Dear Nespresso machines, this is an apology — from a coffee snob and ex-barista

a closeup photo of a coffee being made on the nespresso pixie
(Image credit: Tom's Guide)

Nespresso and Keurig machines do what the best espresso machines cannot: take all the guesswork out of your daily brew.

As a former barista and a self-professed coffee snob, I'm the ideal candidate for a fancy, confusing, temperamental espresso machine. I love dialing in fresh beans, adjusting the grind one micron at a time to get my perfect shot. I love steaming milk by hand, creating a mesmerizing eddy within my milk jug. I love sipping the golden crema of a perfect, honey-colored espresso, savoring the fruits of my labor.

Nespresso Pixie
Nespresso Pixie: $183 at Amazon

This is the model that was in my Airbnb. Ergo, the model that altered my worldview. It's so easy to use — you literally slot the pod in the top, press the handle down, select small or large, and you're good to go. On top of that, it's super small, and I found it really easy to clean. I'm sold.

Nes-press-go

Nespresso Pixie on kitchen counter

(Image credit: Tom's Guide)

The beauty of a pod machine is its simplicity. You can go from no coffee to full-cup-coffee in literally fifteen seconds. You can't say the same of an espresso machine.

Of course, espresso and Nespresso/Keurig are completely different brewing mediums, and I'm not saying I would ever replace my Breville Bambino Plus and Comandante C40 MK4 grinder with a Nespresso machine.

I am, however, saying that I shouldn't have been so harsh on Nespresso machines. True, their coffee isn't "technically" espresso, but that's fine. They're not supposed to be real, Italian, coffee-snob-pleasing espresso machines.

Nespresso Pixie on kitchen counter

(Image credit: Tom's Guide)

Even so, the coffee didn't even taste bad. I bought super-cheap pods, and, yes, while the coffee was a little weak, there was no bitterness or burned notes. Every espresso was rich, flavorful, without those nasty scorched flavors you expect from diner drip coffee.

A Nespresso machine is pure convenience. They're the perfect coffee machine for hotels, Airbnbs, and vacation rentals.

When you're on vacation, you want to get out of the hotel and start exploring, right? So why would you want to spent fifteen minutes dosing, grinding, and pulling espresso, when you could just spend fifteen seconds preparing a pod coffee?

Again — fellow coffee snobs, please don't come at me. I know Nespresso/Keurig isn't "real" espresso. If you're that addicted to the grind (pun intended) that you're willing to sacrifice precious vacation time to make specialty espresso every morning, be my guest. But when I'm on vacation, I'm in vacation mode. I want to be at my first museum of the day at 9:00am sharp — if that means I have to sacrifice a barista-quality flat white, then so be it.

So, Nespresso/Keurig: I'm sorry. I'm sorry I said you were trash and nasty and only for people who don't like coffee. I take it back. You are perfect for vacations.

But pods will never replace good ol' espresso machines

the breville bambino plus / sage bambino plus in stainless steel silver photographed against a blue background shown with its accessories including milk jug, tamper, portafilter, and shown in use extracting espresso

(Image credit: Tom's Guide)

Despite how easy and convenient Nespresso/Keurig machines are, I'll never give up my Breville Bambino Plus in favor of the pod.

For starters, pods are inherently wasteful, even though many of them can be recycled these days. U.K.-only brand Grind makes compostable Nespresso-compatible pods, so these would be my first choice if I were to get a Nespresso machine, but the pods are still being made in the first place, which kind of contradicts their "cyclical" nature. The most sustainable thing of all is straight-up not consuming coffee — think of the air miles! — but, obviously, that's not going to happen. As a result, buying Fairtrade, ethically sourced, small-farm beans with recyclable packaging is the way forward, without the need for processing and pod factories in the mix.

a photo of a latte made on the breville bambino / sage bambino

(Image credit: Erin Bashford)

Secondly, I'm a coffee snob. What can I say? I love watching my espresso pour like honey. I love weighing my beans using my Wacaco Exagram Pro, one of the best coffee scales. I love choosing my small-batch roasted beans from my local snooty coffee house. It's all part of the lifestyle, right?

So, even though I had a wonderful time using the Nespresso machine in the Airbnb, I don't see myself purchasing one any time soon. But I emerge from my vacation a changed woman — one who is much more open-minded and tolerant of the world of pod coffee.


Google News

Follow Tom's Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds.


More from Tom's Guide

TOPICS
Erin Bashford
Senior Writer, Reviews

Erin Bashford is a senior writer at Tom's Guide, focusing on reviews. She has a Masters in Broadcast and Digital Journalism from the University of East Anglia. As an ex-barista, she knows her way around a coffee machine, and as a music lover, she's constantly chipping away at her dream of having a multi-room home sound system. In her spare time you can find her reading, practising yoga, writing, or stressing over today’s NYT Games.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.