iPhone 14 drop tests — here’s why you need a case

iPhone 14 Pro Max and iPhone 14 Plus drop tests
(Image credit: Allstate Protection Plans)

Apple's iPhone 14 Pro Max improves upon its predecessor in many ways, from processing power to cameras to its notch-replacing Dynamic Island feature. But don't include durability on that list of improvements.

Like the iPhone 13 Pro before it, the iPhone 14 Pro Max shattered the first time it was dropped on its back and front during drop-testing performed by Allstate Protection Plans. Apple's best iPhone also took damage to its corners, buttons and camera housing when it was dropped down a flight of stairs.

Allstate, which performs these drop tests as part of a promotion for the insurance plans it offers for devices like the iPhone, also tested the iPhone 14 Plus. Apple's other 6.7-inch phone fared better when it was dropped down the stairs, suffering scuffed corners and roughness on its aluminum frame. But on the face-down and back-down drop tests, the iPhone 14 Plus also took damage on the first drop.

"The new iPhone 14 Plus and 14 Pro Max shattered on the first drop front and back, though they were still fully functional, including their amazing new cameras," said Jason Siciliano, vice president and global creative director at Allstate Protection Plans, in a statement accompanying the test results.

A year ago, Allstate ran the same 6-foot drop tests on the iPhone 13 and iPhone 13 Pro. In those tests, the Pro model suffered damage on the first drop like the iPhone 14 Pro Max did this year.

The iPhone 13 actually took two drops to suffer cracks on the face-down drop test while not cracking on the back-down drop test until a third drop. Those results were better than what Allstate saw with the iPhone 14 Plus this time around.

The iPhone 14 Plus is a leap forward when it comes to repairability.

— Jason Siciliano, Allstate

The newer iPhones have an advantage over their predecessors — their back panels are removable so they're easier to repair. "The iPhone 14 Plus is a leap forward when it comes to repairability," said Siciliano, noting the removable back panel. "Apple should be applauded for this upgrade, as it’s great for their customer’s wallets and the environment."

Still, it sounds as if a good iPhone case remains the best way to keep your Apple smartphone safe from the occasional drop. We've got round-ups of the best iPhone 14 Pro Max cases as well as the best iPhone 14 Plus cases. And though they weren't included in the Allstate tests, our best iPhone 14 case and best iPhone 14 Pro case round-ups can help you find accessories for those two models.

iPhone 14 Pro Max and iPhone 14 Plus drop tests

(Image credit: Allstate Protection Plans)

Here's a closer look at how the iPhone 14 Pro Max and iPhone 14 Plus performed in Allstate's drop tests.

Face-down drop: Both phones were dropped from 6 feet onto a sidewalk with their displays facing downward. After one drop, iPhone 14 Pro Max suffered circular bullseye cracks and a shattered screen. The iPhone 14 Plus sustained bullseye cracks of its own, along with raised glass and scuffed corners.

iPhone 14 Plus drop tests

(Image credit: Allstate Protection Plans)

Back-down drop: Flipping the phones over and dropping them from 6 feet once again, the back of the iPhone 14 Pro Max shattered after one drop with raised and loose glass. One of the rear camera lenses was scuffed, and the camera housing took damage. Similarly, one drop of the iPhone 14 Plus resulted in bullseye cracks, raised and loose glass and a damaged camera housing.

Side-drop down stairs: The iPhone 14 Plus fared better here, with scuffed corners and rough aluminum after its tumble down some stone steps. The iPhone 14 Pro Max also sustained scuffed corners in addition to dented buttons, a damaged camera housing and a shattered back.

TOPICS
Philip Michaels

Philip Michaels is a Managing Editor at Tom's Guide. He's been covering personal technology since 1999 and was in the building when Steve Jobs showed off the iPhone for the first time. He's been evaluating smartphones since that first iPhone debuted in 2007, and he's been following phone carriers and smartphone plans since 2015. He has strong opinions about Apple, the Oakland Athletics, old movies and proper butchery techniques. Follow him at @PhilipMichaels.

Read more
Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra
New Galaxy S25 Ultra's durability test throws cold water on Samsung's claims
iphone 14 pro vs iphone 13 pro
iPhone 14 Pro vs iPhone 13 Pro: Biggest upgrades
iPhone 14 vs iPhone 13
iPhone 14 vs. iPhone 13: Which iPhone should you buy?
iPhone 14 Plus
iPhone 14 vs iPhone 14 Plus: here's how they compare
Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra
Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra torture test is a step backwards from last year’s model
Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra hands-on
Galaxy S25 Ultra scores high for repairability — iPhone 16 Pro Max still beats it
Latest in iPhones
iOS 19 logo on an iPhone
iOS 19's big redesign is tipped to bring a whole new look and unite all of Apple's devices — and pave the way for a foldable iPhone
iPhone 16 Pro Max shown in hand
Forget iPhone 17 — the iPhone 18 could be the first phone with under-display Face ID
iPhone 17 Air render
iPhone 17 Air could lead to portless iPhones and thinner Apple products — if it sells well
iPhone Flip Concept
Foldable iPhone and foldable iPad both just tipped for production next year
A close up image of the Apple Wallet app
iOS 18.4 adds a new way to track your spending — but I think Apple can go even further
iPhone 17 Air render
New leaked iPhone 17 dummy units show off super-thin iPhone 17 Air with this surprising design tweak
Latest in News
Garmin Fenix 8 Sleep
New data reveals the average Garmin sleep score — do you sleep better or worse than most people?
A YouTuber holding the leaked Pixel 9a
Google Pixel 9a just fully leaked in new YouTube video — here's everything it reveals
iOS 19 logo on an iPhone
iOS 19's big redesign is tipped to bring a whole new look and unite all of Apple's devices — and pave the way for a foldable iPhone
iPhone 16 Pro Max shown in hand
Forget iPhone 17 — the iPhone 18 could be the first phone with under-display Face ID
Nintendo Switch 2 console, Joy-Con controllers and dock
Nintendo Switch 2 release window and launch games leaked — here's what we know
Wyatt Russell as Corporal Ford in "Overlord" movie (2018)
This intense war thriller with a dark twist is free to stream right now — and ‘28 Days Later’ fans will love it