Skip to main content
Tom's Guide Tom's Guide
Sign in
  • View Profile
  • Sign out
RSS
  • Newsletters Newsletter
  • flag of Australia
    Australia
    flag of UK
    UK
    flag of US
    US
    flag of Canada
    Canada
    • Best Picks
    • Phones
    • Streaming
    • TVs
    • Computing
    • AI
    • Mattresses
    • Videos
    • More
      • Newsletter
      • News
      • Fitness
      • Reviews
      • How Tos
      • Home
      • Best VPN
      • Deals
      • Coupons
      • Antivirus
      • Entertainment
      • Wellness
      • Security
      • Laptops
      • Smart Home
      • Audio
      • Gaming
    Forums
    Trending
    • Apple WWDC 2025
    • Switch 2 Restock
    • Best laptops
    • Best Mattress
    • Best TVs
    • Wordle Today
    • iPhone 17

    Recommended reading

    The white Xbox Series S next to the black Xbox Series X standing up vertically on a desk
    Xbox I love my more powerful Xbox but the Xbox Series S still holds up in 2025 — here’s why
    PS5 Slim
    Gaming Best games consoles in 2025: our top picks tested and rated
    Indiana Jones and the Great Circle
    Playstation I just played Indiana Jones and the Great Circle on PS5 Pro — and it’s so much better than on Xbox Series X
    PS5 Pro console standing vertically on a table
    Playstation PS5 Pro 6 months later — 3 things I love and 3 things I hate
    Six video game controllers on a coffee table.
    Gaming Peripherals I test gaming controllers for a living — here are the 6 best for each platform
    Nacon Revolution X Unlimited Controller
    Gaming I just tried Nacon’s new Xbox controller — and I never want to play with a regular controller again
    Forza Horizon 5 on PS5 Pro screenshot
    Playstation I just played Forza Horizon 5 on PS5 — and an Xbox game is now Sony's best racer
    1. Gaming
    2. Playstation

    7 Reasons Why Xbox One Beats PS4

    Round-up
    By Michael Andronico published 23 February 2017

    The PS4 might be the current king of the console wars, but the Xbox One is still a better buy. Here's why.

    Comments (13)

    When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

    Comments (13)
    Why Xbox Wins

    Why Xbox Wins

    It may seem like the PS4 has already won the latest console war by a landslide, with over 50 million players and a bigger library of must-have exclusives. But what if I told you the Xbox One was still a better buy?

    Microsoft's home console might not have Uncharted or Horizon: Zero Dawn, but it does a ton of cool things that the PS4 can't in terms of both hardware and software. From backwards compatibility to a superior online experience, here are 7 reasons why the Xbox One beats the PS4.

    Today's best Buy Xbox One S deals
    Buy Xbox One S
    No price information
    For more information visit their website
    See all prices (0 found)
    Page 1 of 8
    Page 1 of 8
    Backwards Compatibility

    Backwards Compatibility

    Unlike the PS4, the Xbox One doesn't make your old games obsolete. The console currently plays over 300 Xbox 360 games (with more being added every month), including such major hits as Red Dead Redemption, Grand Theft Auto IV, Dark Souls, BioShock and the entire Mass Effect series. Want to play PS3 games on PS4? Your only option is to pay up for PlayStation Now, which allows you to stream (not download) a selection of older games for a hefty $20 per month.

    Page 2 of 8
    Page 2 of 8
    Seamless Cloud Storage

    Seamless Cloud Storage

    The Xbox One saves all of your data to the cloud by default, meaning that you can start a game on your home Xbox One and pick up on a friend's console without skipping a beat. If you want cloud storage on PS4, you'll need to be subscribed to PlayStation Plus ($60 per year). Even then, you'll be limited to 10GB, and will have to send your saves to the cloud manually.

    Page 3 of 8
    Page 3 of 8
    Superior Shooters and Racing Games

    Superior Shooters and Racing Games

    The PS4 is king of the big-budget blockbuster -- Uncharted 4, Horizon: Zero Dawn and Bloodborne are in a class all their own. But if you mainly play shooters or racing games, Microsoft's console is for you. Xbox One is the exclusive console home of Gears of War and Halo, while still supporting third-party hits like Call of Duty, Destiny and Battlefield. Microsoft also publishes the best-in-class Forza racing franchise, which consists of the hyper-realistic Forza Motorsport series as well as the open-world fun of Forza Horizon.

    Page 4 of 8
    Page 4 of 8
    Xbox Play Anywhere

    Xbox Play Anywhere

    Virtually all first-party Xbox One games released as of fall 2016 or later support Xbox Play Anywhere, which means that you can buy a digital copy once and play it on both Xbox One and Windows 10. This makes games such as Gears of War 4 and Forza Horizon 3 a tremendous value, as you can start them on your Xbox One and pick up right where you left off on your gaming desktop or laptop — all without having to buy two copies.

    Page 5 of 8
    Page 5 of 8
    TV Integration and 4K Blu-Ray Support

    TV Integration and 4K Blu-Ray Support

    The newer Xbox One S is hands-down the best console for entertainment -- especially if you have a 4K TV. On top of offering 4K streaming, it's currently the only home console that can play 4K Blu-Rays. And even if you're rocking an older Xbox One, you can plug your cable box or HD antenna into your console and seamlessly switch between TV and games.

    Page 6 of 8
    Page 6 of 8
    EA Access

    EA Access

    If your favorite franchises include Madden, FIFA and Battlefield, then the Xbox One is a better place to play. Microsoft's console is the exclusive home of EA Access ($30 per year or $5 per month), which provides access to an all-you-can-play buffet of games that includes major hits such as Star Wars Battlefront and Dragon Age: Inquisition as well as Xbox 360 classics like Skate 3 and Battlefield: Bad Company 2. You also get 10 percent off all digital EA purchases, as well as pre-release trials of some of the company's biggest games.

    Page 7 of 8
    Page 7 of 8
    Better Online Experience

    Better Online Experience

    Multiplayer games are no good without a great network to play them on, and Xbox Live has long been king in this arena. Sony's PlayStation Network has suffered some pretty significant outages, and in an IHS study from 2016, Xbox Live was reported to offer better speeds and overall reliability than PSN. Also, Xbox Live Gold ($60 per year) offers two free Xbox One and Xbox 360 games per month, which means four free games thanks to backwards compatibility, compared to PlayStation Plus' two PS4 games.

    Photo: ArtSimulacra / Shutterstock.com

    Page 8 of 8
    Page 8 of 8
    Comments (13)
    TOPICS
    microsoft
    Michael Andronico
    Michael Andronico

    Mike Andronico is Senior Writer at CNNUnderscored. He was formerly Managing Editor at Tom's Guide, where he wrote extensively on gaming, as well as running the show on the news front. When not at work, you can usually catch him playing Street Fighter, devouring Twitch streams and trying to convince people that Hawkeye is the best Avenger.

    Read more
    The white Xbox Series S next to the black Xbox Series X standing up vertically on a desk
    I love my more powerful Xbox but the Xbox Series S still holds up in 2025 — here’s why
    PS5 Slim
    Best games consoles in 2025: our top picks tested and rated
    Indiana Jones and the Great Circle
    I just played Indiana Jones and the Great Circle on PS5 Pro — and it’s so much better than on Xbox Series X
    PS5 Pro console standing vertically on a table
    PS5 Pro 6 months later — 3 things I love and 3 things I hate
    Six video game controllers on a coffee table.
    I test gaming controllers for a living — here are the 6 best for each platform
    Nacon Revolution X Unlimited Controller
    I just tried Nacon’s new Xbox controller — and I never want to play with a regular controller again
    Latest in Playstation
    PS5 Pro standing on table with green background with Tom's Guide Price Drop badge
    PS5 Pro with $50 price cut makes for a better Father's Day gift than a gaming PC — here's why
    PlayStation Project Defiant fighting stick
    Sony reveals Project Defiant arcade fighting stick
    A splashscreen image for PlayStation Days of Play
    PlayStation Days of Play 2025 live — PS5 Pro gets first-ever discount, $50 off PSVR 2 and more unmissable PS5 deals
    Screenshot from Days Gone Remastered
    I just beat Days Gone Remastered on PS5 Pro — and it's one of the most underrated PlayStation games
    Best games of 2022: God of War Ragnarök
    PlayStation’s epic Memorial Day sale has PS5 games from $5 — these are the 17 best deals I’d buy
    PS5 Pro console standing vertically on a table
    PS5 Pro 6 months later — 3 things I love and 3 things I hate
    Latest in Round Ups
    Young woman in yellow walking with smart phone on the old town square in Prague city
    5 best summer travel apps to help you have the perfect vacation
    Weber Slate griddle with accessories
    I’ve been using a griddle for a year — these are the best starter accessories everyone needs
    A college of four pictures: A blonde woman wearing a grey neck pillow on flight (top left); someone holding up a Kindle in front of plane window (top right); a man sleeping on flight wearing Philips sleep headphones (bottom left) and blonde woman wearing light blue SOMO sleep mask (bottom right).
    These 5 airport essentials are the secret to sleeping through long flights — and they start at $14
    Sustainability Week
    10 ways to save energy at home — small changes that will make a big impact on your energy bill
    Hisense U7N Mini-LED TV
    Best TVs for March Madness 2025 — OLED, QLED, and Mini-LED top picks
    Composite image of Lucid Air Pure, Rivian R1T and Kia EV9
    I've driven over 30 electric cars in the last year — and these are the coolest features that really stand out for me
    13 Comments Comment from the forums
    • AldousHuxley
      XBOX live is $60 PER YEAR not month. Might want to fix that Author.
      Reply
    • soeddy
      I can only laugh at this article lololol...
      Reply
    • YOUDIEMOFO
      Title needs to specify an Xbox One "S" and not just the Xbox One.

      Also...a few of those examples are purely speculative let alone ones opinion, but I do agree with most.
      Reply
    • GrimmyReaper
      Meh, I'd say get a PC and if you have some extra cash, get the console you want the exclusives for.
      Reply
    • Brad_53
      Which one offers keyboard and mouse support for shooters?
      Reply
    • jaystroud1
      Article is dumb. He seems like someone that's not really a gamer. I have both systems and my Xbox one is collecting dust. Yes Halo and Gears are great, but PS has better games like Uncharted, God of War and The Last of Us. I got Madden for Xbox One, it was so horrible, I bought it for PS4 for a better experience. Playstation has better graphics and better modification. It also runs on 4K. I just use my Xbox One for most of the exclusive games and a first person shooter once and a while because I can admit that the controller is better for first person shooters like call of duty than Playstation.
      Reply
    • MingtheMerciless77
      Been a gamer for over 30 years and I've always wondered why people get so uptight over console systems. Unless Sony, or Microsoft is writing you checks and paying your bills why would you be so faithful to corporation that could care less about any of you. I've owned just about every console that has come out since the Coleco Vision and what I love is games not systems and I buy whichever system has the games I like and this generation it's the PS4. Like it or not people buy these systems for the games and the PS4 has a much better game library than the Xbox one.
      Reply
    • Scolar
      Quote from article :


      offers two free Xbox One and Xbox 360 games per month, which means four free games thanks to backwards compatibility, compared to PlayStation Plus' two PS4 games.
      ....

      How? I can download every month 4 free games for PS4 at minimum. I downloaded 5 PS+ games for February : Torquel, Ninja Senki, Starwahl, Not A Hero, LBP 3.
      Reply
    • brad_54
      Lol. Heres the only thing that matters...Sony has decent games coming. Microsoft has the worst lineup of games Ive ever seen in my 30 years. So those "7 reasons" are pretty much moot at this point.
      Reply
    • Neoris
      THANKS! i needed that laugh.
      Reply
    LATEST ARTICLES
    1. Spin Master Real Flying RC Toothless for How to Train Your Dragon
      1
      This new How to Train Your Dragon toy made me feel like a Night Fury — and it's here right in time for the live action movie release
    2. 2
      The entire run of 'Twin Peaks' was just added to a streaming service you've probably never heard of — here's where to watch all 48 episodes now
    3. 3
      I just tried Ikea’s portable induction cooktop — 5 things I like (and 1 I don't)
    4. 4
      I tried power walking for a week — and my body (and mind) feel incredible
    5. 5
      I just tested these $99 noise canceling earbuds with Bose tech — and they're shockingly good

    Tom's Guide is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

    • Terms and conditions
    • Contact Future's experts
    • Privacy policy
    • Cookies policy
    • Accessibility Statement
    • Advertise with us
    • About us
    • Archives
    • Careers

    © Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.

    Please login or signup to comment

    Please wait...