I've already binged all six episodes of Hulu's new football comedy series with Glen Powell — and 'Chad Powers' is a major fumble

Chad Powers (Glen Powell) standing in front of a "Go Fish!" sign in a scene from Disney/Hulu's "Chad Powers" — (Image credit: Disney/DJ Delgado)

Hulu's newest arrival is "Chad Powers," an oddball sports comedy starring and co-created by "Twisters" star Glen Powell. This half-hour series is based on a viral ESPN sketch that saw NFL star Eli Manning heading undercover in full Hollywood makeup as the titular player, to try and live through the experience of walk-on tryouts at Penn State.

In "Chad Powers" the series, the eccentric QB's mythos is expanded into a lengthy "Mrs. Doubtfire" style caper, wherein disgraced college quarterback Russ Holliday (Glen Powell) adopts the identity to take a second shot at football stardom. And, as of today (September 30), the first two episodes of this unique series are available now.

Being both a football fan, intrigued by the premise and — post-"Twisters," "Hit Man" and "Anyone But You," especially — a big fan of the show's main star and co-creator, I was definitely interested to see how Powell and Michael Waldron ("Loki") could turn that segment into a half-hour sports comedy (yes, similar to how"Ted Lasso" made the transition from NBC Sports character to full-bodied Apple TV Plus flagship show).

What is 'Chad Powers' about?

Chad Powers | Official Trailer | Hulu - YouTube

Watch On

"Chad Powers" is a half-hour comedy series that centers on troubled ex-quarterback, Russ Holliday (Powell). Despite being a promising college QB, an unforgivable incident on the field at a Rose Bowl game saw him canceled and put his football career on ice.

Eight years later, our hot-headed lead spots an opportunity to mount his own comeback: the South Georgia Catfish are holding walk-on tryouts. After raiding his father's Hollywood makeup artist stash and adopting his eccentric new alter ego, Russ (as "Chad Powers") heads out onto the field to chase his dreams all over again.

In addition to Powell, "Chad Powers" also stars Perry Mattfeld, Quentin Plair, Wynn Everett, Frankie A. Rodriguez, and Steve Zahn.

'Chad Powers' is serious lacking in the laugh department

Chad Powers (Glen Powell) prepares to throw a football in a scene from Disney/Hulu's &quot;Chad Powers&quot; — (Image credit: Disney/Daniel Delgado Jr.)

It's an offbeat premise to build a show from, it looks pretty well-presented, and Powell and Waldron have added a modest amount of intrigue to the story to make it seem worth expanding beyond a movie. So what's the big problem?

Well, simply put, I just didn't think "Chad Powers" was funny at all. Looking back over the series, I can only really recall one movie makeup mishap that truly got a real giggle out of me. Otherwise, I spent a lot of my viewing time too distracted by the middling writing, the mean-spirited jokes at Chad's expense (specifically about his mental capabilities), the thinly rendered supporting cast, or the fact that, really, our main character is just so hard to root for.

Russ is a selfish, unpleasant asshole, through and through. On the one hand, that's a testament at least to the characterisation, and the actor playing him. But it also makes the show a rough ride, when he's over and above the reason you're there.

Russ Holliday (Glen Powell) sits on a sofa with his arms behind his head in a scene from Disney/Hulu's &quot;Chad Powers&quot; — (Image credit: Disney/Daniel Delgado Jr.)

In a show that's overwhelmingly about Chad and doesn't have much room to sketch out its other characters too much, Russ's presence and motivations loom large. The show, to me, was a double whammy of a character I simply didn't care for, and a sense of humor that didn't work, basically ever, no matter how silly things got.

Comedy is, of course, highly subjective, so for all I know, "Chad Powers" could well be your favorite new arrival this fall. It's fast-moving, well-acted (Perry Mattfeld and Steve Zahn impress the most as a father/daughter coaching duo from the supporting cast), and if the jokes/gags land for you, then it might well be a blast.

Seeing as the episodes cap off at the 40-minute mark at the max, it's easy enough to try "Chad Powers," and curious viewers on the hunt for their next comedy might take to Russ and the jokes more than me. But in my eyes? "Chad Powers" the show isn't the same sort of undiscovered miracle that impresses the South Georgia Catfish coaches; a touchdown this ain't.

The first two episodes of "Chad Powers" are streaming on Hulu and Disney Plus (UK) now. New episodes debut weekly.

Follow Tom's Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button!

More from Tom's Guide

TOPICS

Martin is a Streaming Writer at Tom’s Guide, covering all things movies and TV. If it’s in the theaters or available to stream somewhere, he’s probably watched it… especially if it has a dragon in it. Before joining the team, he was a Staff Writer at What To Watch where he wrote about a broad range of shows that stretched from "Doctor Who" and "The Witcher" to "Bridgerton" and "Love Island". When he’s not watching the next must-see movie or show, he’s probably still in front of a screen playing massive RPGs, reading, spending a fortune on TCGs, or watching the NFL.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.