I tested Sora 2 vs. Grok Imagine with 7 challenging prompts — and there's a clear winner

ChatGPT vs Grok
(Image credit: ChatGPT vs Grok)

As AI gets more sophisticated, tech giants constantly try to outdo each other with the next big thing. This past week has been no different. OpenAI’s Sora 2 launched less than a week ago and practically broke the internet with its TikTok like community of AI videos. Elon Musk’s Grok Imagine has made waves since it came out earlier this summer, but is now free to all users. Since Sora 2 is available by invite only, it’s leaving some users wondering how it compares to Grok.

Here's what happened when I had to put them in a 7-round face-off to see how the AI image generators compare.

1. Animal videos

Prompt: A dramatic, low-angle shot of a tabby cat in a thick, olive-green sweater drinking coffee from a vintage copper mug on a rustic park bench under a canopy of vibrant red and yellow foliage.

Grok Imagine nailed the vibe. It clearly understood the prompt’s whimsy, rendering the cat with almost human-like posture — sitting upright, paws curled around the mug — yet keeping subtle feline details, like the way its eyes closed mid-sip. The result felt cinematic, intentional, and slightly surreal in the best way.

Sora 2, meanwhile, went for realism. Its take showed a lifelike tabby cat sniffing and lapping at the coffee in a way a real cat might, complete with natural movement and believable fur texture. It was beautiful, but less creative than contextual.

Winner: Grok Imagine. If you’re going to put a cat in a chunky turtleneck, it only makes sense to go all-in on the humanlike charm.

2.Urban melancholy

Prompt: A slow pan across a rain-soaked city street at night, where neon reflections ripple in puddles as a lone man in a transparent umbrella waits under a flickering streetlight.

Grok Imagine generated a fairly good video but the man walking was stiff and robot-like. Plus, the man was supposed to be “waiting under a flickering streetlight,” which Grok got wrong here.

Sora 2 created a more realistic image but slightly less interesting. However, it followed the prompt precisely.

Winner: Sora wins for more closely following the prompt and generating a realistic video.

3. Nature in motion

Prompt: A hummingbird hovers mid-air over a bright orange flower, wings beating rapidly in golden morning light as dewdrops fall in slow motion.

Grok Imagine leaned into style over substance. Its take felt more animated than lifelike, with oversized dewdrops that fell more like marbles than mist. The colors were vibrant, but the physics were slightly off — beautiful, just not believable.

Sora 2, on the other hand, produced something mesmerizing. The close-up of the hummingbird was almost photorealistic, complete with soft lighting, natural wing motion, and delicate dewdrops shimmering as they drifted down. The gentle ambient music added to the realism, creating a scene that felt straight out of a nature documentary.

Winner: Sora 2 wins for a visually stunningly video that perfectly captured the delicate balance of motion, light, and calm described in the prompt.

4. Cozy storytelling

Prompt: A corgi wearing a plaid scarf sits by a crackling fireplace, reading a newspaper while sipping tea from a porcelain cup.

Grok Imagine still struggles with the uncanny valley. While the setup was meant to be playful, the video leaned too heavily into obvious This one was full of stiff movement, odd proportions and an overall look that missed the intended humor.

Sora 2, meanwhile, nailed the assignment in its own way. The visuals and sound design were spot-on: the fire crackled realistically, the porcelain cup (although missing tea), and the corgi looked surprisingly natural as it “read.” Even though the prompt was clearly a joke, Sora took it seriously — and it worked.

Winner: Sora 2. Its attention to detail and cinematic polish turned a silly prompt into something unexpectedly charming.

5. Sci-fi worldbuilding

Prompt: A futuristic train speeds through a snowy city at dusk, reflections of holographic billboards dancing across the windows.

Grok Imagine absolutely impressed me with this one. The sweeping camera movement felt cinematic, and the scene came alive with swirling snow, glowing lights, and the rush of the train cutting through the city. It was one of Grok’s most realistic outputs yet.

Sora 2 took it a step further. The reflections of the holographic billboards shimmered across the train’s windows with incredible precision, and the soft, pulsing soundtrack added depth to the atmosphere. Every detail felt intentional, from the lighting to the motion blur.

Winner: Sora 2 wins— by a hair. Grok delivered cinematic flair, but Sora edged ahead with its meticulous attention to detail.

6. Painter’s focus

Prompt: A close-up of an artist’s hands mixing vivid oil paints on a wooden palette as sunlight filters through a nearby window, dust particles drifting in the air.

Grok Imagine could have won this round but the "dust particles" in the prompt seemed to come across as smoke rising from the wooden palette. It's distracting.

Sora 2 beautifully created a realistic video, closely addressing details of the painter's hands and the vibrant paint.

Winner: Sora 2 wins for following the prompt with accuracy.

7. Dreamlike realism

Prompt: A white fox with glowing blue eyes walks slowly through an enchanted forest as luminous butterflies swirl around it, scattering soft light through the fog.

Grok Imagine leaned fully into fantasy. The video looked like it was lifted straight from a storybook — glowing colors, painterly textures, and a dreamlike haze that made the whole scene feel magical. It wasn’t perfectly realistic, but it was mesmerizing to watch.

Sora 2 took a more grounded approach. The fox moved with believable weight and fluidity, and the fog rolled naturally through the forest. It blended realism with a touch of wonder, though it felt more cinematic than enchanted.

Winner: Grok Imagine wins. Its stylized glow and ethereal tone better captured the fantasy spirit of the prompt, proving that sometimes, imagination wins over accuracy.

Overall winner: Sora 2

After seven rounds, Sora 2 ultimately took the crown. However, it's clear that both Sora 2 and Grok Imagine are among the best AI video generators available.

Grok leans into personality and flair, often producing videos that feel stylized and bold, even when they miss some realism. Sora 2 is in a league of its own when it comes to cinematic polish, life-like imagery and motion.

Where Grok thrives on creativity, Sora excels in precision, and that difference might decide which one you reach for. If you want surreal, meme-ready visuals that pop on social media, Grok is your tool. But if you’re hoping for the kind of video that could pass for a professional production, Sora 2 is hard to beat.

Follow Tom's Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button!

More from Tom's Guide

Category
Arrow
Arrow
Back to Laptops
Brand
Arrow
Processor
Arrow
RAM
Arrow
Storage Size
Arrow
Screen Size
Arrow
Colour
Arrow
Condition
Arrow
Storage Type
Arrow
Price
Arrow
Any Price
Showing 10 of 313 deals
Filters
Arrow
Show more
Amanda Caswell
AI Editor

Amanda Caswell is an award-winning journalist, bestselling YA author, and one of today’s leading voices in AI and technology. A celebrated contributor to various news outlets, her sharp insights and relatable storytelling have earned her a loyal readership. Amanda’s work has been recognized with prestigious honors, including outstanding contribution to media.

Known for her ability to bring clarity to even the most complex topics, Amanda seamlessly blends innovation and creativity, inspiring readers to embrace the power of AI and emerging technologies. As a certified prompt engineer, she continues to push the boundaries of how humans and AI can work together.

Beyond her journalism career, Amanda is a long-distance runner and mom of three. She lives in New Jersey.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.