Pandora Premium vs Spotify Unlimited: How They Stack Up

Pandora is finally going right after Spotify, but which service looks better?Illustration: Tom's GuideIllustration: Tom's Guide

Pandora Premium, the service's on-demand streaming music tier, will launch in a free trial starting this Wednesday (Mar. 15). It will cost $9.99 per month after that.

What makes Premium stand out from Pandora's other offerings is that users will finally be able to select the songs they want, rather than depend on the service's radio stations. Pandora will be catch-up out of the gate when it comes to device support and video content, but it looks like a strong contender overall.


Pandora Premium
Spotify Unlimited
Monthly Price
$9.99
$9.99
Free Trial Length
6 months for Plus Subscribers, 30 or 60 days for others
30 days
Song Library
The same as Spotify, minus the karaoke tracks, covers and tributes
More than 40 million songs
Availability
Android phones, iPhones, Chromecast, Android Audio, CarPlay and other car stereos (at launch); desktop computers and connected devices ("in the coming months")
Android devices, iPhones, iPads, desktop computers, Amazon Echo speakers, Amazon Fire TV, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, smart TVs, Sonos speakers and other connected devices Chromecast, Android Wear, Android Audio, CarPlay and other car stereos
Other Content
Music and limited podcasts (Serial, This American Life, Questlove Supreme).
Music videos, other videos (including TED Talks and content from Genius), podcasts

How much do they cost?

Just like Spotify Unlimited, Pandora Premium will cost $9.99 per month. Starting March 15, Pandora will be giving free six-month trials to existing Pandora Plus subcribers who sign up here. Pandora Plus is the $4.99 per month version that removes ads from the personalized internet radio service, as well as adding more skips.

Users who aren't paying for Pandora Plus can sign up at the same page for access to the March 15 trial, but their trials will vary in length between 30 and 60 days. Spotify offers a 30-day free trial to new users.

MORE: 10 Things You Didn't Know Spotify Could Do

Is Pandora Premium going to be available everywhere, just like Spotify?

At first, no. Unlike Spotify and Pandora's current offerings, Premium will launch on iOS and Android phones, Google Chromecast, and smart car setups including Android Auto, Apple CarPlay and systems from GM, Honda, Subaru and others. Pandora says Premium will land on the desktop and "popular connected devices" in "the coming months."

What makes Pandora Premium better?

Pandora says Premium's going to make Search smarter by organizing your results based on what it knows about you, and hiding the stuff nobody wants. So while the company has access to the same "more than 40 million" song library as Spotify and Apple Music, it removes covers from other artists, karaoke versions and other renditions you don't care about at the bottom of your results.

Pandora Premium will rise from Rdio's ashes in a trial for new and existing users starting March 15. Image: Pandora.Pandora Premium will rise from Rdio's ashes in a trial for new and existing users starting March 15. Image: Pandora.
Pandora Premium's "Add Similar Songs" feature appears to be a slightly better version of Spotify's automatically generating song radio stations. On Pandora, once you've added some songs to a playlist, you'll get the option to "Add Similar Songs." On Spotify, you can create a playlist based on one song by clicking the Radio tab, clicking the + icon in the top right corner and finding a song of your choice. The difference is that Pandora lets you add as many starter songs to set a base, while Spotify allows for only one song.

MORE: 9 Best Songs to Stream Right Now

Pandora Premium will offer a dynamic user interface, changing the color scheme of the Now Playing screen based on the art of the song you're listening to. This will be familiar for those who used Apple Music prior to iOS 9, which used a similar trick.

You'll also get a cleaner look with Pandora Premium, which appears to have kept the minimalist look that made Rdio (which Pandora bought) popular among those who appreciate well-designed apps.

How are they the same?

Much like Spotify and other services, Pandora Premium will offer personalized suggestions based on what you've listened to previously.

Pandora Premium will also let you download albums, songs, stations or playlists for offline. This way you won't need to burn through your monthly data allotment or go without tunes when you lose a signal.

MORE: 14 Cheap Headphones Ranked From Best To Worst

What's Pandora Premium missing?

If you want more than music, you might be out of luck. Pandora's given access to select podcasts, such as Serial, but doesn't offer much more. Videos aren't there either, so you're gonna still be YouTubing your favorite music videos.

The Verge reports that there's no ability to edit the Up Next queue currently, which seems like a mistake on Pandora's part that should be remedied soon.

What else?

If you want to take a trip down memory lane of your favorite songs, Pandora offers a My Thumbs Up playlist that compiles every song you've tapped the Thumbs Up icon for. It'll also continue to add to this playlist for all songs you Thumbs Up going forward.

Outlook: Interesting

Pandora Premium looks like it will offer a more personal and catered streaming music service than Spotify. On the downside, early adopters better be OK with sticking to their mobile devices and Chromecasts, as other connected devices won't be supported at launch.

We look forward to getting our hands on Pandora Premium to see how it stacks up as an experience.

Create a new thread in the Audio forum about this subject
This thread is closed for comments
4 comments
    Your comment
  • Markle Sparkle
    Is the content from these providers still in a compressed & lossy format such as MP3? Weird that you don't mention the quality of the sound from any of these providers.
    0
  • henrytcasey
    Anonymous said:
    Is the content from these providers still in a compressed & lossy format such as MP3? Weird that you don't mention the quality of the sound from any of these providers.


    That information is not yet available about Pandora Premium, and we will be sure to mention it when we get hands-on time with it.
    0
  • The Paladin
    unknown I don't use either.
    0