We Dropped $18,000 Worth of Phones, and These Are the Toughest (and Weakest)

We all know that feeling. You're walking along the street, answering a text message, when someone bumps you, and your phone goes flying onto the concrete. Will your phone hold up, or will it crack under the pressure?

At Tom's Guide, we test phones to see which is the fastest, which has the best display, which has the best camera and which has the longest battery life. But we've never tested to see which phone is the toughest. Until now.

To help you avoid finding out the horrifying truth when your phone goes clattering to the ground, we tested all of the major smartphones by dropping them over the course of four rounds from 4 feet and 6 feet onto wood and concrete — and even into a toilet — to see which handset is the toughest.

Good news: Chances are, your phone will survive a 6-foot fall onto wood and, if it's lucky enough to land on its edge, withstand drops onto concrete with minimal damage. Bad news: If you don't have a screen protector, there's a really good chance something's going to break.

So, what's the toughest (nonrugged) phone out there? The $500 Motorola Moto Z2 Force. While the result wasn't completely unexpected — after all, the phone has a ShatterShield display, which the company guarantees against cracks — the Moto Z2 Force survived drops from 6 feet onto concrete, with barely a scratch.

Apple's least-expensive phone didn't prove very tough at all. In fact, the $399 iPhone SE was rendered unusable before all of the others. However, this was not a big surprise, as the newer iPhone 8 and iPhone X are made with much stronger glass than the iPhone SE's from 2016.

MORE: Best iPhone X Screen Protectors

Four other phones — the $999 Apple iPhone X, the $810 LG V30, the $720 Samsung Galaxy S9 and the $329 LG X Venture — made it through to, and survived, our toilet test. But even before this point, their screens were far more damaged than the Z2 Force's. Read on to see how your phone fared.

We also purchased a second batch of these phones, and dropped them from 100 feet using a DJI Mavic Pro drone onto a plywood target set up on an asphalt parking lot. Surprisingly, some of the phones survived intact. To see which phones made it, which ones didn’t, and why this might have happened, check out this story on our sister site, LiveScience.

PhoneToughness Score (Out of 10)
Motorola Moto Z2 Force8.5
LG X Venture6.6
Apple iPhone X6.2
LG V306.0
Samsung Galaxy S9 6.0
Motorola Moto G5 Plus5.1
Apple iPhone 84.9
Google Pixel 2 XL4.3
Huawei Mate 10 Pro4.3
OnePlus 5T4.3
Samsung Galaxy Note 84.3
Apple iPhone SE3.9

 

How We Tested

To measure each phone's toughness, we dropped it from both 4 and 6 feet onto wood and concrete. After each test, we recorded the damage to the phone. If a phone was rendered unusable — the screen totally shattered, for instance — then we stopped dropping it. We have much more detail on how we tested here.

For the first round, we dropped each phone, face-first, onto wood from 4 and 6 feet.

The second round involved dropping the phone from a height of 4 feet onto a concrete pad. For this test, we dropped the phone first on its edge, and then on its face.

For the third round, we also dropped the phone onto concrete, but this time, it was from a height of 6 feet. Here, too, we dropped it first on its edge, and finally onto its face.

The final round for the surviving phones was to drop them from 4 feet into a water-filled toilet. Unused, of course.

MORE: How Can a Smartphone Survive a 100-Foot Drop But Crack on Your Floor?

How We Scored

Each drop was worth a maximum of 5 points; if a phone made it through all of the rounds unscathed, it would earn 35 points. The more severe the damage per drop was, the more points were deducted. If a phone was rendered unusable after a given drop, it would earn no points, and would not undergo any subsequent test. In total, there were seven tests:

  • 4-foot edge drop onto concrete
  • 4-foot face drop onto concrete
  • 6-foot edge drop onto concrete
  • 6-foot face drop onto concrete
  • 4-foot face drop onto wood
  • 6-foot face drop onto wood
  • 4-foot edge drop into toilet

If a phone died in the 6-foot edge drop, it was penalized an extra 10 percent. If it died in the 6-foot face drop, it was penalized 5 percent. And if it died when dropped into the toilet, it lost 2.5 percent.

We then divided the total score by 3.5, to put it on a 10-point scale.

Motorola Moto Z2 Force

Motorola guarantees that the screen on the Moto Z2 Force won't crack, and we believe it. This phone's ShatterShield display didn't break, even after drops onto its face from 6 feet. The only physical signs of damage were tiny nicks on the bottom edge of its aluminum frame.

Motorola Moto Z2 ForceMotorola Moto Z2 ForceWhile it can resist some liquids, it's too bad that Moto didn't make the Z2 waterproof; the phone seemed like it had died a few seconds after taking a dunk in the toilet. After it dried out, though, it came back to life, with no apparent damage.

Toughness score: 8.5/10

LG X Venture

LG's value-priced rugged phone — just $349 — made it through all of the 4-foot drops (wood and concrete) without sustaining any damage. That's because the X Venture is designed to be shockproof, thanks to its metal frame and reinforced corners.

LG X VentureLG X VentureHowever, a 6-foot edge drop caused the screen to shatter in the area beneath its physical buttons, and a hairline fracture through the middle of the screen appeared. A dunk in the toilet killed its microphone, but everything else, including the speakers, still worked.

Toughness score: 6.6/10

Apple iPhone X

As with every other phone we tested, Apple's $999 iPhone X survived both 4- and 6-foot drops on its face onto a wood surface. It also survived a 4-foot edge drop onto concrete; there were only minor scratches on the bottom of its case.

When we dropped it face-first from 4 feet onto concrete, the screen cracked in a few places. Following that, a 6-foot drop onto its edge and a 6-foot drop on its face onto concrete caused a few more cracks, as did a 4-foot drop into a water-filled toilet.

Still, the display remained largely intact, with almost no sharp edges, save for the upper-left corner, where some of the screen broke away. Following the toilet test, the phone turned on and off repeatedly for a few minutes, but resumed normal operation after that.

Toughness score: 6.2/10

LG V30

LG's flagship V30 ($699) made it all the way through our testing, but it didn't do as well as other phones. It survived drops onto wood from 4 and 6 feet without damage. A face drop from 4 feet onto concrete caused the screen to crack.

LG V30LG V30Subsequent drops on its edge and face onto concrete from 6 feet caused more damage to the periphery of the display, including in front of the camera, but the phone was still somewhat usable. The V30 is waterproof, so it survived a dunk in the toilet, though the audio was muffled afterward.

Toughness score: 6/10

Samsung Galaxy S9

Drops from 4 and 6 feet onto wood caused no damage whatsoever to the Galaxy S9 ($720). A 4-foot face drop onto concrete caused the S9's screen to crack, but the phone was still largely usable. Following that, a 6-foot drop onto its edge caused a bit more damage, as did a face drop from that height.

Google Pixel 2 XLGoogle Pixel 2 XLFinally, a 4-foot drop into a water-filled toilet didn't cause much more damage. Ultimately, while the display was still viewable, the screen was cracked enough so that we would be hesitant to swipe it much, for fear of pricking our fingers.

Toughness score: 6/10

Motorola Moto G5 Plus

This budget phone — which costs as little as $149 — proved pretty resilient, surviving 4- and 6-foot drops onto wood, as well as a 4-foot face drop onto concrete, with minimal damage.

Motorola Moto G5 PlusMotorola Moto G5 PlusHowever, a 6-foot face drop onto concrete finally did it in — the screen shattered in a number of places. It was still viewable, but there were enough glass fragments that we wouldn't want to swipe it.

Toughness score: 5.1/10

Apple iPhone 8

Like other phones we tested, the iPhone 8 ($699 unlocked) survived drops from 4 and 6 feet onto wood without incurring any damage.

Apple iPhone 8Apple iPhone 8A 4-foot drop on its edge onto concrete caused a minor crack and scratching along the bottom, which grew larger with a face drop from 4 feet onto concrete and an edge drop from 6 feet onto concrete. Apple's phone lasted all the way up to a 6-foot face drop onto concrete, when its screen went kaput.

Toughness score: 4.9/10

Samsung Galaxy Note 8

Samsung's phablet (which starts at $799) took 4- and 6-foot drops on its face onto a wood surface with ease. A 4-foot fall on its edge onto concrete caused some minor scratches on the bottom edge, but a 4-foot drop on its face cracked the screen in a number of places, including in front of its front-facing camera, which gave selfies a very artistic look.

Samsung Galaxy Note 8Samsung Galaxy Note 8A 6-foot face drop onto concrete caused the Note 8's screen to start flashing white, black and green, and the touch screen was completely unresponsive. The stylus was intact, though.

Toughness score: 4.3/10

OnePlus 5T

No damage occured when the OnePlus 5T ($499) landed face-first onto wood from heights of 4 and 6 feet.

OnePlus 5TOnePlus 5TA 4-foot drop on its edge onto concrete similarly did little damage, but a 4-foot face drop, followed by a 6-foot edge drop onto concrete, caused some pretty big cracks in the OnePlus 5T, including in front of its camera. A 6-foot face drop onto concrete finally did the phone in.

Toughness score: 4.3/10

Huawei Mate 10 Pro

Huawei's phone (which starts around $775 unlocked) might not survive pressure from the U.S. government, but it will survive drops from 4 and 6 feet onto wood without issue. It also withstood a 4-foot edge drop onto concrete, incurring only minor scratches to the bottom.

Huawei Mate 10 ProHuawei Mate 10 ProHowever, a 4-foot face drop caused the upper-right corner of the touch screen to stop working, and a 6-foot edge drop resulted in messed-up screen colors on the right side. A 6-foot face drop onto concrete shattered the Mate 10's screen so thoroughly that several pieces of it flew off completely, revealing the electronics underneath.

Toughness score: 4.3/10

Google Pixel 2 XL

The Pixel 2 XL ($849 through Verizon) survived drops from 4 and 6 feet onto wood with no issues. However, when this phone landed with an XL-size thud on its face from 4 feet onto concrete, the screen cracked in such a way as to obscure the front-facing camera.

Google Pixel 2 XLGoogle Pixel 2 XLAs with the Galaxy S9, an edge drop from 6 feet didn't do much more damage, but a face drop from that height caused half the screen to go white.

Toughness score: 4.3/10

iPhone SE

Apple's budget phone, which starts at $349, survived 4- and 6-foot drops onto wood without incurring any damage whatsoever, and a 4-foot edge drop onto concrete produced just a few scratches on the bottom of its case.

iPhone SEiPhone SEHowever, when we dropped the iPhone SE on its face from 4 feet, the screen completely cracked. Following that, a 6-foot edge drop caused a chunk of the screen in the lower-left corner to come off. Although all the icons were still visible, we decided to stop testing the iPhone SE at this point because we deemed its display too dangerous to use.

Toughness score: 3.9/10

Credit: Shaun Lucas/Tom's Guide

Create a new thread in the Android Smartphones forum about this subject
12 comments
Comment from the forums
    Your comment
  • hannibal
    Well... Some surprises in there...
  • josmala
    I think you missed the actually durable android phones Cat S61 and the Doogee S60, Here's some durability testing of those kind of phones, Cat is for older model. S40 is far less durable based on specs, but its durability test with meat hammer is quite ok.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V4S-AT3tsvg
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wKkwtQotK9o
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4LLDzXTIRE
  • Ramachandran_3
    did you test which is the best phone for TALKING which is the primary job of a phone. I agree the service provider also contributes to SOME EXTENT (only some extent) for the efficiency of voice. But the speaker and mic in the phone are equally important.
  • hismerecry
    What about the iPhone 8 Plus? Wouldn’t it get a better score than the 8 because it has more surface area to dissipate energy or same score?
  • mischon123
    But, will it blend?
  • william.16537
    You should use real world objects to drop the phones on. NOT a concrete square that also bounces when the phone hits it. The impact force is much less than a regular concrete slab. Improve your testing.
  • therealduckofdeath
    I think you're missing Samsung's Active model in this comparison? I see you have the equivalent Moto Force model so it would be prudent to have the bigger brand's rugged model in a durability test.
  • eric716
    How can you afford to buy so many phones to "destroy" them?
    I realize that is based on full MSRP, but still!!!
    Perhaps a quality online entity such as Tom's Guide either gets them heavily discounted, or is a very lucrative enterprise, given the revenue from ads.
  • Roshen
    Didn't drop a Nokia. Hmm...
  • jojomani13
    Why not the Essential phone which is made of titanium?
  • glennquagmire911
    Jojo, I can tell the Essential will be in the middle of the pack or worse. The titanium edges and ceramic back are very tough, but the energy transfer to the glass causes the front face to crack. Like so many of the phones, the corners are not reinforced and the Gorilla Glass 5.0 on the front sticks out further than the slim edges of the phone. Dropped mine from about 3 feet the first week and it landed on the corner and I got a small spider-web of cracking in that corner. Essential's limited warranty does not cover the glass. I would call it a design flaw, however, Essential does not agree.


    Most of the newer phones are designed similarly and are all having glass cracking problems. TG is only one tester and one set of results. Other reviews of the newer phones have some results that vary from Tom's Guide. One well know YouTuber who reviews phones showed the iPhone X's glass back breaking from short drops quite easily.

    VISA offers extended protection on the devices you buy with it. Use that Visa credit card (not debit) because it may just get your phone replaced when you need it.
  • gpaddict
    No Samsung S8 Active?, not that I ever plan on dropping mine! :)