I swapped my Apple Watch 11 for the Garmin Venu 4 — here’s my honest verdict

There’s no doubt about it — I’ve been blown away by the Garmin Venu 4. It’s a stunning-looking smart watch, with all of the premium health and fitness features of some of the best Garmin watches on the market. I’ve swapped my brand new Apple Watch 11 for the Garmin Venu 4 this past week, and read on to find out why I’m not sure I’ll be going back.

If you’re new to the Garmin Venu line, it’s Garmin’s most popular smartwatch. The Venu 4 has had a design upgrade compared with the Garmin Venu 3 — it has lost a button on the side, moving to a touchscreen design, has a brighter screen, and features an all-metal bezel. If you’re trying to decide between the Garmin Venu 4 and the latest Apple Watch 11, here are all the specs compared.

Liked: The Venu 4’s advanced health tracking

The Venu 4 is pretty much the same as the Garmin Forerunner 570 behind the screen. It features all of Garmin’s newest health tracking capabilities, plus one brand-new feature: lifestyle logging. Lifestyle logging will be rolled out to all of Garmin’s newest watches, and it’s effectively the same as Whoop’s logging system, allowing you to log behaviors like caffeine intake or alcohol intake to see how they impact your sleep and recovery.

In fact, the Garmin Venu 4 has one key upgrade compared to the Garmin Forerunner 570, and that’s the ability to take ECG readings from your wrist. The Forerunner 570 does have additional buttons, which makes using it on the run that little bit easier, but it’s a tough decision to make when choosing between the two.

Compared to Apple, I really appreciate Garmin’s recovery recommendations and tools like Body Battery, which allow me to see how the stress of the day is draining me. Garmin’s morning and evening reports are also far more useful than Apple’s, which says "good morning" and not much else.

Liked: The battery life

The Garmin Venu 4 has up to 10 days of battery life in smartwatch mode, and after a week of testing, I found this pretty accurate. I’ve worn the watch 24/7, without the always-on display enabled, and completed at least one workout per day, and haven’t had to charge my watch.

Sure, the Apple Watch 11 has a slightly longer battery life than the Apple Watch 10, but with Garmin, we’re talking about days between charges, not hours. As a busy working mom of a toddler, I appreciate not having to remember to charge my watch every day.

Liked: How neat and comfortable the watch looked on my wrist

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but I love the look of the Garmin Venu 4. I’ve been testing the 41mm version in lunar gold, and it looks beautiful on my wrist. I much prefer the round screen to the square Apple Watch 11, and although I do miss the extra physical buttons when I’m running, I’m adapting to the touchscreen design of the Venu 4, and appreciate that it’s still easier to pause a run than it is on the Apple Watch 11.

Both of these smartwatches are designed to be worn 24/7, but as someone with petite wrists, I found the Venu 4 far more comfortable to wear when sleeping.

Missed: Being able to reply to messages from my wrist

The Garmin Venu 4 has a speaker and microphone, but if it’s paired with an iPhone, you can still only read messages from your wrist. In fact, I soon turned the smart notifications off, as I found it annoying seeing my messages flash up without the ability to reply to them.

Garmin lags slightly behind Apple in terms of apps and smartwatch features, and while I adapted after a few days, it is a consideration worth making if you’re switching from Apple to Garmin.

Missed: Closing my rings

I really wish I didn’t care about closing my Apple Watch rings, but I still do. Again, it’s something I adapted to, but I did miss those pesky rings, reminding me to stand up and keep moving throughout the day.

Garmin’s move alerts are still useful, and again, I’m sure if I’d never started closing my rings, I probably would reach for the Venu 4 over the Apple Watch 11 for the reasons mentioned above.

Follow Tom's Guide on Google News, or add us as a preferred source, to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button!

More from Tom's Guide

• I walked 10,000 steps with the Apple Watch 11 and Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 — here’s which watch was more accurate
• I took 14,000 steps with the Garmin Forerunner 570 vs Galaxy Watch 8 — and I'm shocked by the results
• I walked 5,000 steps with the Apple Watch 10 vs Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 — there’s a clear winner