Tesla has cultivated a range of models to cover all the popular sales bases, with the Tesla Model X proving to be a great attempt at grabbing a thick slice of the red hot SUV sector. However, it’s been suitably prudent and provided us with more of a crossover alternative too in the shape of the Tesla Model Y.
The former model has been produced at Tesla’s Fremont, California facility for a few years now, nearly a decade in fact. Meanwhile, the Tesla Model Y is the newer of the two cars having appeared in 2020. But both models have plenty of features that make them a solid option if you’re keen to take a deep dive into the world of electric car ownership.
Which one to buy? Well, that might depend on what you need it for. Read on to see how this brace of cool Tesla’s compare.
Tesla Model X vs. Tesla Model Y: Overview
The Tesla Model X is one of the oldest models in the range, having followed the Tesla Model S and first releasing back in 2012. However, as is often the case with production at Tesla, initial cars didn't actually make it on to the streets until 2015.
Despite the early glitches, with the car’s characteristic Falcon Wing rear doors l initially proving problematic, the Tesla Model X has become one of the automaker’s biggest success stories.
The Tesla Model Y is a newer car and, to some extent, has stolen a bit of the Model X’s thunder. It provides customers with a slightly smaller option, but keeps the same premium edge and performance appeal of the chunky SUV.
The Tesla Model Y first appeared in 2020, so while it's newer the other bonus is its leaner looks and slightly more refined feel compared to the Model X. In fact, it seems more attuned with the similarly fresh Model 3 sedan.
Tesla Model X vs. Tesla Model Y: Price
The Tesla Model X Long Range car can be ordered starting at $89,990 for the Long Range model. You’ll pay a considerable premium for the Plaid Model X though, with a basic price of $119,990 currently. However, this does come with the benefit of seven seats and the all-wheel-drive powertrain.
Tesla Model X vs. Tesla Model Y: Design and interior
Tesla carries out regular tweaks to its range and even though the Tesla Model Y is a newish model it too had something of a mild refresh this year. Though relatively minor, newer models are carrying the likes of auto-dimming mirrors as also seen in its Model 3 refresh.
The Tesla Model Y currently has a starting price of $51,990 for the Long Range model and $60,990 for the Performance edition. Both of these cars feature the all-wheel-drive dual motor configuration. As is the case with any Tesla in the range, it is also possible to add plenty of additional cost to your final order via a selection of options.
Other improvements have been relatively minor, like silver flourishes in the steering wheel that are barely noticeable, though laminated window glass is a little more substantial. Also present is a USB port in the glovebox, along with a storage device carrying the Tesla logo to assist with the company's penchant for data-intensive driver aids.
The Tesla Model X is perhaps still the model to go for if you want a bona fide SUV with all of the space that comes with it. In fact, it’ll seat up to seven people if you pick that particular seating configuration when you place your order.
Tesla’s Model Y doesn't offer quite the same sort of accommodating interior although it’s still roomy, with seats for five in the Performance edition. However, the design is now available as a seven-seat option too, which is available to order for the Long Range edition of the car.
In terms of overall interior cargo space it’s pretty unsurprising to see that the bulkier Tesla Model X has 91 cubic feet, compared to the 68 cubic feet of the Model Y. The Tesla Model X has also received a spruce up mind, and the refresh means it now benefits from the panoramic glass roof found in the Tesla Model Y.
There have also been interior trim improvements too, with a carbon fiber finish adding an extra premium feel to proceedings. The most notable addition is the yoke steering wheel, which looks like it’s come from a commercial airliner.
If it’s infotainment you’re after then the Model X also tops the Model Y with a 17-inch touchscreen that is more impressive than the latter's 15-inch display. On top of that, it’s landscape oriented. The Model X also packs a second touchscreen for rear seat passengers.
Tesla Model X vs. Tesla Model Y: Power and performance
If you go for either Tesla model then you’ll be able to enjoy very decent performance in equal measure. The Tesla Model X comes as a dual motor, all-wheel-drive model, or there’s a beefier tri motor Plaid powertrain to pick if you want extra power.
Considering its overall size the SUV is pretty potent. The Long Range model packs in 670 horsepower, which can produce a top speed of 155mph and a 0-60mph time of just 3.8 seconds. The car is also capable of towing 5,000lbs, which will make it a great option for many who spend their time outdoors.
However, it’s the Tesla Model X Plaid edition that really gives it the beans, with a peak power of 1,020hp that delivers a 0-60mph time of just 2.5 seconds and a top speed of 163mph. You still get that 5,000lb towing capacity too, although the range drops by 20 miles.
The Tesla Model Y is no slouch either, with some subtle differences between the Long Range AWD edition and the Performance package.
Lookout for a 0-60mph time of 3.5 seconds along with a top speed of 155mph for the Performance car, with a range of 303 miles. The Long Range AWD car delivers slightly less in the performance stakes, though it’s still pretty zingy with a 0-60mph time of 4.8 seconds, a top speed of 135mph and an improved range as a result of 326 miles.
Tesla Model X vs. Tesla Model Y: Battery and range
All of the cars in the Tesla line-up tend to offer impressive levels of range, and both the Tesla Model X and the Tesla Model Y follow suit. The Model X comes in two variants, the Long Range and the Plaid edition. The former car offers up to 360 miles of range currently, while the latter can deliver around 340 miles.
Meanwhile, the Tesla Model Y is currently available as a Performance edition or a Long Range AWD model. Curiously, both cars come fitted with a so-called long-range battery, with the Performance car offering an estimated 303 miles. The Long Range AWD model promises around 326 miles, although calculations are based on EPA estimates for the U.S. market.
Tesla Model X vs. Tesla Model Y: Other features
Considering that the Tesla Model X has been around for as long as it has and the Tesla Model Y is a relative newcomer both vehicles share quite a lot of similarities. That said, the Model X has the likes of heated seats, a heated steering wheel and exterior driver aids like wiper blade defrosters and washer nozzle heaters for owners living in colder climes.
The Tesla Model X also boasts an impressive HEPA air filtration system that has yet to appear in the Model Y. However, given the way that Tesla constantly updates its range you may well see features that currently only appear in the Model X soon appearing in the Model Y too. And vice versa for that matter.
Tesla Model X vs. Tesla Model Y: Outlook
Although it’s been around for a number of years the Tesla Model X still looks relevant and doesn’t feel at all long in the tooth. In fact, in many ways it’s remained ahead of the game, with its ability to pack in three rows of seats inside a well-appointed SUV, and continues to prove very popular with many buyers.
The Tesla Model Y has followed suit, which puts the automaker in a great position to pull in new EV purchasers. After all, not everyone wants a big SUV these days. While sales for the Tesla Model X still appear to be reassuringly strongTesla Model it looks like many electric car converts are seeing plenty of potential in the more restrained crossover appeal of the Model Y.