What Are the Best Prepaid/Value Plans?

If you’re looking to save money on your monthly cellphone bill, opting for prepaid wireless service may be the way to go, especially as carriers offer a wider selection of phones to their prepaid customers. And you've got a lot of top plans to choose from, depending on your specific needs.

Based on our testing and analysis, MetroPCS is the best overall prepaid choice with its $40-a-month 6GB plan, thanks to its superior network performance. MetroPCS also has the best unlimited plan, especially if you don't mind streaming video at lower-resolution. While AT&T normally offers the most attractive rates for families, thanks to escalating discounts as you add more lines, MetroPCS has gotten more aggressive in this area. If you can take advantage of the carrier's current rates for adding extra lines, MetroPCS is our choice for families who want unlimited data.

Now that Virgin has dropped its generous tiered data to only offer a single unlimited data plan to iPhone users, customers who want the most data for the least amount of dollars should consider AT&T's 6GB plan, which costs $40 a month with an autopay discount. If saving money is more important that maximizing data, though, you could turn to a host of discount carriers for an even lower monthly bill. Republic Wireless offers the best balance of cost and data, with a $20-a-month 1GB plan.


How We Picked the Best Prepaid Plans: You've got a vast number of choices when it comes to prepaid and discount carriers. To help simplify things, we divided plans into different categories. First, we looked at the best overall plans, using 3GB as the ideal amount of data an average user would need each month. Because a growing number of discount carriers now offer unlimited data, we also picked the best plan for people who want the fewest limitations on their monthly cellphone plan.

In addition, we determined which carrier offers the most attractive pricing for families who need multiple lines of data. In all of these categories, we took network performance, including our own 4G testing, into account.

Because some wireless customers want an even lower monthly bill, we broadened our search to include additional discount carriers, which allow you to mix and match the amount of talk minutes, text and data you have in your monthly bill. We picked the best plan for less than $30 that had the most attractive combination of service and price.

MORE: The Best Discount Cellphone Carrier

Best Prepaid Plans for Individuals

Best Overall Prepaid Plan: MetroPCS, 6GB for $40 a month

Who Should Get It: Prepaid customers who want the best network performance

MetroPCS stands out because of the superior network of parent company T-Mobile. MetroPCS's $40 plan doesn't put any limits on download speeds, as Cricket does, and MetroPCS recently doubled the size of the plan's data allotment to 6GB. While that's a limited-time promotion, if you sign up for the 6GB plan now, you'll keep that data allotment so long as your MetroPCS account remains in good standing. MetroPCS also includes nice bonuses like the ability to stream music from more than 40 services without it counting against your monthly data allotment.

Metro also boosted the data allotment on its $30 a month plan to 2GB, if you don't consume much data. You may be better off with Boost's tiered data plan, though, which offers more data for the same $30 (once you factor in an autopay discount).

Runner-Up: AT&T, 6GB for $40 a month

Who Should Get It: Data-hungry users who like AT&T's network

Virgin dropped its 5GB for $35 plan, leaving AT&T as the alternative choice for users with big data needs. AT&T offers a 6GB plan for $45, but you can knock $5 off your monthly bill by enrolling in autopay. Any data you don't use with AT&T rolls over to the next month. A current AT&T promotion gives you two free months of data, but the credit only appears for the third and 12th month of service, meaning you've got to stick with AT&T for a year to reap the rewards of that offer.

Other prepaid options include:

• Cricket, 4GB for $40 a month: Enroll in autopay and you can bring your monthly bill down to $35, which is cheaper than what MetroPCS and AT&T charge. Cricket also uses AT&T's network, which performs well. Unfortunately, Cricket caps data speeds at 8 Mbps so you take a performance hit.

Boost, 3GB for $35 a month: Boost's tiered data plan isn't a bad choice so long as you enroll in autopay to bring the cost down to $30 a month. Boost uses Sprint's slower network.

Straight Talk, 8GB for $60 a month: You can get the 8GB plan for $45 from Straight Talk, which recently rejiggered its plans to expand your options and increase the amount of data you get. (Low-data users finally have an option at Straight Talk, now that the carrier also has a 2GB plan for an attractive $35 a month, though both MetroPCS and Boost have cheaper options still.) The more expensive of Straight Talk's 8GB plans adds unlimited mobile-to-mobile calling to Mexico, Canada, China and India. Be aware that Straight Talk finished at the bottom of our annual carrier rankings.

Low-Cost Plans

If you want to save even more money on your monthly bill, other discount carriers let you mix and match talk, text and data allotments. By turning to one of these options, you can cut your bill down to size if you don't really use a lot of data each month or you prefer texting to talking.

The perfect low-cost plan depends upon your needs, but to find the carrier that offers the best mix of options, we set a budget of $30. Then we tried to build a plan that offered the best mix of talk, text and data without exceeding our monthly limit. We gave extra marks to plans that came in well under budget while still giving us a good allotment.

Carrier
Talk Time
Texts
LTE Data
Monthly Cost
Network
Notes
Consumer Cellular
250 minutes
Unlimited
500MB
$25
AT&T, T-Mobile
5 percent discount for AARP members
FreedomPop
Unlimited
Unlimited
2GB
$25
AT&T, Sprint
Also offers family plans
PagePlus
1,500 minutes
Unlimited
1GB
$30
Verizon
Includes unlimited international texts
Project Fi
Unlimited
Unlimited
1GB
$30
Sprint, T-Mobile, US Cellular
Get refunds for unused data; Only works with Google devices
Republic Wireless
Unlimited
Unlimited
1GB
$20
Sprint, T-Mobile
Uses Wi-Fi for calls and text when possible
Tello
Unlimited
Unlimited
1GB
$29
Sprint
Plans cover calls to Canada and Mexico
TextNow
Unlimited
Unlimited
3GB
$28
Sprint
Plan is discounted to $14 for the first month
The People's Operator
Unlimited
Unlimited
2GB
$25
Sprint, T-Mobile
Includes $5 discount for autopay enrollment
Ting
500 minutes
100 texts
500MB
$28
Sprint, T-Mobile
Plan reflects "pay what you use" pricing
US Mobile
500 minutes
1,000 texts
1GB
$27
T-Mobile
Plan reflects "pay what you use" pricing

Our favorite plan comes from Republic Wireless, which offers 1GB of data along with unlimited talk and text for $20 a month. Republic keeps monthly prices low by using Wi-Fi networks to handle much of your calling, texting and data needs; when Wi-Fi's not available, it turns to the mobile networks of Sprint and T-Mobile.

If you need more data and don't mind paying a little bit more each month, The People's Operator and FreedomPop both offer 2GB plans with unlimited talk and text for $25 a month. The People's Operator uses the networks of Sprint and T-Mobile, while FreedomPop operates on AT&T and Sprint. FreedomPop is particularly appealing if you want to add multiple lines, as a family of four can share 1GB of data for $20 a month. If you want the largest pool of data for less than $30, TextNow offers a 3GB package for $28 a month, and you get half-off for the first month of service.


You can also lower your bill by turning to carriers like US Mobile and Ting, which offer pay as you go plans. It's difficult to say exactly how much your monthly bill will be with these services — again, it depends on exactly how much you use each month. But a Ting plan where you have 500 minutes of talk time, 100 texts and 500MB of data should run you about $28 each month. You'd pay $27 at US Mobile by limiting yourself to 500 minutes of talk time, 1,000 texts and 1GB of data.

Unlimited Prepaid Plans

Best Unlimited Prepaid Plan: MetroPCS, $50 a month

Who Should Get It: Data-hungry cell phone users who want the fastest network

MetroPCS and Boost have the best price on unlimited data at $50 a month, though both carriers restrict video streaming to 480p. Boost goes a step further by also imposing speed limits on game and music streaming for unlimited customers. That, plus MetroPCS's better performing network, make the choice easier. And if you want to get rid of the video streaming limitation, you can opt for MetroPCS's $60-a-month plan. (You can get those restrictions removed at Boost, too, but it costs $20 extra a month, pushing your bill to $70.)

Other unlimited plans include:

• Boost, $50 a month: As noted above, under Boost's unlimited plan, music will stream at 500 Kbps, and streaming games will be limited to 2 Mbps on top of the 480p streaming video restriction. A current promotion throws in unlimited calls and texts to and from Mexico along with 8GB of roaming data when you're traveling in that country.

• Virgin, $50 a month: Virgin has reinvented itself as an iPhone-only carrier, stripping down its data plan options to just a single unlimited offering. The good news is that Virgin charges as much as MetroPCS and Boost do for their plans. The bad news: Virgin puts the same restrictions on video, games and music that Boost does. Virgin has an intriguing offer as of this writing: sign up for its service and buy an iPhone from the carrier, and you can pay just $1 for data over the next year. Virgin extended the deadline for taking advantage of that deal to August 31.

• Cricket, $55 a month: Things have gotten confusing at Cricket, where the carrier now offers two unlimited plans that ultimately cost the same. The better of the two options is Cricket's $60 a month plan, which costs $55 after you enroll in autopay. It features the usual 8 Mbps cap on data speeds, but you can stream video at full resolution. The Cricket Unlimited 2 plan costs $55 a month but caps speeds at 3 Mbps and limits video streams to 480p resolution. Really, it just exists as part of a two-line promotion Cricket now offers (and which we'll discuss below.)

• AT&T, $60 a month: AT&T clearly has the worst prepaid unlimited plan, even after you knock $5 off the $65 rate when you enroll in autopay. Not only does AT&T restrict video streaming to 480p resolution, there's also a 3 Mbps cap on data speeds, which is even more severe than the 8 Mbps cap that Cricket imposes.

• Sprint, $60 a month: Sprint has a new unlimited option for prepaid customers that normally costs $60. But Sprint is following the lead of its postpaid unlimited plan and cutting the monthly fee to $50 through Sept. 30, 2018. You will have to sign up by Aug. 10 to get the special rate. You can stream video at 1080p resolution on this plan though there are caps on streaming music (1.5 Mbps) and games (8 Mbps).

• Verizon, $80 a month: Verizon has the most expensive unlimited data plan for prepaid users. It costs as much as Verizon's unlimited postpaid plan, and this version restricts video streaming to 480p resolution.

Family Plans

If you're shopping for multiple prepaid lines, five carriers are worth considering — AT&T, Boost, Cricket, MetroPCS and Sprint. They offer discounts when you add multiple lines. In the case of AT&T and Cricket, those discounts escalate the more lines you add.

Best Plan: T-Mobile's unlimited plan for four lines of data, $125

Who Should Get It: Families with more than three lines who want to save money

MetroPCS typically offers modest discounts when you add an extra line of data ($5 off its tiered data plans, $10 off its unlimited options). But the carrier has gotten more aggressive with discounts this summer. Currently you can add extra lines of data to its 6GB and unlimited plans at $25 per line. That's particularly appealing if you opt for the $50 unlimited plan. Three additional lines of unlimited data will cost you $75, bringing your monthly total to $125. You'll have to live with lower-resolution on video streaming, but on a phone-sized screen, that's a sacrifice worth the monthly savings.


Other options for families include:

• AT&T: Cricket has more generous discounts as you add more lines, but parent company AT&T gets the nod for having a better performing network. And AT&T's discounts still escalate as you add more lines: you save $5 on the second line, $10 off the third and $15 off the fourth. A family of four that opts for four lines with 6GB of data each will pay $130, once you factor in all those discounts, plus additional savings from autopay. That same family can mix and match plans, too, adding a cheaper 1GB plan if there's a member of the family who doesn't use as much data as the rest.

• Cricket: Cricket doesn't have the best performing network, thanks to an 8 Mbps ceiling on download speeds. But it does offer big discounts as you add additional lines — $10 off the second line, $20 off the third, $30 off the fourth and $40 if you have a fifth line. Opt for the carrier's $40-a-month, 4GB plan, and a family of four pays $100 a month, with 4GB of data for every line. (A family of five also pays $100 since that fifth line is essentially free.)

If there are just two of you and you want unlimited data, Cricket's new Unlimited 2 plan may fit the bill. You get two lines of unlimited data for $80 a month. The restrictions are pretty onerous, though: your data speeds are capped at 3 Mbps, and you can only stream 480p video.

• Sprint: Sprint's revamped prepaid plan adds a discounted rate when you add more lines. The first line of 4GB of LTE data costs $40 a month with autopay enrollment, but subsequent lines cost $30 each. For unlimited plans, Sprint is mimicking its postpaid off of $90 for two lines of data while waiving the cost of the third and fourth line until Sept. 30 2018. After that, you'll pay $160 for those same four lines ($60 for the first line, $40 for the second and $30 for each line after that). That promotional pricing ends Aug. 10.

• Boost: You only get a substantial discount when adding lines to Boost's unlimited plan. The first line will cost you $50 per month, but each subsequent line of unlimited data costs $30. Extra lines also cost $30 a month for the 3GB plan at Boost, which is only a $5 savings off the initial line. As of this writing, Boost is offering four lines of unlimited data for $100 a month. That's a monthly savings of $40 off Boost's regular pricing for four lines. The promotion runs through Sept. 7.

Big Four Prepaid Plans

Carrier
Prepaid Data Plans
Monthly Cost
Notes
AT&T
1GB/6GB/Unlimited
$30/$40/$60
Includes $5 autopay discount; Unlimited plan caps video streaming at 480p and data speeds at 3 Mbps
Sprint
4GB/Unlimited
$40/$60
Includes $5 autopay discount, with unlimited international texting and hotspot data; Unlimited plan is currently discounted to $50 per month for a year
T-Mobile
4GB/6GB
$45/$55
Only tiered data plans available at T-Mobile
Verizon
3GB/7GB/10GB/Unlimited
$40/$50/$60/$80
Tiered plans offer rollover data; Unlimited plan caps video streaming at 480p

Besides AT&T, the other major carriers offer prepaid plans, though they're not as appealing as the options outlined above. Recent changes to prepaid pricing at Verizon give you 4GB for $40 a month or 7GB for $50 a month, respectively, while Sprint's prepaid options include 4GB for $40 plus a new unlimited option. T-Mobile's $45, 4GB prepaid option is compelling only if you still want to subscribe to that carrier's wireless service but don't want a pricier unlimited data plan.

Create a new thread in the Wireless Carriers forum about this subject
2 comments