Decluttering fatigue is real: How the 'unfinished business' test can get rid of your mess for good

Donation box with old clothing
(Image credit: Shutterstock)

There is something deeply satisfying about aligning your home with the shift in seasons. As fall settles in and we naturally spend more time indoors, clearing out accumulated clutter makes space for the cozy season.

However, it’s easy to get overwhelmed by what stays and what goes, and while some items are obviously no longer needed and can head for the rubbish or donation pile, other items remain in the ‘unfinished business’ pile and may stay cluttering up your home for months.

Dealing with what you've decluttered

A person decluttering clothes in a cardboard box

(Image credit: Shutterstock)

The hardest part of decluttering is deciding what to do with items that aren’t quite trash but that aren’t actively being used. It could be a pile of clothes waiting to be listed for sale, boxes from a house move still unpacked, children’s toys ready to be donated, or an unused piece of furniture you planned to sell online.

Latest Videos FromTom's Guide

These items may not seem like a problem on their own, but when several start to accumulate and fill your hallway, bedrooms and living space, they can make your home feel much more crowded. At this time of year, when you’re spending more time inside, the clutter from what you’ve decluttered can start to take over.

moving boxes in a wooden hallway

(Image credit: Shutterstock)

According to Chris Hutton, storage expert at Adams Selfstore, decluttering becomes harder when each item comes with a task attached. This is why he says, “Some people can live with the same pile of things for months without really seeing it as clutter. You know why it’s there, so it doesn’t feel like rubbish.”

Some people can live with the same pile of things for months without really seeing it as clutter

Chris Hutton, Adam Selfstore

So although there may be a job attached to every item, whether it needs selling, donating, returning, or simply unpacking, if you apply the “I’ll deal with it later” mentality to each object, he says you’re creating your own very long-term storage system — what I’d prefer to call a storage problem.

“If something has been waiting for you to do something with it for six months, ask yourself whether that job is actually going to happen anytime soon,” he advises.

Fall is a good time to tackle these items, as children have settled back into school, work routines return to normal, and Thanksgiving is still a fair distance away.

What is the 'unfinished business' test?

Cluttered space

(Image credit: Shutterstock)

To help you sort out your clutter, Huttons proposes trying the 'unfinished business' test. Rather than telling people to throw things away, he recommends asking why an item is still in your home.

“Not using something recently doesn’t automatically mean it needs to go. The better question is why you’re keeping it, and whether you’re realistically going to get around to doing what you’ve been putting off.”

He proposes three methods to help you decide and take action.

1. Set a deadline

Hutton’s main advice is to set yourself a deadline rather than sticking with vague intentions. “If you’ve got a bag of clothes you’ve been meaning to sell, give yourself a realistic date to do it. If you haven't got around to it by then, make a different decision.

“The important thing is stopping temporary piles from becoming permanent fixtures in your home.”

2. Reconsider where objects are stored

If you decide to keep an object rather than selling or donating it, it doesn’t necessarily have to stay in a prime spot in your home. Hutton explains, “Keeping something doesn’t automatically mean it needs to take up space in the room you use every day. There are belongings that are worth holding onto but that don’t need to be within arm’s reach all year round.”

Items don’t need to be within easy reach unless you use them daily. I use this method in my kitchen, and I keep any appliances I don’t use regularly in an appliance cupboard. But a word of warning: only keep the items you use. You still need to be ruthless about what you declutter.

Citylife Storage bins with bamboo lids, 4 pack
Citylife Storage bins with bamboo lids, 4 pack: $32 at Amazon

These 7-quart storage bins come with an attractive bamboo lid, so they stack. They are ideal for storing toys, desk supplies, snacks or sundries, and can be neatly stacked or placed on shelves. For ease of use they have built-in handles.

3. Start at your clutter zones

Hallway clutter

(Image credit: Future / Camilla Sharman)

Hutton says the easiest place to start is often the areas that have gradually become holding zones. For me, that’s an area in my hallway where I put items ready to be donated.

“Look at the things you’ve walked past so often that you’ve stopped noticing them. That’s usually where you’ll find the unfinished business. Pick one of those areas and finish the jobs attached to what’s there.”

Over to you

I’d love to hear your decluttering tricks and whether you have a problem with clutter zones in your home. Please leave your thoughts in the comments below.


Google News

Follow Tom's Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds.


More from Tom's Guide

Camilla Sharman
Staff Writer, Homes

Camilla is the Homes Staff Writer and covers everything to do with homes and gardens. She has a wealth of editorial experience, mounting over 30 years, and covers news and features, tests products for reviews and compiles buying guides. 


Her work has appeared in business and consumer titles, including Ideal Home, Real Homes, House Beautiful, Homebuilding & Renovation, and Kitchen & Bathroom Business. She’s even appeared on the cover of Your Home, writing about her own house renovation.


Although she’s obsessed with decorating her home, she also enjoys baking and trying out the latest kitchen appliances. But when she’s not inside, you’ll find her pottering about in her yard, tending to her vegetable patch or taking in her prized hydrangeas.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.