The best comforter is built for adding cozy comfort to your bed for a good night’s sleep. When paired with one of the year's best mattresses, a high-quality comforter makes an excellent sleep duo to help you sleep all night no matter the season.
But, how do you decide on the right comforter when there are so many different options available in the market? It all comes down to finding something that suits your sleep needs and budget.
That's why we've curated a list of comforters that contain different fill powers, span different price tiers, and are made from a variety of materials. Read on to discover the best comforters we've tested, or head to our Labor Day mattress and bedding sales hub for the lowest prices from all our favorite brands.
The 3 best bed sheets we've tested
Also recommended
We're testing new comforters to see if they're good enough to make the final cut. While we haven't got round to fully testing the following comforters yet, we still recommend considering them based on their impressive specs and verified user reviews.
Budget comforters
Why you can trust Tom's Guide Our writers and editors spend hours analyzing and reviewing products, services, and apps to help find what's best for you. Find out more about how we test, analyze, and rate.
Luxury organic comforters
How we select the best comforters
Our guide for the best comforters were based on our own at-home testing, plus extensive consumer report research and online reviews.
We rated things like material type, size and comfort for various sleeping positions. In addition, we looked at how practical it was to use and clean and its durability.
How to choose the best comforter for you
Not all comforters are made equal. When it comes to choosing one, consider whether you are looking for a comforter you can use all year-round, or one you can throw onto your bed during the chillier seasons. The biggest decision you'll need to make is whether you want a down or down alternative comforter - down comforters are harder to care for, which is something to keep in mind.
Material
Down comforters are made from duck or goose feathers and are known for their warmth and coziness. Goose down is fluffier than duck down, but both are good choices for providing warmth and sleep comfort. To ensure the down comforter you are buying uses ethically sourced materials, look for Responsible Down Standard certification.
Down alternative comforters are usually made from polyester-cotton blends and are much more affordable. Luxury down alternative materials include gel-fiber and the patented and breathable material PrimaLoft.
Fill power
Hot sleepers, when choosing the best comforter for you keep an eye on the fill power as the higher the number, the warmer your comforter will be. We'd recommend a light or all-season comforter. As a general rule, a fill power of 600 or higher is the best choice for winter use (and room temperatures below 60℉). Interestingly, a higher fill power doesn't mean a heavier comforter. You can also make a comforter feel warmer by adding a flannel cover.
Machine washability
For an easier laundry day, we’d suggest looking out for comforters that are machine washable. Some comforters are dry clean only though, and these are usually the more expensive down comforters. If you do score a machine washable comforter, keep in mind that it will take up a lot of space in your washer and dryer. We shake out and fluff our comforters mid-drying cycle to prevent clumping.
