Netflix's new time travel thriller isn't the best — but here's why it's still worth watching

Madison Bailey and Antonia Gentry as Lucy and Summer Field in "Time Cut" (2024), now streaming on Netflix
(Image credit: Netflix)

When Netflix dropped the trailer for “Time Cut” earlier this month, it promised a nostalgic thrill ride and a playful time travel twist. With an unmistakable similarity to “Totally Killer” — Prime Video’s own time travel slasher that hit screens just over a year ago — “Time Cut” seemed poised to give us that same cheeky Halloween charm. Teen slasher flicks can be a lot of fun with throwbacks and silly humor, and I went in hoping this new movie would deliver on those fronts.

But while the movie sets the stage with promising retro aesthetics, and it dabbles in that time travel twist we’re seeing a lot of in horror-thrillers lately, it didn’t quite live up to my expectations.

That said, “Time Cut” may still be a solid pick for anyone who wants something lighter and less intense this Halloween. Its playful approach to the genre might appeal to viewers who prefer a horror-inspired storyline without the serious scares.

So, here’s what I really think about “Time Cut” on Netflix, and why it could still be worth watching now that it’s on the streaming service

‘Time Cut’ is an easy thriller with little charm

Time Cut | Madison Bailey & Antonia Gentry | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube Time Cut | Madison Bailey & Antonia Gentry | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube
Watch On

The premise for “Time Cut” is pretty standard for a time travel movie. It follows Lucy (Madison Bailey), a teenage girl who stumbles upon a time machine and is unexpectedly transported back to the early 2000s. Soon, she realizes she's landed in the very year a serial killer claimed four lives, including her sister, Summer (Antonia Gentry). Faced with a rare chance to alter fate, Lucy takes it upon herself to rewrite history and stop the killer.

To start, “Time Cut” is a very easy watch that could appeal to a more casual crowd. Its nod to 2000s nostalgia is evident in everything from the set pieces to the vibrant color palettes, lending a fun, retro flair to the movie. Visually, it’s not bad at all; the bright colors and style choices make it an aesthetically pleasing watch. But for serious horror or slasher fans, “Time Cut” might feel a bit lacking in substance. It doesn’t deliver on the genre it claims to embrace, and while it’s marketed as a slasher, it doesn’t fully commit to that label.

When it comes to the actual kills, most of them happen off screen (ideal for anyone who doesn't like gore). And the one who is committing them wears a rather boring plastic mask that does little to terrify. The victims remain anonymous and undeveloped, more like fresh meat than actual characters, making it hard to care when they meet their ends. There is one interesting kill scene that happens about halfway through on an escalator, but again, you don’t really see much.

This lack of connection extends to the main cast as well — the acting didn't really draw me in, and I found it difficult to connect with or root for anyone. If you’re a fan of Bailey in “Outer Banks” or Gentry in “Ginny & Georgia” and are curious to see them in a teen slasher, this movie might be worth a casual watch one evening. However, don't expect them to fully spread their wings here; their performances feel a bit restrained.

(L-R) Antonia Gentry as Summer Field and Madison Bailey as Lucy Field in "Time Cut" streaming on Netflix in October 2024

(Image credit: Allen Fraser / Netflix)

That said, “Time Cut” has its place for a Halloween watch this year, especially if you’re looking for something laid-back and not too intense. I understand that not everyone is after bone-chilling horror this time of year; for some, a lighthearted, nostalgic flick is more their speed, and this movie fits that bill. I wouldn’t even call it horror at all, but as a teen-centered, low-stakes thriller, it works as a quick, non-committal escape.

While I’d probably recommend something darker for horror lovers, “Time Cut” could still be a fun choice for those who enjoy a dose of light banter with their Halloween fare. Overall, it’s a safe, easy watch — just not for those expecting a true scare or a deep story with real emotional impact.

Is ‘Time Cut’ worth streaming on Netflix?

Antonia Gentry as Summer Field in "Time Cut" streaming on Netflix in October 2024

(Image credit: Netflix)

If you’re contemplating whether to stream “Time Cut” on Netflix, consider what you’re in the mood for. This movie offers a lighthearted escape filled with little nostalgic charm, making it a decent choice for a laid-back movie night, especially around Halloween.

However, if you're a dedicated horror fan seeking thrills and chills, you might find this flick lacking in intensity and emotional depth. While it has familiar faces from popular shows, their performances don’t quite reach their full potential.

Ultimately, “Time Cut” is best suited for those who enjoy light banter and a sprinkle of teen nostalgia, rather than a full-fledged horror experience. If that sounds appealing, it could be worth your time. However, if you prefer a gripping, adrenaline-fueled slasher, you may want to look elsewhere for your Halloween fix.

Netflix has some other Halloween movies worth checking out instead. We also have a guide on the best horror movies to stream on Prime Video during spooky season.

Stream “Time Cut” on Netflix.

More from Tom's Guide

Alix Blackburn
Staff Writer, Streaming

Alix is a Streaming Writer at Tom’s Guide, which basically means watching the best movies and TV shows and then writing about them. Previously, she worked as a freelance writer for Screen Rant and Bough Digital, both of which sparked her interest in the entertainment industry. When she’s not writing about the latest movies and TV shows, she’s either playing horror video games on her PC or working on her first novel.

Read more
Heart Eyes killer in "Heart Eyes" movie (2025)
One of my favorite movies of 2025 so far is now streaming — and it’s Certified Fresh on Rotten Tomatoes
Josh Hartnett as Cooper in "Trap"
Netflix just got a twisting thriller movie that feels fresh — and there’s one thing about it that I love
David Oyelowo as Detective Jack Radcliff in "Don't Let Go"
This new to Netflix mystery thriller just crashed the top 10 — and viewers disagree with critics
Megan Fox and Bruce Willis in "Midnight in the Switchgrass" (2021)
Netflix just got a crime thriller movie that’s already crashed the top 10 — but there’s a problem
Dakota Fanning as Mina in "The Watchers" (2024)
One of the most disappointing movies I saw in 2024 just crashed the Netflix top 10 — here’s what to stream instead
Shailene Woodley as Eleanor Falco in "To Catch a Killer"
Netflix just added a crime thriller you (probably) haven’t seen — and it’s packed with mystery
Latest in Netflix
Owen Cooper as Jamie Miller in Adolescence
'Adolescence' is a gripping new Netflix show that's already hit No. 1 — and it’s 100% on Rotten Tomatoes
Jeffery Dean Morgan as Negan and Lauren Cohan as Maggie in "The Walking Dead: Dead City" season 1
Netflix finally got one of the best ‘Walking Dead’ spinoffs — and now’s the perfect time to binge it
(L-R) Josh Hartnett as Cooper and Ariel Donoghue as Riley in "Trap"
Netflix top 10 movies — here’s the 3 worth watching right now
Uzo Aduba as Cordelia Cupp and Randall Park as Edwin Park in "The Residence"
I watch Netflix for a living — here’s the 7 new shows and movies I’d stream this week
Josh Brolin as Beck Weathers, Jake Gyllenhaal as Scott Fischer, and Jason Clarke as Rob Hall in "Everest" movie (2015)
Netflix just got this intense thriller movie based on a shocking true story — and it’s already crashed the top 10
Cristin Milioti in "Black Mirror" season 7 coming to Netflix
‘Black Mirror’ season 7 trailer teases some of the darkest episodes yet — here’s when you can stream it
Latest in News
A person on a laptop converting a PDF to a DOC
FBI issues warning over free online file converters that infect your PC with malware
The Find my People feature
Android Find My can now track your friends and family — here's how to use it
Foldable iPhone concept image
Are you sitting down? Here’s what the foldable iPhone could cost
Samsung HW-Q990D soundbar
Samsung’s flagship 2024 soundbar just got bricked by a new firmware update — don’t update
A hacker typing quickly on a keyboard
New MassJacker malware is hijacking digital wallets to steal large sums from users
Owen Cooper as Jamie Miller in Adolescence
'Adolescence' is a gripping new Netflix show that's already hit No. 1 — and it’s 100% on Rotten Tomatoes