Best Smart Speakers 2018

Product Use case Rating
Amazon Echo (2nd Gen) Best Overall Smart Speaker 4
Amazon Echo Dot (3rd gen) Best Value Smart Speaker 5
Sonos One Best Sounding Smart Speaker 4
Lenovo Smart Display Best Smart Speaker with Display 4
JBL Link 20 Best Portable Smart Speaker 4.5

There's a good chance that your first smart home device will be a smart speaker. For one, it works just fine as a way to play music from your smartphone or the cloud. But if you start talking to it, the speaker will respond to your commands. It can do things like look up the weather and sports scores, turn on your coffee maker, read you a book or even change the channel on your TV.

Tom's Guide reviews dozens of smart speakers each year, of all shapes, sizes, and price points. Our favorite smart speaker is the second-generation Amazon Echo ($99). While we initially were disappointed in its sound quality, Amazon released a firmware update which greatly improved the listening experience. This all-new Echo is also smaller, more attractive, and less expensive than the original. Our budget pick is the 3rd-gen Echo Dot, which costs just $50. Both of these picks use Amazon's voice assistant, Alexa. Google Home, is worth considering for its price and compatibility with Google's services, and now there's a $50 version—the Google Home Mini.

Latest News and Updates (November 2018)

  • Facebook's first two smart displays, The Portal ($199) and the Portal Plus ($349), are now available for purchase through Amazon, Best Buy, and Facebook's online store. The displays are focused on video chats using Facebook Messenger, and have an AI that lets the camera automatically pans and zoom in on its subjects.
  • Sonos has announced that Alexa can now stream the 24-hour radio service Red Bull Radio on the Sonos One. To enable it, go to "Add Music Services" in the Sonos Controller app and select Red Bull Radio.
  • Although the company initially promised it in 2018, Sonos announced that its Sonos One speaker won't get Google Assistant until some point in the future. The company said it will provide an update in early 2019.
  • We reviewed the new $149 Google Home Hub, which we found to be a cheaper, simpler alternative to devices such as the Amazon Echo Show, even if it's relatively limited in functionality.
  • We've reviewed the new third-generation Amazon Echo Dot and the second-generation Echo Show; both look much more stylish than previous models, and have some other great improvements, such as better audio in the Dot, and a larger and sharper screen in the Show.

The second-generation Amazon Echo is smaller and more stylish than the original, and its outer skin can be swapped out for different colors and textures. An improvement to its firmware made this speaker sound as good as the original; if you're looking for a good all-purpose smart speaker, this is it.

The third-generation Echo Dot has vastly improved sound over the previous generation and, with a fresh, cloth-covered design, looks better too. Like before the Dot has both Bluetooth and a 3.5mm jack, so you can connect it to a better-sounding speaker. The Dot is ideal for places where you want Alexa, such as a kitchen, but don't want another large device cluttering the space. And, at $50, it's the same price as the last model.

The Sonos One is based on the Play:One, but has Alexa built in, as well as six microphones to pick up your voice. It produced the best audio we've yet heard from an Alexa-powered speaker, and, like other Sonos devices, you can pair two of the Ones for true stereo sound, or link them with other Sonos speakers for whole-home audio. Plus, it also works with streaming services such as Spotify and Red Bull Radio. Yes, you'll pay more, but the sound quality is worth it.

The first smart display to feature Google Assistant, the Lenovo Smart Display is an improvement on Amazon's original Echo Show in a number of ways. Lenovo's device looks better, has a bigger and sharper screen, and even a privacy shutter for the camera. But, you can do more with Google Assistant on the Smart Display than you can with Alexa on the Echo Show. For instance, looking up and using recipes, timers, and smart home devices is much easier on the Smart Display. Lenovo is selling the Smart Display in both 8-inch ($199) and 10-inch ($249) sizes.

One problem with most smart speakers is that they need to be plugged in for them to work. The battery-powered JBL Link 20 takes care of that limitation: we found that it will last at least 10 hours on a charge. Its audio quality is great, too, for those times you want to extend Google Assistant's reach to your backyard. The Link 20 is also water-resistant: You can dunk it for up to 30 minutes.

The Google Home speaker is more attractive, and sounds better than, the Echo. Take your pick from six colors and two finishes for the base (fabric or metal). At $129, it's also cheaper than the Echo. Plus, you can use Google Home to control Chromecast-enabled devices, such as TVs. Alexa can't do that. However, in a face-off between the two assistants, we found Amazon's to be more well-rounded than Google's.

Other Smart Speakers We Tested

The Apple HomePod ($349 on Apple) (7/10), Apple's first smart speaker sounds amazing, thanks to an array of speakers and beam-forming tech that automatically adjusts its audio properties based on the room in which the speaker is placed. However, Siri's smarts lag behind both Alexa and Google Assistant, and we don't like that if you want to use Siri to ask for tunes, you have to use Apple Music. Read our full review of the Homepod.

We were pleasantly surprised by the quality of audio from the Harman Kardon Invoke ($99.99 on Harman Kardon) (6/1), but Cortana's smart home skills are far behind those of Alexa, Siri, and Google Assistant. Read our full review of the Invoke.

Speakers with Amazon Alexa

The Amazon Echo Plus ($149.99 on Amazon) (7/10) looks and sounds much like the original Echo, but has a built-in Zigbee radio, so it can act as a smart home hub. However, the smart home automation you can enable through Alexa is fairly limited at this point. Read our full review of the Echo Plus. A second-generation Echo Plus is on the way, which has a better design, and the ability to control some smart home devices when your Internet goes down.

The Amazon Echo Spot ($129.99 on Amazon) (7/10) is a more compact alternative to the touchscreen Echo Show, which makes its great for nightstands. But its small, circular display makes watching videos cumbersome, and the Show’s dual speakers provide a better sound. Read our full review of the Amazon Echo Spot.

At about $30, the Eufy Genie ($34.99 on Amazon) (7/10) is a good budget alternative to the already inexpensive Echo Dot. With a single 2-watt down-firing speaker, the Genie offers better audio than the Dot, but lacks Bluetooth, so if you want to connect an additional speaker, you'll have to use the included 3.5mm audio cable. Read our full review of the Genie.

The Alexa-enabled Fabriq ($49.99 on Amazon) (7/10) speaker comes in a variety of colorful skins, and lasted about 5 hours on a charge. It also has pretty good bass for such a small speaker. However, you have to press a button on the speaker before you can use Alexa; its treble is thin; and it's not waterproof. Read our full review of the Fabriq.

If you already own an Echo Dot, the Vaux ($49.95 on Amazon) (8/10) could be for you. You slip the Dot into the Vaux to turn Amazon's device into a better-sounding, portable speaker. That's because the Vaux has a battery that will power the Dot for up to 6 hours, and the speakers are loud, with crisp treble. Read our full review of the Vaux.

The UE Megablast ($299.99 on Amazon) (8/10) is waterproof, unlike the Echo and Sonos One, and produces better all-around sound than Amazon’s speakers do. But it can’t access all the unique talents of Alexa (for example, it can’t stream from Spotify or integrate with multi-room audio). Read our full review of the UE Megablast.

Speakers with Google Assistant

The Onkyo Smart Speaker G3 ($99.00 on B&H Video) (9/10) sounds fantastic, is relatively small and competitively priced for its performance. However, you can't use it to make calls with Google Assistant. Read our full review of the Onkyo G3.

The Google Home Mini ($49 on Best Buy) (8/10), Google's competitor to the Echo Dot, sounds far superior to Amazon's mini-sized Alexa speaker. And, it will connect to other Chromecast devices. The fabric top of the Home Mini is certainly more attractive than the hockey-puck Echo Dot, and comes three colors: Black, Gray, and Coral (pink). Read our full review of the Google Home Mini.

The Google Home Hub (7/10) is a compact, intuitive smart display companion that works well with apps like YouTube and Google Photos while letting you easily manage any smart device in your home. However, the Home Hub's dual speakers are seriously lacking bass. Read our full review of the Google Home Hub.

The super-sized Google Home Max ($399 on Google) (7/10) kicks out an impressive amount of sound, and you can also pair two of these together for fuller stereo sound. Still you get just as good performance from two Sonos Ones as you do from one Google Home Max. Read our full review of the Google Home Max.

Unlike most other smart speakers, the Sony LF-S50G Smart Speaker ($199.99 on Best Buy) (7/10) has a display on the front that shows the time and volume. This speaker is splash-resistant and sounds good, too. It can also be controlled using gestures, but we found they didn't work well. Read our full review of the Sony LF-S50G. Read our full review of the Sony LF-S50G.

JBL Link 300 ($249.99 on Best Buy) (7/10): This smart speaker also pumps out a ton of sound, and has great bass. However, its treble tones are lacking, and like most third-party speakers, can't make phone calls with Google Assistant. Read our full review of the Link 300.

The even larger—and pricier JBL Link 500 ($299.95 on Amazon) (7/10) has an even wider sound field, but we found bass was lacking unless the volume was turned up. Read our full review of the Link 500.

The Zolo Mojo ($79.99 on Zolo) (5/10) is compact, responsive, and relatively easy to set up. However, its sound quality is average at best, and it’s not worth the extra cost. Read our full review of the Zolo Mojo.

What to Look For When Buying a Smart Speaker

Before you purchase a smart speaker, decide how you plan to use it. If it's going to be the only device in your living room that will play music, then you'll want one that has good audio quality. But while sound is important, it shouldn't necessarily be the deciding factor in which smart speaker you choose. For example, the Amazon Echo Dot has perhaps the worst-sounding speaker among those we've tested, but its small size and low price make it useful for people who already have a good speaker and merely want to add some smarts to it. The Dot is also a cheap way to spread a voice assistant throughout your house.

If you want a speaker that you can take outdoors, though, you'll want to consider a portable option, such as the Amazon Tap (pictured above), or a third-party speaker, such as the Fabriq.

Create a new thread in the Audio forum about this subject
Comment from the forums
    Your comment
  • s.oliver.daniel
    This is not a comment. I would just like to know whether I would get total stereo sound from these "single" speakers if I place one of them in front of a PC monitor placed right in front me?
  • eric.cazin
    Hi guys,

    The SONT LF-S50G is missing in your list.

  • jbukow
    Check out the insignia google voice speakers from Best Buy, normally I don't recommend store brands but these are stereo 2.0 or stereo+subwoofer 2.1 portable speakers with battery, obviously support Google Voice Assistant, they sound really good and can hear you really well when music is playing, and are in the $70-$110 range.
  • itsjoecool
    Im trying to help my mom, who recently had a stroke. She is having trouble with spelling and math. Which of these devices would be the best at helping her spell words and do math?
  • gditrecruiter

    I just read an article that said Google Home is better. The rationale was that Google's algorithm is superior to Bing, which Amazon's products utilize for commands. I must admit when searching on the web, I always find Google blows Bing out of the water...

    I think this is especially relevant for you/your mom. My mother, now deceased, had similar type of issues due to stroke. I know that the Google product would have suited her better.

    An example they mentioned about Bing was you have to construct the question a particular way, whereas Google's commands you didn't really need to do that as much. For someone with a stroke, you want it to be as simple as can be.....

    Wish you and your mom the best whatever you choose!

  • speakerfreak
    KitSound Voice One?
  • murraysandes
    Do you think google will get around to updating software in google home and google home mini to include latency delay ability. Both my google home minis receive and produce audio quicker than my other powered speakers retro fitted with chrome cast audio meaning I can't use my google home mini as part of an audio group..very frustrating
  • mdr1000ton
    You forget the Harman Kardon Invoke with cortana. A very good sounding speaker, better than most of the others, and a good price. Not too expensive and for the hardware it wort it.
  • murraysandes
    Anonymous said:
    You forget the Harman Kardon Invoke with cortana. A very good sounding speaker, better than most of the others, and a good price. Not too expensive and for the hardware it wort it.

    So what does that have to do with the google,Home lack of latency issue
  • speakerfreak
    murraysandes - have you tried doing the steps as outlined here?
  • murraysandes
    Hi speakerfreak, thanks for responding. Your link outlines the directions to correct speaker delay for chrome cast audio disc that is plugged into the 3.5 mm audio input of an existing powered speaker or hometheatre amp. And yes this allows to slow the speaker response how ever the issue is for the google home and google home mini where the chrome cast audio is built in to the unit. When sending for example Spotify music to it through wifi, there is less circutery for the signal to travel and so it plays the music more instantly than say a hometheatre unit that has an external chrome cast audio disc plugged into the 3.5mm input. Both the google home or google home mini speaker does not have built into its software an ability to slow the signal to match in my case the signal coming from hometheatre unit. Hope this makes sense
  • madtestengineer1
    amazon echo 2 as the best overall is kinda misleading. It does sound better then Gen1 but it still not much better then a low/mid level bluetooth speaker. A lot of the mid level JBL bluetooth speakers sound better then the echo 2. That is why the echo dot is the best selling echo. Everyone knows the sound is lacking. But people plug it into much better sounding speakers.

    As an overall best smart speaker, it should be a speaker first then the smart second. It really better as the best smart-smart speaker. Not the overall best smart speaker.
  • rsklein
    This article makes a direct comparison between a pair of Sonos Ones and a single Google Home Max. While this may be fair from a strictly price comparison, it doesn't answer the question many people face: How do a pair of Google Home Max compare with a pair of Sonos Ones? I'm guessing that the Google Home Max pair wins hands down, but guessing isn't hearing. I'd be interested in hearing from anybody who has had the opportunity to make this comparison.
  • lazworld
    Anonymous said:
    This is not a comment. I would just like to know whether I would get total stereo sound from these "single" speakers if I place one of them in front of a PC monitor placed right in front me?
  • lazworld
    I'm afraid not. You will not get total stereo sound from these single speakers. The JBL has a solution to this but you need to have a pair where each speaker will be designated to carry either the L or the R signal which I find very useful.