano Banana 2 surprised me by adopting the beloved Studio Ghibli anime style, which is prominently featured in classic anime films such as "Castle in the Sky," "Howl's Moving Castle," and "Princess Mononoke" (which happens to be my favorite). The katana-wielding warrior that appears here can be seen traversing a wrecked battlefield, with debris floating in the air and multicolored explosions going off around him.
Winner: Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 generated an image that ended up being a pleasant surprise, as it created an image that owes its inspiration to Studio Ghibli art. And what’s crazy is the fact that I didn’t even have to tell it to generate it in that style! The more profound landscape and action mayhem erupting around my anime sword master in this shot made him seem even more daring and easy to root for.
5. A concept art scene
Prompt: A floating city hanging above a bioluminescent ocean in the daytime with massive moons in the sky fashioned in a hyper-detailed sci-fi fantasy style
ChatGPT-5.2 gifted me with an image that wouldn’t look out of place on the front of those glossy planning books they handed out on the first day of junior high school. The floating city, strikingly blue ocean, and dual planets hanging in the background made this image pop. The extra element of water flowing out of different ports of the floating city is pretty cool, too.
Nano Banana 2 generated an image with similar elements, with a few key differences. The floating city appeared on its own instead of being fitted to a huge rock. Below it is a prominent shadow, which was a nice surprise to see. Two planets appear in the background as well, with the one on the right looking like a destination point for the spaceships that have taken flight.
Winner: Nano Banana 2
Nano Banana 2 impressed me with its use of shadows and spaceships flying around the floating city itself. Even though the clouds look better in the competition’s generated image, I still have to hand it to this pick since it looks that much better with all the extra activity happening in it.
Overall winner: Nano Banana 2
Both ChatGPT-5.2 and Nano Banana 2 generated some of the visually impressive images I’ve ever seen emanate from AI.
But in most cases, I’d prefer using Nano Banana 2’s images if I’m ever in the mood to produce store mockups, concept art for my wild sci-fi ideas and action shots of the anime avatars that come to mind.
Both image generators worked to produce my images in seconds, so I have no complaints with either one in the latency category. But Nano Banana 2 still ends up standing tall in this competition, thanks to its ability to include more background and foreground elements that make its images pop.
The improvements made to ChatGPT and Nano Banana that have helped them reach their current upgraded states are awesome — I can’t wait to see how much better their image generator functions become over time.
Follow Tom's Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds.
More from Tom’s Guide
- I tested ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude on the Iran strike — and one AI fed me fake news
- ChatGPT vs Claude: I put both default models through 7 real-world tests — one is the clear winner
- I've created thousands of AI images and these are the best AI image generators of 2026
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.
