What mattresses are comparable to the Saatva Classic? The top 3 alternatives based on our extensive lab testing
The Saatva Classic is the best bed of the bunch according to our expert mattress testers, but these top performers are worthy alternatives
The Saatva Classic is as close to perfect as you can get if you're looking for a mattress that delivers hotel-style comfort at a sub $2,000 price.
The Saatva Classic sits at the top of our best mattress guide and remains the only mattress to receive full marks across the board from our expert testing team. But what if you're looking for a different mattress type, or working with a smaller budget?
Here, we're highlighting three mattresses that are comparable to the Saatva Classic in performance and cost. And if you're working with a smaller budget, we're also sharing three beds that share similarities to the Saatva Classic, but at a lower price.
Along with the best mattress sales, we track the best Saatva mattress sale every month, so you'll be able to find a great deal — whether you choose a Saatva or go with something else.
The defending champ: Saatva Classic
The Saatva Classic is our highest-rated mattress and the best hybrid you can currently buy, with three firmness options and two heights. In our Saatva Classic mattress review we found it suited nearly every sleep style and delivered excellent temperature control, motion isolation, and edge support. Right now, you can take $400 off all sizes with our exclusive Saatva mattress sale. You'll also get a 365-night sleep trial, lifetime warranty, plus free White Glove Delivery and old mattress removal.
The top 3 mattresses comparable to the Saatva Classic
The WinkBed is the closest competitor to the Saatva Classic. Both are hybrids with variable firmness levels and dedicated lower back support. They're similarly priced, as well, with the WinkBed coming in at slightly less than the Saatva Classic for a queen-size. WinkBed sale prices don't change much, even during events like Labor Day, so there's no real pressure to buy. It comes with a lifetime warranty, a 120-night trial, and free shipping to your door.
Why we chose it: The WinkBed has the advantage of being more supportive for heavier bodies, with a max weight capacity of 900lbs. (The Saatva Classic can only withstand up to 600lbs.) There's also the WinkBeds Plus, which is a modified version of the WinkBed that includes heavy-duty coils and denser foams.
If you're looking for an all-foam alternative to the hybrid Saatva Classic, then the Nectar Premier should be your top choice. As the best memory foam mattress on the market, the Nectar Premier offers a body-hugging feel that's ideal for side and back sleepers. It's cheaper, too, thanks to regular Nectar mattress sales that keeps a queen below $1,000. Free shipping and returns, a lifetime warranty, and a year-long sleep trial are also included.
Why we chose it: The Nectar Premier offers a blend of side-sleeper body contouring and back-sleeper support. It's also a top choice for couples, as its slow-moving foam dampens partners' movements exceptionally well. (We gave it a 4 out of 5 score for motion isolation.) And like Saatva, Nectar offers a one-year trial and a lifetime warranty — albeit for much less.
While the Saatva Classic is still a great option for anyone who sleeps on their side, the Helix Midnight Luxe is the best mattress for side sleepers we've tested. It delivers plusher comfort and targeted support that soothes pressure points in the shoulders and knees, with a balanced medium firmness. The Helix Labor Day mattress sale cuts 25% off all sizes, which is among the best deals we've seen. Extras include a 120-night sleep trial, lifetime warranty, and free shipping and returns.
Why we chose it: We tested the luxury firm version of the Saatva Classic, and while it was excellent for side sleeping, a couple of testers did report some pressure buildup in that position. While you can opt for the plusher Saatva, you can also choose the Helix Midnight Luxe, a bed designed especially for side sleeping with a balanced medium tension.
The 3 affordable alternatives to the Saatva Classic
The Saatva Classic is an excellent value for money for a luxury mattress, but it's still a premium-priced bed at the end of the day.
If you're working with limited funds, you don't have to forego all the qualities that make the Saatva Classic our most beloved mattress. These affordable alternatives offer a comparable level of comfort for less than $800 in a queen-size:
A luxury hybrid bed-in-a-box that's always under $700 for a queen, the DreamCloud Classic is an outstanding mid-range alternative to the Saatva Classic. The DreamCloud delivers a just-right combination of cushioning and support for both back and side sleepers. You'll also get a 365-night trial, lifetime warranty, and free delivery. DreamCloud mattress sales are evergreen and don't change much, so there's no rush to buy right now.
This is the cooling mattress that comes closest to the Saatva Classic in nearly every major category. It's only available in medium-firm (7/10), but the pillow top adds enough plushness that we think combination side and back sleepers will get on with it very well. A rare 30% Brooklyn Bedding Labor Day mattress sale brings the CopperFlex Pro to one of the best prices we've seen all year. It also comes with a 120-night trial, a lifetime warranty, and free shipping.
Now hear us out — we know this is a bona fide budget mattress, but the EGOHOME Black Hybrid scored a 4 or higher in each of our tests, and it even earned a perfect 5/5 for edge support. The caveat? Unless you're a strict side sleeper, you might not find the support you need here. Otherwise, take advantage of the EGOHOME Labor Day sale and bring home a queen-sized mattress for roughly a quarter of the price of the Saatva Classic.
Our review: ★★★½
Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips.
Based in Philadelphia, writer and editor Alison Barretta has been sharing buying advice and retail news for over 15 years. Since 2020 she's been helping Tom's Guide expand its robust library of sleep content by researching the latest trends, speaking with renowned experts, and going behind the scenes at Saatva, Casper, Sleep Number, Tempur-Pedic, and 3Z Brands. Alison has reviewed everything from budget mattresses to immersive luxury smart beds that automatically adjust to your every move. When she isn't reviewing mattresses or searching for great deals to save you money, Alison can be found practicing yoga and martial arts, experimenting with recipes, getting too invested in the Philadelphia Flyers, and snoozing with her cat / assistant mattress tester Alex.
Next Badge:
More Comments/Likes Until Your Next Badge
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.






