Google Chrome May Block Ad Blockers: What This Means for You

UPDATED with comment from Google.

Google is moving ahead with a rule change for Chrome browser extensions that would deactivate many ad blockers and other content blockers, including parental-control extensions and malicious-website screeners. But not all blockers will be affected, and the earliest the rule would go into effect would be this fall.

Credit: Shutterstock

(Image credit: Shutterstock)

In a posting last week to a Chrome/Chromium developer discussion board, Simeon Vincent, developer advocate for Chrome extensions at Google, said that Google would indeed restrict the functions of an application-program interface (API) function called webRequest in Manifest V3, the third version of the declaration, or manifest, that all Chrome extensions must present to the browser to explain what they do.

Manifest V3 is expected to come into force this fall at the earliest, after which only enterprise deployments of Chrome (i.e., versions deployed in-house by large companies and organizations) will be able to fully use the webRequest API to block content.

What you can do to keep ad blockers working

If Google does eventually neuter many ad blockers with this move, there are plenty of other browsers that share the same Chromium codebase, will not be affected by Google's decision and for which ad-blocking extensions are available.

Among them are Brave and the most recent versions of Opera, which come with their own ad blockers; Vivaldi, a fairly new browser from Opera's creators; beta versions of Microsoft Edge, including one for macOS; and Chromium itself, which Google doesn't offer as a precompiled package but which can be downloaded from third-party sites such as https://chromium.woolyss.com/.

Of course, there's always Firefox, which uses a different browser layout and has strong ad-blocking extensions available, and Safari for macOS, which has fewer ad-blocking offerings.

MORE: Best Google Chrome Privacy Extensions

The implementation of the new rules would effectively negate extensions such as uBlock Origin and the Electronic Frontier Foundation's Privacy Badger, both of which use the webRequest API to block ads and other content before it even reaches the browser. Google wants extensions to instead use a different API called declarativeNetRequest, which lets Chrome decide whether to block content based on a set of up to 30,000 rules.

Google's argument is that the extensions using the webRequest API slow performance because the browser has to wait for the extensions to decide whether to display content. declarativeNetRequest is arguably faster because the browser can start loading content while it decides what to block.

"Currently, with the webRequest permission, an extension can delay a request for an arbitrary amount of time, since Chrome needs to wait for the result from the extension in order to continue processing the request," states Google's current draft of Manifest V3. "This can have a significant effect on every single network request."

One of the best-known ad blockers, AdBlock Plus, already use rules to block ads and should have little trouble adjusting to declarativeNetRequest. But AdBlock Plus is widely seen as less effective than some other ad blockers. So is Chrome's built-in ad blocker, which blocks only ads that Google finds too obtrusive or annoying.

Is it all about the money?

Raymond Hill, developer of uBlock Origin, argues that Google, a dominant player in the online ad market, is making this change so that more ads show up in Chrome.

"Google strategy has been to find the optimal point between the two goals of growing the user base of Google Chrome and preventing content blockers from harming its business," Hill wrote this past Sunday (May 26) in a GitHub discussion forum. "The blocking ability of the webRequest API caused Google to yield control of content blocking to content blockers. Now that Google Chrome is the dominant browser, it is in a better position to shift the optimal point between the two goals which benefits Google's primary business."

Eva Galperin, director of cybersecurity at the EFF, summed of the feelings of many Twitter users following this news: "This is a really disappointing decision by Google. I will be switching to Firefox."

Your correspondent is a bit bummed because his favorite Chrome extension, ScriptSafe, does indeed seem to use the webRequest API to work its magic. We've asked the developer of ScriptSafe for clarification.

UPDATE: Google reached out to us and provided this comment: "Chrome supports the use and development of ad blockers. We're actively working with the developer community to get feedback and iterate on the design of a privacy-preserving content filtering system that limits the amount of sensitive browser data shared with third parties."

TOPICS
Paul Wagenseil

Paul Wagenseil is a senior editor at Tom's Guide focused on security and privacy. He has also been a dishwasher, fry cook, long-haul driver, code monkey and video editor. He's been rooting around in the information-security space for more than 15 years at FoxNews.com, SecurityNewsDaily, TechNewsDaily and Tom's Guide, has presented talks at the ShmooCon, DerbyCon and BSides Las Vegas hacker conferences, shown up in random TV news spots and even moderated a panel discussion at the CEDIA home-technology conference. You can follow his rants on Twitter at @snd_wagenseil.

Latest in Browsers
Google Chrome on Android
How to stop your personal data from appearing in Google searches
Opera Air
I just tested the world’s first mindful browser — it’s calmly convinced me to ditch Google Chrome
A photo of the Google Chrome logo on a white background, displayed on the screen of a large MacBook Pro which is situated on a table with green foliage behind.
Google Chrome just got three new modes — and it's a game changer for performance
Google Calendar app on iPhone
Google Calendar just got the dark mode we’ve been waiting for — here’s how to activate it
Image of an Apple MacBook with a Google Chrome logo on the display
This new Google Chrome upgrade made me say 'whoa' out loud — and it's a game changer
Two Opera Browser Days attendees standing in front of a screen displaying the Opera logo
How Opera is challenging Google by putting privacy first
Latest in News
iPhone 17 Air render
iPhone 17 Air could lead to portless iPhones and thinner Apple products — if it sells well
iPhone Flip Concept
iPhone Flip and Foldable iPad could finally go into mass production next year — what we know
Jeffery Dean Morgan as Negan and Lauren Cohan as Maggie in "The Walking Dead: Dead City" season 1
Netflix finally got one of the best ‘Walking Dead’ spinoffs — and now’s the perfect time to binge it
NYTimes Connections
NYT Connections today hints and answers — Monday, March 17 (#645)
iPhone 17 Air render
New leaked iPhone 17 dummy units show off super-thin iPhone 17 Air with this surprising design tweak
Simone Ashley and Hero Fiennes Tiffin in "Picture This" now streaming on Prime Video
Prime Video top 10 has 3 must-watch movies — including a bubbly romcom starring 'Bridgerton's' Simone Ashley