Club Benefits
Rating: ★★★★ stars
Verdict: “Jury Duty Presents: Company Retreat pulls off the rare feat of making lightning strike twice. Anchored by the effortlessly likable Anthony, the show delivers consistently funny, deeply cringe comedy without ever tipping into cruelty. It’s still one of the most unexpectedly charming shows on TV right now.
Release schedule: First three episodes available to stream now. Episodes 4-5 drop March 27 and episodes 6-8 on April 3.
Where to watch: Prime Video
When "Jury Duty" blew up in 2023, it felt like a total fluke. It was a weird hybrid of a prank show and a mockumentary that banked everything on one massive gamble: Could you drop a regular guy into a fake jury trial, surrounded by actors including James Marsden, without him suspecting a thing?
The short answer: You don’t try to replicate it; you just make it weirder. After seeing the first three episodes of "Jury Duty Presents: Company Retreat" on Prime Video, I can say it's cringier, more chaotic and somehow just as charming as the original.
Article continues below
Kelly is currently watching "The Pitt," "Top Chef," "Shrinking," "Survivor 50," "High Potential" and "Age of Attraction." Yeah, that's a diabolical watch list.
Trading the courtroom for company hell
The most obvious change this time around is the setting. Gone is the contained, fluorescent-lit order of the courtroom, replaced by a sprawling corporate retreat for a fictional hot sauce company, Rockin’ Grandma’s.
Where season 1 thrived on the structure of the justice system, "Company Retreat" thrives on instability. There are cabins, team-building exercises, awkward dinners and way too much forced bonding. It’s basically "The Office" if Michael Scott had an unlimited budget and no HR oversight — which, ironically, is part of the plot.
The premise is very similar: Anthony Norman, a temp worker, believes he’s helping organize the company’s retreat, while a documentary crew captures the action. In reality, every single person around him is an actor, and every interaction is carefully orchestrated mayhem. The difference this time is scale. There are more moving parts, more opportunities for things to go wrong and more ways for Anthony to realize he’s been dropped into a sitcom.
That sense of barely controlled madness is what makes the season click. The actors don’t just play quirky coworkers; they build out an entire ecosystem of fake relationships, histories and office politics. It feels lived-in in a way that the jury pool — by design, a group of strangers — never quite could.
Every loopy bit (and there are many) feels real enough for Anthony to just barely accept. Because that’s the magic trick here: The show is constantly pushing him to the brink of “this cannot be real,” and Anthony just ... accepts it.
Verdict: 'Company Retreat' all comes down to Anthony — and he delivers
Like the first season, "Company Retreat" lives or dies by its central figure. If Anthony doesn’t buy in — or worse, if he’s not interesting to watch — the whole thing collapses.
Fortunately, he’s perfect for this. Where Ronald was a bit more of a passive, "straight man" observer, Anthony is more of a doer. He doesn’t just watch the insanity; he tries to fix it. He’s stepping into leadership roles and genuinely trying to help a company that doesn't actually exist.
There’s always an ethical question mark hanging over a show like this. It is, at its core, an elaborate lie, but the producers manage to keep it from feeling mean-spirited. The joke is always the absurdity of the actors, never Anthony’s gullibility. Like Ronald, Anthony comes across as incredibly adaptable and kind.
It’s honestly surprising that this formula still works. It shouldn’t be repeatable, yet three episodes in, I’m totally hooked again. "Company Retreat" proves that as long as they keep finding decent souls like Anthony, this social experiment has plenty of life left in it.
Follow Tom's Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button!
More from Tom's Guide
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.
