Club Benefits
Nicole Kidman clearly has a taste for mysteries, as the actress has appeared in several streaming originals built around twisty plots, including Netflix’s “The Perfect Couple” and Prime Video’s 2025 movie “Holland.” The latter platform now has another Kidman-led thriller in the form of “Scarpetta,” a gripping new series based on Patricia Cornwell’s investigative novels.
“Scarpetta” actually caught my eye when Amazon revealed it had given the show a two-season order back in September 2024, meaning this is only the beginning of the series, and clearly, there are long-term plans for the story. Having already watched the episodes, “Scarpetta” is certainly a bingeable thriller that knows its audience well.
The series uses scientific analysis and detective work to connect clues across time and uncover the truth behind a series of murders, with the dual-timeline structure proving to be its most interesting element. Now that it’s streaming on Prime Video, here are my honest thoughts on “Scarpetta” and whether it’s worth adding to your watchlist.
Article continues belowWhat is ‘Scarpetta’ about?
“Scarpetta” centers around Dr. Kay Scarpetta (Nicole Kidman), a top forensic pathologist who returns to her hometown and her role as chief medical examiner when a brutal murder resurfaces ties to a case from her past. Across two timelines — her early days in the late 1990s and the present‑day investigation — Scarpetta uses her expertise to pursue answers and bring a potential serial killer to light.
Alongside her are her sister Dorothy Farinelli (Jamie Lee Curtis), former detective Pete Marino (Bobby Cannavale), FBI profiler Benton Wesley (Simon Baker), and Scarpetta’s niece Lucy Farinelli‑Watson (Ariana DeBose). Rosy McEwen, Jake Cannavale, Amanda Righetti, and Hunter Parrish play the younger versions of the characters.
‘Scarpetta’ is a dual-timeline mystery worth investigating
“Scarpetta” begins how most mystery thrillers do, by introducing the central protagonist getting called to a murder scene. In this case, Kidman’s character, an intelligent (and experienced) pathologist, studies the body of a woman by the train tracks, and within the first 10 minutes, we’re transported back in time to a similar case Scarpetta had already been on, showing that they’re somehow connected. Even though it’s a familiar setup, the series works because the dual timeline makes it interesting.
Each episode regularly flicks between the two versions of Scarpetta, not only to help us connect the dots whenever a new clue is revealed, but also to build the relationships introduced. Beyond the mystery, there is family drama, with Scarpetta essentially mothering her niece in her sister’s absence, alongside her growing romance with FBI profiler Benton Wesley. For me, that makes the past timeline even more intriguing, particularly in how it gives these characters depth and context that enrich the present-day story.
I also appreciate “Scarpetta” being more of a slow-burn mystery, with reveals usually happening at the end of each episode, and story developments unfolding naturally. That means the viewer is just as much in the dark as the investigators. But along with this lack of knowledge, we’re also thrust into the grisly nature of such cases, including autopsy scenes and Scarpetta explaining in detail how the victim was found. Yet it’s ultimately a testament to her determination for justice.
Rosy McEwen offers the strongest performance as the younger Scarpetta, capturing her struggles as an intelligent woman in a field where she’s constantly judged. Jake Cannavale is also great as young Pete Marino (and fun fact, he’s actually the real-life son of Bobby Cannavale), which makes the casting feel surprisingly authentic. With so many characters, it’s tough to give everyone their moment, but Nicole Kidman’s presence is naturally charming, and so you can’t help but root for her.
Even though the dual timelines are the best part of the series, they can sometimes distract from the central mystery, especially when the family drama takes center stage. Learning about Scarpetta’s past with her absent and reckless sister, her role in caring for her niece, and the older conflicts in the present timeline of them all living together can feel a bit overwhelming. At times, it took me a moment to remember where we were in the case. However, “Scarpetta” thankfully didn’t choose a mystery that was too complicated.
“Scarpetta” is one of Prime Video’s grittier mystery thrillers, and certain parts of the case are difficult to watch, but it still makes for a bingeable thriller with strong performances and an intriguing mystery at its core. I also have to note that the visuals match the tone really well: heavier moments are often blue-tinged, while softer moments are shrouded in orange. It’s a small detail, but it really shows the care put into the show’s look.
Stream ‘Scarpetta’ on Prime Video now
“Scarpetta” manages to balance suspense, character work, and a carefully constructed world in a way that keeps you invested from the start. Even with the occasional narrative detour into family drama, the series never loses its grip on the central mystery, and the dual timelines give it a richness that makes rewatching or pausing to catch details worthwhile.
For viewers who enjoy a procedural that takes its time to reveal secrets while still delivering tense moments, “Scarpetta” is worth streaming. It sets up a promising foundation for future seasons, and with the cast and creative team fully committed, it feels like a series that could grow into one of Prime Video’s standout thrillers.
Stream "Scarpetta" on Prime Video now
Follow Tom's Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds.
More from Tom's Guide
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.
