I walked 5,000 steps with the Apple Watch 11 vs Garmin Venu X1 — and there's a clear winner

Which premium, square-shaped smartwatch is best, the Apple Watch 11 or the Garmin Venu X1? When it comes to fitness tracking performance, I tested the two head-to-head to find out.

Both of these devices are new for 2025 and sport generously-sized and easy-to-read displays, advanced health tracking and fitness training tools, sleek and stylish cases, useful safety tools, and hefty price tags.

Fortunately, they are also each on sale for Black Friday, with the Garmin Venu X1 reduced by $200 and the Apple Watch 11 discounted by $50. Find details on these deals below, followed by the biggest differences between the Series 11 and Vanu X1, and finally, the results of my 5,000-step walk test, with a winner declared at the very end.

Apple Watch Series 11: was $399 now $349 at Amazon

The Apple Watch 11 is a refinement of last year's Series 10, with even better battery life (24 hours per charge), hypertension alerts, a daily sleep score metric, and a tougher protective glass screen. It's also sleek, easy-to-navigate, and brimming with smart features, safety tools, and wellness insights.

View Deal

Garmin Venu X1: was $799 now $599 at Garmin

The Garmin Venu X1 is one of the brand's latest high-end smartwatches, sporting the largest screen of any Garmin wearable to date, along with the thinnest case design. Like the Apple Watch 11, it offers plenty of workout and wellness tools, along with safety features and some smart features.

View Deal

Apple Watch 11 vs Garmin Venu X1: Key differences

While the Apple Series Watch 11 and Garmin Venu X1 look similar enough — large, sleek, square-shaped devices with minimal bezels, a pair of physical controls, and numerous holistic sensors underneath — these are the five key differences between them.

1. Garmin Venu X1 is Android-friendly

Only the Garmin Venu X1 plays nicely with both Android and iOS devices. However, on the flip side, only the Apple Watch Series 11 comes in a cellular-capable variant.

2. Apple Watch 11 is more wallet-friendly

The Apple Watch Series 11 starts at $399 for the smaller 42mm model (non-cellular) and increases to $429 for the larger 46mm option.

The Garmin Venu X1 only comes in 46mm and costs $799, the same cost as the Apple Watch Ultra 3.

3. Garmin Venu X1 has a slimmer case

The Apple Watch 11, at 9.7mm thick, is an easy-wearing smartwatch. However, the Garmin Venu X1 is even thinner at just 7.9mm, making it my preferred choice for comfort.

4. Apple Watch 11 has way more smart features

For a Garmin smartwatch, the Venu X1 is stacked with smart features, including an onboard microphone and speaker to take phone calls from a paired smartphone, NFC for mobile payments via Garmin Pay, onboard storage for saving music for offline listening, and more.

Still, the Venu X1 doesn’t come close to matching the Apple Watch 11’s smart features. Not only does the latest flagship Apple Watch have access to the world’s largest app store, but genuinely useful native smart features and apps are plentiful. Some of my favorites include on-wrist translations, global tide tracking, and access to Apple’s nifty Notes app.

5. Garmin Venu X1 has better battery life

Apple bumped up battery life to 24 hours of usage per day, or roughly 8 hours of use when tracking an outdoor activity with GPS.

By comparison, the Garmin Venu X1 is rated to last for up to eight days in smartwatch mode (two days when using the always-on display) or up to 16 hours with GPS.

With the key differences between the Garmin Venu X1 and Apple Watch 11 covered, it’s time to jump into fitness tracking accuracy.

Apple Watch 11 vs Garmin Venu X1: Walk test

To assess which is the better device, I wore one smartwatch on either wrist and tracked my daily midday walk around Seattle, Washington. As a primary control, I counted my steps for the duration of the walk, using a manual tally-counter to note every 100 steps taken.

As a secondary control for distance, climb, and pace, I ran ol’ reliable, Strava, on my iPhone 12 mini. Find the results for the Apple Watch 11 vs. Garmin Venu X1 below.

Both the Garmin Venu X1 and Apple Watch Series 11 were within 100 steps of my actual step count total, an impressive outcome for sure. However, the Garmin is just 12 steps off compared to 82 steps for the Apple Watch. Strava, meanwhile, noted 5,038 steps counted.

The Apple Watch and Garmin both measured roughly the same distance covered, which is only a tenth of a mile off from Strava's tally or well within a reasonable margin for error.

Elevation data is a bit more scattered. The smartwatches clocked a more uphill intensive walk compared to Strava, with nearly 40 feet separating Apple's calculation from Strava's. I suspect my actual total elevation gain is closer to an average of the three, or 204 feet. If that's true, the Venu X1 is right on the money.

While both Garmin and Strava provide an average moving pace and an average elapsed pace figure for outdoor workouts, Apple only offers one metric for pace and doesn't specify which it is (though I highly suspect it's elapsed).

For what it's worth, while Garmin's average moving pace is 33 secs off from Strava's, the Venu X1's elapsed pace of 17 mins, 52 secs is a near match with Apple's.

Heart rate data is also a bit inconclusive, with the Garmin Venu X1 (worn on my right wrist), seemingly over-calculating my cardiovascular efforts. (This was by no means a high-intensity walk.)

Could the fact that the Garmin was worn on my right wrist be the reason for the hiccup? Maybe. When I tested the Venu X1 vs Apple Watch Ultra 2, Garmin's heart rate data was a near-match with Apple's....but the Venu X1 was on my left wrist then.

Moving on, both the Apple Watch Series 11 and Garmin Venu X1 noted roughly the same amount of calories burned, while the Apple Watch used about twice as much battery tracking my 45-minute workout compared to Garmin.

Apple Watch 11 vs Garmin Venu X1: Winner

Even though both the Apple Watch 11 and Garmin Venu X1 delivered impressively accurate step count and distance data, the Venu X1 was ultimately closer to the control in both instances, making it our official winner. It also seemingly produced the most accurate elevation gain metric while using significantly less battery power overall.

Which smartwatch models should I test head-to-head next? Let me know in the comments below.

Follow Tom's Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds.

More from Tom's Guide

• Apple Watch Ultra 2 vs. Garmin Venu X1: I raced 5 miles wearing both watches — here’s the winner
• I walked 5,000 steps with the Apple Watch 11 vs Samsung Galaxy Watch Ultra — and there's a clear winner
• I test smartwatches for a living — and these are my 5 favorite models when I go hiking