Club Benefits
Whether you're hosting a party, camping, or simply want to add warmth to a patio, there’s nothing like sitting around one of the best fire pits. But how do you know which one is right for your yard?
That's why we asked expert Rich Woodbridge to test dozens of the best fire pits on his family farm. Rich is the perfect person to test these fire pits; he is an experienced camper, an Eagle Scout, and best of all, a former cookstove product designer. Trust us, he knows exactly what makes for a good fire pit.
Here are our best smokeless and traditional fire pit picks based on our comprehensive testing and expertise.
Best fire pit overall
As a smokeless fire pit, the Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0 offers everything you need and more. It has a sleek design, great airflow for a nice smokeless burn, and is very easy to clean after each use. It was the only smokeless fire pit in Rich's tests that had both a removable ash pan (the metal grate the logs sit on) and a removable ash tray located below the pan. Rich found that this made the Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0 the easiest fire pit to clean, which is one of the reasons why it takes the top spot as the best fire pit.
Rich found the Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0 incredibly simple to assemble, taking less than a minute; just rest it on its base and flip over the fire ring on top. It had clear instructions, and he was able to build a nice, controlled fire very easily. It produced very little smoke and sparks, and after half an hour, the fire burnt down to the perfect point for roasting marshmallows.
Unlike other fire pits that may reserve stainless steel for only the inner burn chamber, the Bonfire 2.0 is entirely constructed out of corrosion-resistant stainless steel. This results in a sturdy and quality product. In fact, Solo Stove is so confident in the design and durability that it offers a lifetime warranty with each fire pit.
Like most smokeless fire pits, the Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0 is not designed to be permanently left outside. There are no built-in handles, and the smooth stainless steel design can be slippery when moving. However, it comes with its own canvas travel bag and at just over 23 pounds, it is relatively easy to pick up. The included stainless-steel stand fits and supports well, lifting the fire pit off the ground by a few inches.
Solo Stove offers many add-ons to make the most of your fire pit. If buying cords of wood is not your thing, Solo Stove also sells a wood pellet adapter for its fire pits; this perforated metal plate sits inside the stove and lets you pour in pellets to keep the fire going.
Best budget
Looking for a sub-$100 option? The Amazon Basics Steel Lattice Fire Pit is the best value option we tested, and it's also the only fire pit we tested with designated handles, giving it a rustic, cauldron-like appearance.
It took approximately 20 minutes for Rich to assemble the Amazon Basics model, and the instructions were very straightforward. Rich found the fire easy to light and produced a nice, controlled flame in a matter of minutes. The attractive lattice design, combined with wire mesh, allowed plenty of airflow for large fires with very few sparks. Overall, the burn time lasted about half an hour, which was similar across the other traditional fire pits of this size.
Most of the traditional fire pits Rich tested, like the Bali Outdoors 32-Inch, came with short fire screen lifting tools or pokers that were only 14-19 inches long. The Amazon Basics Lattice Fire Pit, on the other hand, came with a 3-foot-long fire poker that doubles as a screen lifter. This tool made it much easier to manage the fire at a safe distance compared to all the other fire pits. At 17 pounds, it was very easy to move around and dump out the ash.
The one main drawback of this fire pit is that it doesn’t come with any drain holes. While traditional fire pits aren’t designed to be left uncovered outside for extended periods, most have at least one drain hole to prevent accidental water buildup and premature rust. Aside from that one gripe, it is a great overall fire pit that is both sturdy and attractive at a great price. It has the basics of what you need for a good backyard bonfire.
Best gas
The Ninja Fireside360 is a strong pick for anyone wanting a truly effortless firepit experience, thanks to its propane-fueled design that minimizes smoke and makes it safe and comfortable for close gatherings.
In day-to-day use, the Fireside360 stands out for its straightforward operation. Our tester, Dan, found that the ease of ignition meant he found himself using it far more than he uses his wood-fuel fire pits, because whether you want to enjoy it for one quick alfresco drink on the patio, or a full evening with friends, you won't need to worry about getting it fired up and adding more fuel to the fire. It has three settings: flame only, heat only, or flame and heat.
The Ninja Fireside360 runs on propane and delivers a true smokeless burn, making it perfect for smoke-sensitive settings and relaxing close to the fire. Because it runs on gas, turning the Ninja Fireside360 on and off is a breeze. In our testing, we found that the Fireside360 radiates heat consistently in every direction. You get the same cozy warmth whether you’re sitting directly in front or off to the side, making it a great centerpiece for group settings. However, Dan did find that the tall design of the Fireside360 meant his feet would get cold if he sat in a low-slung chair.
The Fireside360 comes with a two-year limited warranty, which is reassuring but falls short of the Solo Stove’s lifetime coverage. Unlike the Bali Outdoors 32-Inch, this isn’t a grill-focused fire pit, and it's also not very portable, with no handles on its stout and tall design. The Ninja is best for buyers who care most about easy, smokeless fires for relaxing or entertaining, and are happy to make their new firepit a permanent feature in their yard.
Most durable
Breeo’s X24 Fire Pit is big, and it’s not even the biggest fire pit in the Breeo X lineup. This solid fire pit is made for entertaining in the backyard, and thanks to its stainless and corten steel construction, it can stay right there all year round. Stainless steel resists rust, and Corten steel is designed to develop a rusty patina, which in turn protects it from the elements. If you don’t like the look of Corten steel, you can upgrade to a full stainless steel construction.
Breeo offers a limited lifetime warranty on the X24. It’s made in the USA and ships free to your doorstep. Be sure to have a friend on hand when it arrives, because this 62-pound fire pit is heavy. That’s a great feature for sturdiness and safety, as long as you don’t intend to move it around a lot; it's more than three times as heavy as the Amazon Basics fire pit.
Breeo touts the X24 as a smokeless firepit thanks to its double-wall construction and X-Airflow design that feeds oxygen to the fire from below and directs heat up through the double walls. According to Breeo, the heated oxygen then exits through the vents at the top of the unit and re-burns, causing more heat. The system does its job well, and the X24 throws off a ton of heat. It’s awesome in cold, snowy weather or cool autumn nights.
But what makes the X24 truly shine is its almost-overwhelming selection of accessories. You can turn your X24 into a live fire cooking station with the Fire Pit Firemaster bundle of grill and sear plate add-ons. Alternatively, you can turn it into a gourmet pizza station with the Live Fire Pizza Oven Bundle.
You can even add a heat deflector add-on that throws the X24’s heat outward, further away from the fire, warming a larger area. The X-series lid is a must-have for covering the firepit after use, preventing stray sparks, smoke, and ash. These bundles are pricey, but their versatility is unmatched. Breeo’s accessory options outnumber those of Solo Stove, and add versatility no other brand currently matches.
Best smokeless
What makes the Cuisinart Cleanburn Fire Pit unique is its bowl-shaped design. While the majority of other smokeless fire pits have vertical walls, the Cuisinart Cleanburn’s convex shape gives it two advantages. First, it makes it much easier to reach in to light the fire compared to the traditional deep-cylinder design. Second, once the fire is going, its concave design radiates the fire’s heat outwards towards the user, instead of straight up. Heat could be felt sitting over 6-feet away. This made the Cuisinart Cleanburn the warmest fire pit to sit around compared to all other brands tested.
Rich found the Cuisinart Cleanburn very easy to assemble, taking only a couple minutes to figure out. Just rest the fire pit on the base and give it a quarter turn clockwise to lock it into place. The base has a useful integrated ash tray. When it’s time to dump the ashes, just twist the fire pit a quarter turn counter-clockwise and lift it off the base to reveal the ash.
However, he had to use a small hand broom to sweep the excess ash down through the holes in the fire pit, so it all ended up in the tray. At 22-pounds, there is also the option of flipping the fire pit over after removing it from the base to dump out the remaining ash and debris, which is fine, but more complicated than other similar fire pits. This convoluted method is an inconvenience compared to the Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0, but not a dealbreaker.
With a limited, one-year warranty, you definitely want to take good care of this fire pit and bring it inside after each use. Although it does not come with a cover, they are available to purchase separately online.
Overall, the Cuisinart CleanBurn Fire Pit created one of the best fire-side experiences in Rich's tests. It was easy to light, produced very little smoke and sparks once started and burned steadily for about 35 minutes. If it had a better warranty, and it was easier to clean, the Cuisinart Cleanburn fire pit could have tied for first place with the Solo Stove as the best fire pit.
Best portable
If you’re looking for fire pit you can take on the go, the Tiki Portable is our recommendation. It has a stylish and compact, rectangular design, a removable ash tray and convenient handles. Built with a 16-gauge stainless steel interior and powder-coated exterior, this fire pit is both durable and sturdy. On top of that, it’s easy on the eye.
The Tiki Portable had easy-to-follow instructions and took Rich about five minutes to assemble with the included hardware. It was the only rectangular-shaped fire pit tested, but it performed just as well as its cylindrical counterparts, offering a four-foot heat radius from the fire and the longest burn-time (40 minutes) of all the fire pits he examined.
It was easy to reach in and light the fire because of its width, and it produced a nice, low-smoke flame. Weighing in at 41 pounds, it is surprisingly heavy for a “portable” fire pit, but the handles make moving it easy.
The Tiki Portable features a removable ash tray, and the interior just requires a quick brush between uses to knock the ash down into the tray. You just grab the tray by the handle and it pulls right out of the unit without having to move the fire pit at all. It comes with a weather-resistant canvas cover, however, that does not mean it should be left outside for an extended period of time.
The fire pit also comes with a pack of Tiki Brand of wood pellets; just light the bag for an easy half-hour campfire. Rich found that this fire pit worked equally well using hardwood and wood pellets as fuel. Both options burn very well, but the wood pellets felt like they produced more heat from a distance, although they didn’t burn for as long as the hardwood. However, it was very easy to add another log or two to the fire after the wood pellets died down.
Whether sitting in your back patio or camping by the lake, the Tiki Portable is a great fire pit option for people on the go.
Best for cooking
Rich found the Bali Outdoors 32-inch to be the best fire pit with a grill, and it comes at a great price. Its large, 32-inch diameter interior holds a lot of wood and throws a nice amount of heat to those nearby. It is solidly built, easy to use and very stable. In fact, it seemed to be the best constructed of all the traditional fire pits Rich tested. It comes with an 18-inch adjustable grill that can be swiveled into place at an ideal cooking height, and a collapsible internal log frame to make building your fire a breeze.
The Bali Outdoors 32-inch does not come with a mesh screen cover like the Amazon Basics fire pit, mainly due to its built-in adjustable grill. If you live in an area where local regulations require a screen cover for fire pits, this will likely be a dealbreaker. Rich did, however, like that that grill can be locked into place at different heights or easily removed if not required. He cooked hotdogs evenly with the grill set at the top rim level.
This fire pit had the most pieces to assemble of all the fire pits Rich tested and took about half an hour. However, it had very detailed and intuitive instructions, so it wasn’t difficult. It features a helpful ledge around the rim that works as a great safety bumper as well as a shelf to rest a mug of hot chocolate. The design also includes a ring of steel that overlaps the legs for support. This acts as an additional safety bumper, so you can’t trip over the legs while walking by. It comes with a very short fire poker. Though it works well when the fire burns down and you can get close enough, it will most likely result in singed fingers when the fire is fully stoked.
Rich liked that the fire pit has drain holes in its base in case it gets rained on. Based on reviews, the fire pit can be prone to rust, especially at the base of the bowl and the screen around the fire bowl, but that was similar across all fire pits he reviewed. It is designed to be left outdoors for the season, but rust can be prevented if it’s covered or brought inside when not in use. This fire pit was easy to light and it’s easy to build a large, controlled fire which produces a typical amount of smoke for a traditional fire pit. Overall, it provided an all-around nice fire pit experience — that’s why it’s one of the best fire pits.
Also tested
Rich selected three of the best smokeless fire pits and three of the best traditional fire pits to appear in his roundup, but there were many other hot contenders. Here are some other tested options that might be a better fit for you.
Other smokeless firepits to consider
Why you can trust Tom's Guide Our writers and editors spend hours analyzing and reviewing products, services, and apps to help find what's best for you. Find out more about how we test, analyze, and rate.
How we selected and tested the best fire pits
There are hundreds of fire pits available on the market. The ones chosen for this test were selected because they ranked among the highest in terms of product reviews from reputable brands and vendors. Rich wanted fire pits that were durable, aesthetically pleasing and provided a proper balance of functionality and easy maintenance.
Rich ensured each fire pit was used a minimum of three times and left uncovered outside, exposed to the Western, NY elements for at least one month. He tested every fire pit with ash wood split and cured in standard 16-inch lengths. All fire pits were started with the same fire-starting technique (crumpled-up newspaper and kindling) and the same quantity of wood. If alternate fuels, such as wood pellets were supplied, Rich tried those out too.
Rich tested the effective heat throw of the fire pits by walking towards the burning fire pit until he could feel the heat radiating from it, and he measured the distance. If a fire pit included a grill, Rich tested it out with some good old-fashioned hotdogs.
Of course, no fire pit test is complete without toasted marshmallows, and so marshmallows were toasted once on each pit. This tester’s favorite marshmallow roasting stick is a collapsible model from MalloMe ($9.99, Amazon).
Rich is an experienced farmer and owns and runs McCollum Orchards, which has been in his family for 200 years. He took on the farm with his wife, Bree, in 2011. Working on the farm full-time, with his wife, Rich has vast experience in testing products for Tom's Guide, including products from fire pits to gardening gloves. His manual dexterity and practical insight enable him to comprehensively test and review products to see if they make the grade. McCollum Orchards is an organic fruit, vegetables, and flower farm on a 100-acre site.
What to look for when buying a fire pit
Typically, fire pits have been split into two categories – traditional and smokeless. Within those categories, there are also portable and non-portable designs. The difference between these is usually dependent on weight, the ability to collapse the body and the presence of handles or a carrying bag:
Traditional fire pits
- Made from steel and coated in a heat and rust-resistant paint
- Supported by legs that raise the fire bowl off the ground
- Some have an open, shallow design
- Others have a deep wall encircling the bowl that acts as a wind screen and a spark container — these fire pits are usually wide and heavy and create a “normal” amount of smoke
- Some have attachments for cooking food and can double up as a charcoal grill.
Smokeless fire pits
- Constructed of steel with a double-walled design with strategically placed air holes for improved airflow and less smoke
- Sit low to the ground and usually throw less heat outward when compared to traditional fire pits. Why is this different? The double-wall acts as an insulator and most of the heat is consequently directed straight up.
- Fire burns very efficiently and a little ash is usually all that remains of the wood
- The low-smoke design makes them ideal for crowded areas, where smoke can be bothersome
How to choose the best fire pit for you
Looking for convenience?
Find a fire pit that’s easy to clean. Look for ones that are either large enough to reach into with a dustpan or comes with a removable ash tray.
Are you an RV camper?
If you are just planning to use a fire pit for a few nights relatively close to your vehicle, then a portable version could be a good fit along with one of the best coolers. You can get the comfort and safety of a fire pit in a much smaller and lighter package. Some of the portable devices also double up as grills and even power sources.
Are you a hiker?
If you plan to hike into a campsite, then an ultra-portable fire pit, such as the Fireside Outdoors Pop-Up Pit offers a much safer alternative to your traditional campfire, without taking up much space in your pack.
After a grill experience?
Many fire pits can also use charcoal for a more grill-like cooking experience. The BioLite stove with electric forced air is the best all-around cooking fire pit we reviewed, although it didn't make it into our top three of the best traditional fire pits. If you want to up your outdoor cooking game beyond the traditional grilled hotdog, hamburger or chicken, Solo Stove just came out with a new pizza oven attachment for their Bonfire 2.0 stove. Plus, be sure to check out the best outdoor pizza ovens.
What is the best shape for a firepit?
A round firepit is a common choice. Similar to sitting around a campfire, round pits are ideal for emitting heat evenly around the perimeter, and will help ensure a warm seat for everyone. However, if you have a compact space, a square shape would be more suitable.
Not all fire pit manufacturers are the same
BioLite, for example, designs cookstoves and other products to make cooking safer in developing countries. Fireside Outdoor has a mission to revolutionize the campfire experience by reducing pollution and wildfires that can result from camping.
Pricing
Prices for the fire pits we tested ranged from $119 to $599. We recommend looking for a mix of durability and functionality, at a price you can afford.
