Barry season 4 review: Another hit for HBO's favorite hitman

A slower pace actually helps freshen up Barry in season 4

Bill Hader, as Barry, dressed in a blue jumpsuit, in a prison cell in key art for Barry season 4
Editor's Choice
(Image: © HBO)

Tom's Guide Verdict

Barry season 4 feels like the fitting end to a wild, dramatic ride. And by finally putting its protagonist in jail, Barry gets to switch its escape-focused formula up a bit, which works for the better. That said, some might think the early episodes are too methodical.


  • +

    Excellent tension drawn from Barry going to jail

  • +

    The whole cast delivers strong performances

  • +

    As gorgeously shot as ever


  • -

    A slow start

  • -

    One big surprise doesn't exactly work

Why you can trust Tom's Guide Our writers and editors spend hours analyzing and reviewing products, services, and apps to help find what's best for you. Find out more about how we test, analyze, and rate.

Barry, HBO Max's favorite depressed hitman, is back for his final outing. Having finally been caught and arrested at the end of season 3, Barry Block/Berkman (Bill Hader) is stuck in his tightest situation yet: prison. 

Over three seasons now, Hader's hitman (who tried his hand at acting but couldn't escape the murder industrial complex) has repeatedly unstuck himself from the trickiest jam-ups. Now, in a season that Hader himself directed, Barry starts out in captivity, which creates a difficult situation for all of the people he's connected to. Everyone, from his ex-girlfriend Sally (Sarah Goldberg) down to his acting coach Gene Cousineau (Henry Winkler), is worried about the lies they've told along the way that could be exposed now that Barry's in custody.

Having watched nearly all of Barry season 4 — HBO provided critics with seven of the eight episodes, leaving us hanging — I can truly recommend that you get into this show if you haven't already. It's truly one of the best HBO Max shows.

This Barry season 4 review, I should note, is spoiler-free, as I've left out all the significant plot points (and some medium-sized ones as well), writing this as if I was going to read it before I watched. Those include two fantastic cameos that you might learn about beforehand. I hope neither is spoiled for you.

Barry season 4 switches speeds on us

Bill Hader, as Barry, in a prison yard in Barry season 4

(Image credit: Merrick Morton/HBO)

The Barry writers have loved to set up traps for their protagonist to escape, but kicking off Barry season 4 with the titular character behind bars freshens up the series. Now, Barry's survival is based around an escape we can't really imagine. This isn't Shawshank. That said, this season is as immaculately shot as all that came before it, so kudos to the entire production team behind Barry. 

This leads to two key changes: Hader's performance goes to a subtler, more stoic place, as he's starting to lose it a little. And in this situation, the show moves to a different pace, which viewers may find slower than anticipated. It still works nonetheless. Primarily, this comes from the show's ultimate through-line: the lies being told by actors (both good and bad).

In true Barry fashion, there's one moment in particular that had me asking "WTF?" right before the credits hit.

For example, on a phone call early in the first episode, Barry shows a vulnerability that Gene Cousineau — who's on the other end of the line — probably doubts. I didn't believe him either, but it's left up to the audience's interpretation.

Action does pick up, as it always does in Barry, and the show continues to keep audiences on their toes. And throughout, the series continues to veer into the surreal. In true Barry fashion, there's one moment in particular that had me asking "WTF?" right before the credits hit. 

What follows that, though, is maybe my only personal hang-up about this season. A surprising pivot doesn't (at least before the finale) quite pay off.

Barry's ensemble still delivers

Sarah Goldberg as Sally, looking at her phone on an airplane in Barry season 4

(Image credit: Merrick Morton/HBO)

While Barry is Bill Hader's show by title, its excellent supporting cast is still delivering throughout. As Sally, Sarah Goldberg has a ton to work with, from going back to her small-town home and her pleasant and quaint parents — and navigating Hollywood. And don't worry: Sally's narcissism is still here, even as she's coping with the aftermath of Barry's arrest. 

Trying to find the next steps in her career, Sally starts teaching the Cousineau method that she experienced herself, and Goldberg really nails the tone and moments. That even brings her to the next level in Hollywood, where she continues to climb the ladder. 

Anthony Carrigan as NoHo Hank, sitting in a living room, in Barry season 4

(Image credit: Merrick Morton/HBO)

Of the seven of eight episodes provided to critics, I truly believe the best moment came from NoHo Hank.

And now that Gene Cousineau — who helped with Barry's arrest — is believed by the public to be a hero, Barry's writers have put that character in an increasingly anxious situation. We all know the truth, and it's fun to watch him squirm as he deals with increased attention. I won't spoil it, but there's a certain moment where he curses in a weaselly way that I kept rewinding to.

Ultimately, some of the best moments for the whole season come from Anthony Carrigan's NoHo Hank. Still with Cristobal (Michael Irby), the two venture into a new enterprise this season that they can't help but screw up. Of the seven of eight episodes provided to critics, I truly believe the best moment came from Noho Hank.

Stephen Root as Monroe Fuches, interviewed by cops, in Barry season 4

(Image credit: Merrick Morton/HBO)

Oh, and what can I say about Fuches (Stephen Root), Barry's former handler turned nemesis? Well, Root continues to prove that he can turn manic energy driven by fear and neuroses into gold. His false confidence in prison leads to some excellent moments as well. 

Bottom line: Barry season 4 may start slow, but it works

While I could explain more about the best scenes of this new season — of which there are many — I would rather end this Barry season 4 review noting that the series appears to be going out on the perfect note. 

First of all, it hasn't overstayed its welcome at all. And, secondly, you do get the feeling that they may be close to running out of ways for Barry to escape the chaos he's found himself in. 

I'll save my final decision for when I've seen the finale, but the first seven episodes give me a strong indication that Hader and co-creator Alec Berg can land their chaotic show perfectly, a rarity among even the best prestige TV shows. 

Earlier on Sunday nights, over on Succession, Jesse Armstrong is trying to do the same exact trick in Succession season 4, something that the likes of The Sopranos and The Wire — two of the best HBO shows of all time — couldn't pull off. If HBO's finally found the magic equations to make shows end when they should? That's a deserving a reason as any to applaud.

More from Tom's Guide

Henry T. Casey
Managing Editor (Entertainment, Streaming)

Henry is a managing editor at Tom’s Guide covering streaming media, laptops and all things Apple, reviewing devices and services for the past seven years. Prior to joining Tom's Guide, he reviewed software and hardware for TechRadar Pro, and interviewed artists for Patek Philippe International Magazine. He's also covered the wild world of professional wrestling for Cageside Seats, interviewing athletes and other industry veterans.