Is it safe to use metal utensils on cast iron pans? I asked pro chefs

A cast iron skillet with a cut steak, a bulb of garlic and a sprig of rosemary cooking within next to grated salt

(Image credit: Shutterstock)

For such a durable, hard-wearing piece of cookware, it can sometimes feel like cast iron skillets require a lot of extra care. But that investment pays off, with a naturally nonstick finish and chemical-free cooking. Best of all, if used correctly, your pan can last a lifetime.

If you're keen to keep your kitchen free of forever chemicals and plastics, you may opt for metal utensils over plastic ones. Not only are they durable, but they're also easier to clean and won't degrade even in a hot pan. However, I wanted to check with pro chefs before I started using my metal utensils with my precious skillet, and their advice was universal.

Can I use metal utensils with my cast iron?

Is it OK to use metal utensils on cast iron? — (Image credit: Shutterstock)

"Metal utensils are fine if used gently, but heavy scraping can scratch the pan’s surface."
Hank Shaw, Chef

I reached out to Paul Bough, a Chef at STAUB, and Hank Shaw, James Beard Award–winning chef and author of the new cookbook Borderlands, to get the answer once and for all.

"To keep the cast iron enamel surface pristine, it’s best to use wooden, silicone, or heat-resistant silicone utensils," says Bough. "Metal utensils can leave marks or, over time, damage the enamel."

So with regards to enameled cast iron, such as Staub's skillets, you'd be better off using less harsh utensils when flipping your steak or stirring your eggs.

When I asked Shaw if it was OK to use metal utensils, his response surprised me. "Yes," he said "but I prefer wood."

So technically, you could use metal utensils with your bare cast iron. But when it comes to the likes of Lodge or Lancaster, you might still be better off opting for a wooden or plastic option.

"Metal utensils are fine if used gently, but heavy scraping with, say, a metal spatula can scratch the pan’s surface."

While hard-wearing, your pan's seasoning can be damaged easily if it's not cared for correctly. That's why I also asked chefs whether it's OK to cook tomato sauce in cast iron.

What to use instead

An empty cast iron skillet on a tea towel on a wooden surface — (Image credit: Shutterstock)

"Mostly I use a wooden spatula, which will not hurt the iron," says Shaw. Which makes sense, because a wooden spoon is about as timeless as cast iron cooking.

Of course, you could also use silicone utensils, but wooden utensils do offer a few advantages. For one, you'll often be cooking at high heats with cast iron, and plastic can be prone to melting and even leaching chemicals if exposed to high temperatures. High-grace silicone is a notable exception, but cheaper utensils are often not designed to work with high heat cooking.

Wooden spoons are also incredibly durable. I've had mine since I went to university, and they've held up amazingly well against daily use.

Do you use metal utensils with your cast iron cookware? Let me know in the comments.

Follow Tom's Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds.

More from Tom's Guide

Millie is the Managing Editor of Homes at Tom's Guide. She's been reviewing home tech for over five years, testing everything from coffee makers to the latest vacuum cleaners.

With particular expertise in cookware and kitchen appliances, you'll struggle to find an air fryer Millie hasn't tested. She's traveled the world reporting on the latest home innovations and product launches, learning how to use pizza ovens from Pizzaiolos in Naples, and touring the De'Longhi factory in Venice. Millie is also an SCA-Certified barista.

When she's not reporting on home and appliance trends, Millie loves watching live music. She's currently learning the guitar - naturally, she plays a Fender.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

GET TG ACCESS QUICK

Can I use metal utensils with my cast iron?

What to use instead

More from Tom's Guide