Best mattress 2026: We spent 24,000 hours sleeping on 170+ beds to find the top-rated mattresses for every sleeper — here are our 8 winners
We tested 170+ mattresses for pressure relief, motion isolation, edge support, and temperature regulation to find this year’s best mattresses. Here’s what we recommend for side, back, and stomach sleepers, for hot sleepers, those with hip and back pain, and for every budget
Need help choosing a new mattress? We’ve got you. My team and I have tested over 170 mattresses (from hybrid and memory foam to innerspring and latex) to find the best mattresses of 2026.
Every mattress we review at Tom’s Guide goes through rigorous testing (read more about our mattress methodology) so that we can evaluate their performance in four key areas that most affect your sleep comfort:
- 1. Pressure relief: Using a 55lb weight, we measure how body weight is distributed across the lumbar, shoulders, and hips to relive pressure points.
- 2. Motion isolation: We drop a 15lb slam ball from standardized heights to measure how much movement the mattress transfers from one side to the other. Less movement means better motion isolation.
- 3. Edge support: We record how much compression (in inches) happens when we sit on the edge of the bed and place weights on it. Less compression means better edge support.
- 4. Temperature regulation: We track heat absorption and dissipation over 15-minute intervals using a thermal camera. The faster the dissipation, the cooler the mattress.
Only eight made the cut here – 162 did not – and five of our top picks are endorsed by the American Chiropractic Association. I’ve also slept on four of the beds in this guide and have true insight into who they do and don’t suit.
And yes, while we have mountains of test data to back up our recommendations, we know not everyone loves crunching numbers. That’s why we also sleep on each mattress for at least three weeks to give you a real-life understanding of what these beds are like, especially when shared with restless partners, wriggly kids, and pets.
Here’s what we’ve learned from all our testing: a good mattress doesn’t have to cost a fortune. While our top-rated mattress, the Saatva Classic, costs around $1,849 for a queen on sale, our second highest-ranking option, the DreamCloud, costs $699. I’ve slept on both, and while the Saatva is in a league of its own, the DreamCloud offers sturdy support for a lower price.
So whatever your budget, sleep needs, and body type, we’re confident from our testing that the mattresses in this guide will help you sleep better. Here's what my team and I recommend based on our latest round of testing and November 2026 ranking audit. Now is a great time to buy, because most of our top picks are discounted thanks to this year’s Black Friday mattress deals.
Feel: 3 to 8/10 (Plush, Luxury-firm, Firm) | Type: Innerspring hybrid | Height: 11.5” or 14.5” | Queen price: $1,804 (save $425 for Black Friday) | Our score: ★★★★★
The Saatva Classic is our highest-scoring mattress for best-in-class back support and customizable firmness and my personal fave. It’s also the four-time winner of the Tom’s Guide Mattress of The Year Award. In our lab the Saatva Classic delivered the best pressure relief and edge support, beating 169 other beds, making it ideal for couples with aches and pains. Free White Glove Delivery means you don’t have to lift a finger.
Feel: 6.5/10 (medium-firm) | Type: Innerspring hybrid | Height: 12” | Queen price: $699 (Up to 60% off each month) | Our score: ★★★★
DreamCloud’s breathable innerspring coil hybrid with a quilted foam-top looks and feels like a luxury hotel mattress at a fraction of the price ($699 for a queen). In our lab tests, the DreamCloud Classic Hybrid cushioned pressure points along our hips and shoulders, while isolating partner movement better than luxury cooling rival the Bear Elite Hybrid (number five).
Feel: 6/10 (medium) | Type: Zoned pocketed coil hybrid | Height: 13.5” | Queen price: $1,874 (25% off for Black Friday) | Our score: ★★★★
Designed with over 1,000 individual coils that deliver zoned support – it feels softer under the shoulders and firmer under the hips – the Midnight Luxe is excellent for ensuring a neutral spine position when side sleeping. It beat 168 other mattresses at pressure relief, coming in behind the Bear Elite Hybrid and the Saatva Classic. The Helix also eliminated heat spots in our temperature control test, making it safe for hot sleepers with hip pain.
Feel: 6.5/10 (Medium-Firm) | Type: Gel memory foam | Height: 12” | Queen price: $699 (up to 50% off) | Our score: ★★★½
The Nectar Classic is firmer than the Leesa Original (number six) and not as contouring, which is why Leesa is our best memory foam mattress and not Nectar. But for side and back sleepers, the Nectar is supportive enough to keep you on top of the mattress to prevent painful hammocking of your spine. Another good value pick at under $700 for a queen.
Feel: 6.5/10 (Medium-firm) | Type: Zoned coil hybrid | Height: 14”Queen price: $1,484 (35% off + free bedding) | Our score: ★★★★
Our highest-rated cooling mattress shed over 8°F of surface heat in under a minute during our thermal testing. Phase-change materials and copper-infused foam drive rapid heat dissipation, while a powerful combo of zoned coils and comfort foam bagged the Bear a 4.5 out of 5 pressure relief score. Edge support lets it down, so choose the Saatva Classic (number one) if you need a bed that’s easy to get in and out of.
Feel: 6/10 (medium) | Type: Memory foam | Height: 10” | Queen price: $999 (25% off for Black Friday) | Our score: ★★★★
New to our guide this November, the Leesa Original beat our previous top-scoring all-foam mattress, the Nectar Premier, in every critical lab test. It’s responsive and easy to move around on, with little motion transfer. The Leesa Original also outperformed all other foam mattresses we’ve lab-tested, scoring a 4.3 out of 5 for pressure relief.
Feel: 6.5/10 (medium-firm) | Type: Organic latex hybrid | Height: 10” | Queen price: $899 (up to 50% off every month) | Our score: ★★★★
Bouncier than the Leesa Original and cooler than the Nectar Classic, the Awara Classic Hybrid uses Rainforest Alliance-certified natural Dunlop latex to relieve painful pressure points across the back, shoulders and hips, and keep back and stomach sleepers lifted while they sleep. Organic wool and individually-wrapped pocket coils improve airflow, making it safe for hot sleepers.
Feel: 8/10 (Firm) | Type: Memory foam | Height: 10” | Queen price: $399 | Our score: ★★★★
The Siena Signature is a firm foam mattress with robust edge support – we measured just 3.06 inches of sinkage beneath a 25kg weight. For context, the Bear Elite Hybrid failed that same lab test. But while the Siena excels at support, it lacks cushioning, so we don’t recommend it to side sleepers. However if you’re a back or stomach sleeper looking for a cool and firm cheap foam bed, the Siena is our top pick.
How to choose the best mattress for you
When it comes to choosing the right mattress, I have two golden rules. Firstly, never choose a mattress based on sale price alone – instead, pick one that suits your sleeping position, body weight, and any health needs that affect your quality of sleep.
Secondly, only buy a mattress if it comes with a sleep trial – any good sleep brand offers a mattress trial of at least 60 nights because it takes around 30 nights for your body to get used to a new bed.
1. The best mattress overall in 2026
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Specifications
Reasons to buy
Reasons to avoid
The Saatva Classic is the highest-scoring mattress we've tested, and one of the comfiest beds I've slept on. We scored it 5 out of 5 in our pressure relief, temperature regulation, edge support and value for money tests and, plus a 4 out of 5 score for motion isolation (that's impressive for a bouncier hybrid). The hip and lower back pain that plagued me on other mattresses disappeared during my first night sleeping on the Saatva Classic, but it came back (to a lesser degree) when I started testing the Helix Midnight Luxe (number three).
Pressure relief: 5 out of 5
Temperature regulation: 5 out of 5
Motion isolation: 4 out of 5
Edge support: 5 out of 5
Value for money: 5 out of 5
The subjective feedback from our diverse testing panel backs up our lab data too: all of our testers found the Saatva Classic to be instantly comfortable, effective at melting away aches and pains, and for staying cool through the night. I'm a chronic hot sleeper and never overheated on the Saatva, but I did on the Midnight Luxe and the DreamCloud Classic.
The Saatva Classic also reduces pressure points for ache-free sleep, and has edge support so strong you could park a car on it. That's great news for bed-sharing families like mine who need to every inch of sleep space. So who don't we recommend it to? People who weigh over 300lbs – the Saatva's max weight capacity of 600lbs won't deliver the support you need. For everyone else, the Saatva Classic is our number one recommendation. We've also crowned it the best hybrid mattress of the year, plus our top mattress for couples.
- Read our Saatva Classic mattress review for full test data
2. The best value mattress
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Specifications
Reasons to buy
Reasons to avoid
The DreamCloud Classic Hybrid is the best value mattress you can buy this year. This 12" top-rated mattress in a box is designed with dual foam comfort layers, individually-wrapped coils, and a quilted top to provide good lower back support and full body pressure relief. It scored a 4 out of 5 in our pressure relief, temperature control, and edge support tests, and earned a 3.5 out of 5 score for motion isolation. That means it will do a decent job of helping you to sleep through the night if your partner only makes smaller movements next to you, but it might wake up if they are restless sleepers. I will say from personal experience that the DreamCloud is far easier to move around on compared to the Midnight Luxe.
Pressure relief: 4 out of 5
Temperature regulation: 4 out of 5
Motion isolation: 3.5 out of 5
Edge support: 4 out of 5
Value for money: 5 out of 5
We rate the feel as a 6/10 on the mattress firmness scale, which is the sweet spot for comfort versus support. The testers on our review panel preferred it for back and side sleeping, and we could see from our spinal alignment assessment that it kept our testers' hips lifted. However we question how much support it would deliver for stomach sleepers who weigh over 250lbs – the heavier tester on our team felt some 'hammocking' beneath her hips when stomach sleeping. A better choice for heavier stomach sleepers is the Siena Signature (number eight), but it's much firmer.
While the DreamCloud's CloudQuilt cover maintains a neutral sleep temperature, very hot sleepers may not find it effective enough for their needs. I overheated on the DreamCloud several times, and in our temperature regulation tests it had the slowest cooling rate out of our top five mattresses – 1.12 °F per minute. For comparison, the Bear Elite Hybrid (number five), our best cooling mattress for hot sleepers, had a rapid cooling rate of 1.82°F per minute. Overall, if you don't sleep very hot, mainly switch from side to back sleeping, and want a comfy queen mattress for under $700 where you can sleep right up to the edges, the DreamCloud Classic Hybrid is unbeatable.
- Read our DreamCloud Classic Hybrid Mattress review for full test data
3. The best mattress for side sleepers
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Specifications
Reasons to buy
Reasons to avoid
The Helix Midnight Luxe is the more premium version of the Helix Midnight and our best mattress for side sleepers. It's the third highest scoring mattress out of 170+ we've tested for pressure relief – the Saatva Classic (number one) scored a 5 out of 5, and the Bear Elite Hybrid (number five) scored a 4.6 out of 5 – and that's thanks to a densely cushioned pillow top followed by a layer of cradling foam to reduce pressure on your shoulders, hips and knees. I slept on the Helix Midnight Luxe for six months and found it extremely comfortable. However, I did find myself sinking in a little too much at my hips — personally, I personally prefer how the Saatva Classic gently contours my hips but keeps me on top of the mattress. But my colleague Nicola, who has a lighter body weight than me, loves the feeling of being enveloped by the Midnight Luxe.
Pressure relief: 4.5 out of 5
Temperature regulation: 4 out of 5
Motion isolation: 3.5 out of 5
Edge support: 4 out of 5
Value for money: 4 out of 5
This luxury mattress also features dedicated lumbar support via reinforced center coils, and we could see this support in action in our spinal alignment assessments. It's a good option for people with back and hip pain, especially if you upgrade to the optional ErgoAlign foam layer for additional lower back support like one of our testers Alison Barretta, who has scoliosis, did. But for chronic back and joint pain, we recommend the Saatva RX instead. The breathable Tencel cover kept us cozy, but we recommend upgrading to the GlacioTex cool-touch cover if you run very hot.
The plush pillow top didn't impact the sturdiness of the edges, but it did limit ease of movement for some of our testers including myself; my biggest annoyance with this mattress is how hard it is to move around on and switch positions. The other drawback is the price. Like the Satava Classic, the Midnight Luxe is over $1,800 for a queen, even with a 25% discount in the Helix Black Friday sale, and while we think it's worth the money, it's still an investment. The Sweetnight CoolNest is worth a look for much smaller budgets. Otherwise, if you want the best mattress for maximum side sleeper comfort, the Helix Midnight Luxe is our top pick.
- Read our Helix Midnight Luxe Mattress review for full test data
4. The best mattress for combi sleepers
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Specifications
Reasons to buy
Reasons to avoid
The Nectar Classic is the brand’s cheapest mattress and a Tom’s Guide Hall of Famer. It ranked highly in this guide for four years before we replaced it with the Nectar Premier, which scored higher in our lab tests. However, after retesting the updated Nectar Classic Memory Foam, we’ve reinstated it here as our best mattress for back sleepers—and a strong contender for combination sleepers who flip between their back and side at night. The Classic offers a high level of back support for a mid-range mattress and kept our tester’s spine aligned in both key sleep positions. Stomach sleepers searching for an all-foam mattress on a budget are better off choosing the Siena Signature 10” (number eight).
Pressure relief: 3 out of 5
Temperature regulation: 3.5 out of 5
Motion isolation: 3.5 out of 5
Edge support: 5 out of 5
Value for money: 4.5 out of 5
Considering a queen costs a third of the price of luxury rivals (the Classic costs around $699 in the Nectar mattress sale), it had the joint-best edge support score out of 170 mattresses we’ve tested, measuring 3.5 inches of compression at the foot of the bed and delivering 59.5 inches of usable sleeping space out of a total 60 inches in our roll-off test (Saatva delivered 60 inches of usable sleep space). But it doesn't sleep as cool as the Leesa Original (number six), and hung on to excess heat for a little longer in the lab (the Nectar shed 2.9°F of heat in the first minute while the Leesa shed 3.5°F).
The Nectar Classic performed much better in our motion isolation test, scoring a 4 out of 5 – the same score as our number one mattress, the Saatva Classic, and beating the DreamCloud Classic Hybrid (3.5 out of 5). Coupled with that best-in-class edge support lab score, we’re confident in recommending the Nectar Classic to couples and bed-sharing families who need a firmer, temperature-neutral mattress for healthy back sleeping.
However, there’s little give here—our 55lb weight barely sank during pressure relief tests. So don't buy the Nectar Classic if you’re a lightweight side sleeper or want a cozy, body-hugging bed; look at the Leesa Original (number six) or the Zinus Green Tea Memory Foam instead. Otherwise, if you're an average-weight back or combination sleeper wanting a supportive queen bed under $700, the Nectar Classic is tough to beat.
- Read our Nectar Classic mattress review for full test data
5. The best cooling mattress
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Specifications
Reasons to buy
Reasons to avoid
The Bear Elite Hybrid is the best cooling mattress we've tested. Like the Saatva Classic, it scored a best-in-class 5/5 in temperature control. But it's our best cooling bed overall because it has the fastest heat dissipation rate out of every mattress in this guide at 1.82°F per minute (the Saatva dissipated heat at a rate of 1.26°F/min, but it absorbed way less heat in the first place compared to the Bear with a Maximum Temperature Increase of just 6.3°F versus a 10.5°F MTI on the Bear).
Pressure relief: 4.6 out of 5
Temperature regulation: 5 out of 5
Motion isolation: 3.2 out of 5
Edge support: 2.5 out of 5
Value for money: 4 out of 5
The Celliant-infused cover that was once an optional upgrade now comes as standard. This specialist cover, along with the copper-infused comfort foam, enables the Bear to draw in heat then quickly release it for a neutral microclimate. It's the best mattress for hot sleepers and anyone dealing with night sweats and hot flashes. We tested the Bear Elite Hybrid in a medium firm (like the Saatva, it comes in three firmness options). Our panelists rated it as a 6/10 on the firmness scale, and found it well-balanced for every sleeping position. The high-density foams and zoned lumbar coils support and contour the body.
There's plenty of pressure relief — the Bear Elite Hybrid scored a 4.6 out of 5 in that category, second only to the Saatva Classic. However, it has the lowest edge support and motion isolation scores on the list, with a 2.5/5 and a 3.2/5, respectively. Our lead tester Eve has now been sleeping on the Bear Elite Hybrid for over a year and says that in real-life, the perimeter support is perfectly adequate, and she's rarely disturbed by her partner at night. If overheating at night is your biggest barrier to a good night's sleep, the Bear Elite Hybrid could be a game-changer for you.
- Read our Bear Elite Hybrid Mattress Review for full test data
6. Best memory foam mattress
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Specifications
Reasons to buy
Reasons to avoid
The Leesa Original claims our top memory foam spot this November by solving the biggest issue we’ve found with other all-foam beds: balancing deep pressure relief with good support and ease of movement. Redesigned with a 3lb slab of open-cell GreenFlex BioFoam (an eco-friendly alternative to memory foam), the Leesa is packed with responsive cushioning that bounces back fast when you change positions.
Pressure relief: 3.9 out of 5
Temperature regulation: 3.8 out of 5
Motion isolation: 3.6 out of 5
Edge support: 4.5 out of 5
Value for money: 3.8 out of 5
In our pressure relief test, the Leesa scored 3.9 out of 5, sinking 4.3 inches beneath our 55lb weight at the shoulder area and 4.1 inches at the hip/lumbar area. It offers more contouring sink than the Siena Signature (number eight) and the Nectar Classic (number four), feeling closer to the plush Nectar Premier (which scored 3.2 out of 5 in the same test)—except the Leesa responds faster than any of them and is easier to move around on. Edge support was the biggest surprise though—the Leesa Original scored 4.5 out of 5 in our test (thanks to an average sink of just 3.8 inches) and delivered a full 60 inches of usable sleep space from a queen size, just like the Saatva.
Overall temperature control is good, with the Leesa scoring 3.8 out of 5 in our thermal test. It gained 11.1°F at its hottest point (warmer than the Nectar Premier) before shedding 9.6°F over 15 minutes. So heat can pool beneath you unless you upgrade to Leesa’s Cooling Quilt Top Cover ($199). Our lead tester also noted there isn't enough cushioning around the knees for comfortable stomach sleeping, so we only recommend the Leesa Original to side and back sleepers—stick with the Siena Signature 10” if you're a stomach sleeper on a budget.
Like the Saatva, it only supports up to 300lbs per sleeper (600lbs total), so if you fall into a heavier bracket we recommend the Nectar Premier instead. The monthly Leesa mattress sale drops the Original down to $1,059, but for Black Friday you can expect a 25–30% discount with a queen down to 899-999.
- Read our Leesa Original mattress review for full test data
7. Best organic mattress
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Specifications
Reasons to buy
Reasons to avoid
Most certified organic mattresses from the likes of Avocado and Naturepedic cost around 1,900-2,200 for a queen, so the Awara Classic Hybrid is great value at $899. We tested the Awara at home for over three weeks and rate it highly for hot sleepers seeking a mattress that’s easy to move around on. The trade-off is that the Awara doesn’t isolate motion as well as the seven other mattresses in this guide, so we don’t recommend it to restless sleepers who share a bed. If you want a mattress made with a higher level of natural and organic materials that does isolate motion well, look at the Saatva Classic (number one) instead.
Pressure relief: 4 out of 5
Temperature regulation: 4.5 out of 5
Motion isolation: 3 out of 5
Edge support: 3.5 out of 5
Value for money: 4 out of 5
The combination of an organic cotton cover, natural New Zealand wool, open coils and Rainforest Alliance-certified Dunlop latex creates a fully breathable mattress that wicks away sweat and heat. It won’t actively cool like the Bear Elite Hybrid (number five), so pick that instead if you are dealing with night sweats and hot flashes. But for general hot sleepers, the Awara is plenty good enough. Latex is firmer than memory foam, so you’ll sleep on top of this mattress rather than sinking in.
We rate the Awara Classic as a medium-firm (a 6.5/10 on the mattress firmness scale). Your hips and spine will be lifted and aligned, and while we think it’ll be comfortable for back and stomach sleepers and average weight side sleepers, heavier bodies (over 230lbs) might not get the support they need to stay lifted. Consider the Helix Midnight Luxe (number three) instead if you want a softer mattress with good cushioning and cooling (the Sweetnight CoolNest is a good budget option) or the Avocado Green Mattress in Firm for good support for heavier bodies (weight capacity is 1,100lbs).
- Read our Awara Classic Hybrid mattress review for full test data
8. The best cheap mattress
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Specifications
Reasons to buy
Reasons to avoid
The Siena Signature punches above its budget price tag in many ways. In our lab tests, it scored 4.6/5 in motion isolation — the best of any mattress in this guide — and 4/5 in edge support, which is impressive for sub-$300 all-foam queen mattress. For those reasons and more, we think the Siena is the best affordable mattress-in-a-box you can buy. But if you're expecting the soft hug of memory foam, you won't get it here (try the Leesa Original instead).
Pressure relief: 3.8 out of 5
Temperature regulation: 3.3 out of 5
Motion isolation: 4.6 out of 5
Edge support: 4 out of 5
Value for money: 4 out of 5
Our testing panel rate it an 8 out of 10 on our firmness scale. Lead tester Ruth says she finds it second only to the Plank Firm mattress (also tested) as the firmest bed she's tried, but the subtle pressure relief of the Siena prevents it from feeling rock solid. It's a top affordable choice for back and stomach sleepers, but side sleepers will find it too unyielding at their shoulders and hips.
The consistent edge-to-edge support, combined with minimal motion transfer, makes it one of the best affordable mattresses for couples. (It's even available as a split king, which is an unusual but welcome choice for a budget bed.) Our lab tests revealed that the Siena warms up quickly, but it sheds that heat almost just as fast. Our testers didn't wake up sweaty on the Siena, as they have with other cheap foam mattresses. The Siena is the best bed you'll find for temperature regulation in this price class; it even rivalled the Bear Elite Cooling Hybrid (number five) in our temperature regulation test. With a queen costing under $400, you can't go wrong here.
- Read our Siena Signature Mattress Review for full test data
Our top 8 mattresses of 2026 compared (at a glance)
Mattress |
Best for |
Why we rate it |
Queen price |
1. Saatva Classic Innerspring Hybrid |
All sleep positions, bed-sharing, hot sleepers, back pain. |
Best-in-class pressure relief, spinal alignment, edge support and cooling |
$1,804 (was $2,229) in the Black Friday sales with $425 off. [ View at Saatva ] |
2. DreamCloud Classic Hybrid |
Couples on a budget wanting a good all-rounder mattress. |
Luxury hotel feel and deep pressure relief for under $700 |
$699 (was $1,540) with up to 60% off every month. [ View at DreamCloud ] |
3. Helix Midnight Luxe Hybrid |
Side sleepers of all body weights with hip or shoulder pain. |
Zoned design cushions shoulders while hips are lifted. |
$1,874 (was $2,498) with 25% off for Black Friday. [ View at Helix ] |
4. Nectar Classic Memory Foam |
Combi sleepers and bed-sharers wanting a firm foam bed with robust edge support. |
Supportive firm foam prevents spinal 'hammocking' for better sleep posture. |
$699 (was $1,567) with up to 50% off every month. [ View at Nectar ] |
5. Bear Elite Hybrid |
All hot sleepers, including people with night-sweats and hot flashes. |
Shed over 8°F+ in the first minute in our cooling test. Wicks sweat too. |
$1,670 (was $2,570) with 35% off, plus free bedding, for Black Friday. [ View at Bear ] |
6. Leesa Original |
Side and back sleepers seeking a contouring me yet responsive memory foam mattress. |
Excellent balance of deep pressure relief and support versus ease of movement. |
$999 ($1,332) with 25%. We predict this will increase to 30% off for Black Friday. [ View at Leesa ] |
7. Awara Classic Hybrid |
Eco-conscious sleepers seeking a natural alternative to memory foam. |
Bouncy, breathable and fast to relieve pressure points in every sleep position. |
$899 (was $1,411) thanks to a 50% off sale each month. [ View at Awara ] |
8. Siena 10” Signature |
Stomach sleepers and bed sharing families wanting a firm queen bed under $400. |
Supportive foam with sturdy edges (we measured just 3.06” sinkage). |
$399, but no Black Friday deal yet. [ View at Siena ] |
Also tested and recommended
Bear Original Mattress ★★★★
This great value medium-firm memory foam mattress has a comfortable contouring feel to relieve pressure points in all sleeping positions. It's beaten by the Cocoon by Sealy Chill Memory Foam (number seven) for temperature regulation. From $462 at Bear Mattress.
▶ Read more: Bear Original Mattress review
The WinkBed ★★★★
A good alternative to the Saatva Classic for stomach and back sleepers needing a very firm surface and one that keeps their bodies on top of the mattress to prevent their spine from dipping out of alignment. Also a good more affordable alternative to the Saatva RX for back pain. From $999 at WinkBeds.
▶ Read our WinkBed mattress review
Cocoon by Sealy Chill Memory Foam ★★★★
Proper cooling mattresses normally cost thousands of dollars, but the Cocoon by Sealy Chill Memory Foam bucks that trend by costing just $597 for a queen. It isn’t the best cooling mattress we’ve tested – hot sleepers will struggle on it – but it is a good option under $600 for a queen. From $349 at Cocoon by Sealy.
▶ Read more: Cocoon by Sealy Chill Memory Foam Mattress review
DreamCloud Ultra Hybrid ★★★
If you want an extra tall mattress (15 inches) for couples that has a marshmallowy soft feel, the DreamCloud Ultra Hybrid is worth a look. We found it hard to mov around on though, so give it a swerve if you need a more responsive bed that's easy to get in and out of. From $1,299 at DreamCloud Sleep.
▶ Read more: DreamCloud Ultra Hybrid mattress review
How we test mattresses
Buying a mattress is a big decision — not just for your wallet, but your health too. Our expert team has been testing mattresses for half a decade, and we've just launched our brand-new mattress methodology comprising seven robust data-led lab tests, plus extensive value for money analysis.
Here's a breakdown of our new approach to testing mattresses at Tom's Guide, and the five most critical areas we test and analyze:
1. Pressure relief (Comfort and support)
Why you can trust Tom's Guide
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Why it matters: This is a top reason for most mattress purchases. Although it’s somewhat subjective, an ideal mattress cushions pressure points (particularly at the hips and shoulders) while maintaining healthy spinal alignment. Without that balance, you'll start to develop aches and pains.
How we test: We use a 25kg (55lb) weight to simulate the body's heaviest touch points across multiple areas to measure indentation depth (how much the surface sinks after five minutes) and recovery time (how long it takes for the mattress to snap back into place). This allows us to assess how a mattress reacts when weight is put on it. We also use a laser level and a tripod to observe a tester's alignment when side sleeping.
How we score: Indentation depth makes up 60% of our pressure relief (comfort and support) score, as the right balance is key to preventing pain. Mattresses receive a higher score for faster recovery times; anything over eight seconds is considered slow-moving (and therefore difficult to move around on).
2. Temperature regulation
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Why it matters: Overheating disrupts sleep. The best mattresses dissipate heat and promote a neutral (or comfortable) temperature for an individual.
How we test: Using a medical-grade thermal imaging camera, we measure passive cooling (how much heat the mattress absorbs while our tester lies on it) and active cooling (how quickly it releases that heat once our tester gets up).
How we score: We combine the results of our passive and active cooling tests. Mattresses with minimal heat retention receive higher marks.
3. Motion isolation
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Why it matters: Couples and families who share a bed with kids or pets need a mattress that prevents movement from transferring.
How we test: We drop a weighted ball next to a sensitive scientific accelerometer to simulate a partner shifting in bed, measuring the initial impact absorption and the motion-damping speed.
How we score: Our motion isolation score is weighted 60/40 initial impact absorption to motion-dampening speed. The most important thing we look for is how well a mattress prevents motion from reverberating across the surface.
4. Edge support
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Why it matters: Strong edges allow couples to maximize every inch of their sleep surface, give sleepers with mobility issues a steady surface to push off from, and indicate how durable a mattress will be over time.
How we test: To measure sitting stability, we place a 25kg (55lb) weight on the middle perimeter of the mattress and measure the vertical sinkage after five minutes. As for sleeping security, our testers lie on the mattress and note (in inches) how far from the edge they feel most secure.
How we score: Sitting stability makes up 60% of our edge support score, with higher marks for lower sinkage. Sleep security makes up the remainder, with mattresses providing consistent edge-to-edge support receiving a perfect grade.
5. Value for money
Knowing you're getting a good mattress at a good price is important, so we've developed a new scoring rubric to give each mattress we test a rating out of 5 for value for money.
To create an overall value for money score, we consider the build quality of a mattress, and the quality of the materials. The better the quality, the higher the score, because these two factors indicate the likelihood of durability and longevity. In other words, how long we expect this mattress to last – a critical consideration when assessing value for money.
We also factor in the performance of the mattress in our lab tests versus price, plus the benefits (sleep trial, mattress warranty, and level of shipping) you get with the mattress.
Here's how our Top 5 mattresses score in terms of value for money:
- Saatva Classic – 5 out of 5
- DreamCloud Classic – 5 out of 5
- Siena Signature – 4 out of 5
- Nectar Premier – 4 out of 5
- Bear Elite Hybrid – 4 out of 5
- Longevity and assurance (35%): Encompasses the length of the mattress warranty and sleep trial.
- Build quality and materials (30%), Accounts for materials, construction, and country of origin.
- Price competitiveness (25%): Regards how a mattress is priced against direct competitors, using queen-size as a benchmark.
- Brand consensus and user rating (10%): Based on verified customer ratings and overall brand reputation.
How we measure subjective feedback
At the end of the day, we're humans sleeping on these mattresses, not inanimate objects. Our diverse group of testers lie on a mattress in all positions (side, back, and stomach) and make note of any pressure buildup (or relief) in their touchpoints.
Sensory feel and performance: This relates to how cool or warm a mattress feels to our testers upon first contact and after extended use.
Partner disturbance assessment: One tester gets in and out of bed and shifts positions while another tester lies still and measures the level of perceived disturbance for light sleepers.
Sit and sleep assessment: Our testers sit on the edge of the mattress to assess security and stability, then lie near the perimeter to gauge whether or not they'll roll off the bed.
How we score mattresses
The final rating a mattress receives is the sum of its performance across all five categories (a maximum score out of 25). For example, a final score of 23 or more culminates in a 5-star rating, while a score of 18-22 earns a 4-star rating.
Meet the testing team
We constantly have a wide selection of mattresses in on review to make sure our rankings are up-to-date — the entire Tom's Guide Sleep team gets involved. Here’s who tested the mattresses in the most recent version of this guide:
I’ve been reviewing mattresses and sleep products for more than five years, and led the development of our brand-new testing methodology. Of our top-ranked mattresses, I’ve slept on both the Saatva Classic and DreamCloud Classic, and oversaw the testing of all five in our Sleep Lab. I’m extremely excited to bring you the latest version of this guide: it’s backed by more data than ever before, which makes it easier than ever to recommend these brilliant mattresses.
Nicola has been on Tom’s Guide sleep desk for two years, during which time she’s helped review some of the best mattresses for back pain and side sleepers. She joined the testing panel for the Saatva Classic, Bear Elite Hybrid and Siena Signature.
Ruth joined the Tom’s Guide Sleep team nearly two years ago and has slept on the Siena, Nectar Premier and Zinus Green Tea mattresses here (among many others) — she’s something of a memory foam expert. She also joined the Saatva, DreamCloud and Bear Elite testing panels, getting hands-on with all our best mattresses and contributing to their final scores.
Our resident hybrid mattress expert, Frances has been reviewing mattresses and toppers for more than two years. She sat on the testing panel for the Saatva Classic, Siena Signature and Nectar Premier mattresses in this guide
Claire is a Certified Sleep Science Coach, the Managing Editor of Sleep at Tom's Guide, and a senior health journalist with over 16 years product review experience. Claire oversees our rigorous mattress testing procedures and our sleep buying guides. She is connected to a wealth of globally renowned sleep experts including mattress designers, neuroscientists, and board-certified doctors. Claire is certified to advise people on how to choose products that suit their individual sleep needs, and to help them create a nighttime routine and bedroom environment for better sleep. Previously, Claire worked at T3 and TechRadar, testing the latest wellness products and sleep tech.











