Saatva Graphite vs Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt mattress toppers: Which should you buy?

The Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper and the Tempur-Adapt Topper are both 3"-thick all-foam bed toppers designed to add comfort and support to any mattress.

However, there are some key differences between them, and our Saatva Graphite vs the Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt mattress toppers comparison can help you pick the best option for your bed.

The Tempur-Adapt is currently the top pick in our best mattress toppers guide, while the Saatva Graphite is also featured as the best topper for back pain. It allows you to experience the signature comfort of the brand behind 2025's best mattress, the Saatva Classic, for less.

Which one is right for you, though? In this Saatva Graphite vs Tempur-Adapt mattress topper showdown, we'll compare the design, comfort and support, and temperature regulation of the two top-quality mattress toppers.

We'll also take a look at the price and extras, so you can decide which is better for your budget when shopping this month's mattress sales.

Saatva Graphite vs Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt Mattress Toppers: Price & deals

• The Saatva Graphite is never on sale, but often included in bundles
• The Tempur-Adapt is sometimes on sale for 20%-40% off
• The Graphite has a 180-night trial, but the Tempur-Adapt has none

The Tempur-Adapt Topper is included in the monthly Tempur-Pedic mattress sales but its discount comes and goes, and the price reduction can fluctuate between a meagre 10% off to a generous 40% off. At 20% off, a queen-sized Tempur-Adapt Topper is $299, but outside of sales it's $349.

Saatva mattress sales, meanwhile, are typically reserved for mattresses only. We've never seen a discount on any of its toppers (the Graphite included), so you're unlikely to find a queen Saatva Graphite for anything other than $295.

So, if you catch the Tempur-Adapt while it's discounted, it's slightly cheaper than the Graphite. Outside of sale, it's slightly more expensive.

Price aside, what lets the Tempur-Adapt Topper down in the deal department is the lack of a sleep trial. A huge benefit of buying mattress toppers directly from a brand online is that you'll get to try out your purchase for a specified amount of time (at least 30 nights), so Tempur-Pedic's lack of a trial period is a disappointment. Still, you do get a relatively long 10-year warranty and free shipping.

Saatva, meanwhile, offers a very generous 180-night sleep trial (most mattresses don't even have a trial that last this long) and a one-year warranty (which could be longer as a lot off topper warranties last for five) plus free shipping.

Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Toppers: from $215 at Saatva
Saatva is the second cheapest of Saatva's topper collection. Prices start at $215 for a twin, while a queen is $295. While you won't find it on sale, you'll always get a 180-night sleep trial, a one-year limited warranty, and free shipping.

View Deal

Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt Mattress Toppers: from $259 at Tempur-Pedic
At $349 for a queen, Tempur-Adapt is the more expensive of Tempur-Pedic's two available toppers (the other is the Tempur-Cloud Topper). You'll never find both discounted at the same time, but when the Tempur-Cloud isn't discounted you'll find the Tempur-Adapt on sale for 10% to 40% off. While you'll get a 10-year limited warranty and free shipping, you unfortunately won't get a sleep trial.

View Deal

Saatva vs Tempur-Pedic Mattress Toppers: Materials & design

• Both bed toppers are made from a 3" foam layer
• The Tempur-Adapt uses "Tempur-Material" with a removable cover
• Saatva's cover is spot clean-only and non-removable

Both the Saatva Graphite and Tempur-Adapt consist of a 3" slab of foam (Saatva has memory foam, Tempur-Pedic uses its trademark Tempur-Material), with a cover that included anchor straps to prevent shifting. However, the differences are in the details.

As with most Saatva mattress toppers, the Graphite has an organic cotton cover primed with a Guardin botanical antimicrobial treatment to prevent bacteria and mold growth. The organic cotton is moisture-wicking and hypoallergenic, and the anchor straps are made from stretch elastic for increased compatibility with mattresses under 16" thick.

The Saatva Graphite's design is a let-down in only one aspect: the cover is non-removable and spot clean only.

The Tempur-Adapt's cover, on the other hand, is removable and machine washable, making for an easy clean. It's also dust-mite and allergen-resistant and has corner straps designed to fit mattresses 13" deep.

Saatva Graphite vs Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt Mattress Toppers: Comfort & support

• The Saatva Graphite provides body-hugging support to back sleepers
• The Tempur-Adapt provides sink-in softness to side sleepers
• Both may be too soft for heavier people and stomach sleepers

f you want to know what type of mattress topper you need for your body, sleep preferences, and dominant sleep position, take a look at our guide on how to choose a mattress topper first.

Both the Tempur-Adapt and Saatva Graphite received glowing reviews from our testing panel of sleep experts, but both have their ups and downs.

Testers for the Saatva Graphite mattress topper review were impressed with the support it offered to back sleepers and woke up ache-free every morning of the testing period.

They also liked the balance between support and comfort as, while it was firm enough to support the lumbar region, it was soft enough to give a body-hugging feel. Side sleepers will like the support and squishy foam, too, but it may be too soft for plus-sized sleepers and stomach sleepers.

Over at our Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt Topper review, our reviewers adored the plush relief it offered to side sleepers, with key pressure points in the shoulders and hips soothed and free of joint pain. In fact, we can recommend the topper as a cheaper alternative to buying one of the best mattresses for side sleepers.

However, this is definitely a topper that's best suited to side sleepers seeking to soften a hard bed. Many other sleepers (especially back and front sleepers) may find this topper too soft to provide adequate support.

Saatva Graphite vs Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt Mattress Toppers: Temperature regulation

• The Tempur Material is developed to be more breathable, but traps heat
• The Saatva Graphite has excellent temperature regulation
• You can give the Tempur-Adapt a cooling upgrade for $60 extra

Despite being made of Tempur-Material, Tempur-Pedic's propriety foam developed to be more breathable than standard memory foam, the Tempur-Adapt did leave our testers feeling overheated at night as it trapped body heat.

You can, however, opt for a cooling upgrade that costs $60 extra. In our Tempur-Adapt + Cooling Mattress Topper review, testers woke up sweat-free, so it's an upgrade worth considering if you experience night sweats or live in a warmer climate.

While not billed as a cooling mattress topper, the Saatva Graphite impressed our testing panel with its excellent cooling properties, which we attribute to the breathable, moisture-wicking cover and the cooling graphite gel infused into the memory foam.

Saatva Graphite vs Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt Mattress Toppers: Which should you buy?

Choose the Saatva Graphite mattress topper if...

✅ You want more support: The Saatva Graphite offers great support to the lower back, especially when back sleeping.

✅ You want a cooler option: Testers were impressed with the cooling capabilities of the Saatva Graphite, despite it not being a specialist cooling topper.

✅ You have a mattress up to 16" tall: The Saatva Graphite is designed to fit all Saatva Mattresses. The tallest Saatva mattress stands at 15.5", so the Graphite is perfect for taller mattresses.

Choose a Tempur-Adapt mattress topper if...

✅ You sleep on your side: The Tempur-Adapt soothed our side-sleeping testers with its cloud-like softness.

✅ You want a discount: While discounts come and go and the price drops fluctuate, you can still catch a good deal on the Tempur-Adapt.

✅ You want a removable, washable cover: The Tempur-Adapt's cover is removable and can be put into the washing machine for a quick, easy clean.