Download the
Tom's Guide App from the AppsStore
News and trends on internet
/ mobile / "sound & picture" / IT
Yes No
Ads

The Anti-Dock: Sonos 2.0 Reviewed

- by

9. Conclusions: Free Audio From Your iPod

Not having tested the SqueezeBox Duet side-by-side with the new Sonos Bundle 150, I can’t choose one over the other. But I can say that the Sonos Bundle 150 is a heck of a lot more fun, versatile, flexible and easy to use than my original-model SqueezeBox. That’s an easy contest: multi-room listening is a simple yet powerful new way to experience music, and remote control of these multiple rooms is a relief from a hot and heavy laptop.

My back of the envelope math, however, puts the Sonos system at about a $250 premium to the "comparable" SqueezeBox Duet system. Sonos’ proprietary wireless network is smarter and more reliable than my cable company router, and I definitely like being able to turn off my PC and let the Sonos controller find music elsewhere in the house (networked storage, and so forth.). Are these benefits, as well as the good looks of the Sonos hardware (to my taste), worth $250? Perhaps to some. If I hadn’t already invested in a SqueezeBox years ago, I might buy a Sonos today. And I’d easily recommend the Sonos system to somebody with few budgetary constraints.

If your only solution to listening to digital music in your house has been to set up an iPod dock in your living room, or to congregate your family around the office PC and its less-than-stellar speakers, I encourage you to read about the options available to you for bringing digital audio into any and all the rooms of your house. It isn’t exactly cheap, but at least one of the broadband-reliant solutions on the market today will get you excited about listening to music again.

Share:
14
Comments
X

Comment:

Read the comments on the forums
ro53ben 08/05/2008 10:57 AM
Hide
-0+

A couple of tips:

1) When scrolling through the artist list on the Sonos controller, push the soft button labelled "PowerScroll". This will allow you to skip straight to any letter in the alphabet, like the W you mentioned in the review. This function was added by Sonos a couple of years ago following customer requests.

2)Sonos can actually play some DRM protected files from stores that use MS Play for Sure technology.

3) Get your microwave checked out, the magnetron really shouldn't leak that much interference and may be unsafe. Getting a unit with better shielding won't just improve your wifi signals, it will help protect your husband's fertility more than getting that laptop of his thighs!

ro53ben 08/05/2008 10:58 AM
Hide
-0+

A couple of tips:

1) When scrolling through the artist list on the Sonos controller, push the soft button labelled "PowerScroll". This will allow you to skip straight to any letter in the alphabet, like the W you mentioned in the review. This function was added by Sonos a couple of years ago following customer requests.

2)Sonos can actually play some DRM protected files from stores that use MS Play for Sure technology.

3) Get your microwave checked out, the magnetron really shouldn't leak that much interference and may be unsafe. Getting a unit with better shielding won't just improve your wifi signals, it will help protect your husband's fertility more than getting that laptop of his thighs!

Anonymous 08/05/2008 11:51 AM
Hide
-0+

On the price comparison: With Logitech yet get two unamplified Zones for $599, to compare with the Sonos bundle you need to figure in the cost for an amp as well, which is included in the ZP120

Anonymous 08/05/2008 12:08 PM
Hide
-0+

Another note: Sonos does offer a "jump to" option to jump to a certain letter. It is on the left soft button (below the screen).

Tomsguiderachel 08/05/2008 2:18 PM
Hide
-0+

ro53ben :
A couple of tips:1) When scrolling through the artist list on the Sonos controller, push the soft button labelled "PowerScroll". This will allow you to skip straight to any letter in the alphabet, like the W you mentioned in the review. This function was added by Sonos a couple of years ago following customer requests.2)Sonos can actually play some DRM protected files from stores that use MS Play for Sure technology.3) Get your microwave checked out, the magnetron really shouldn't leak that much interference and may be unsafe. Getting a unit with better shielding won't just improve your wifi signals, it will help protect your husband's fertility more than getting that laptop of his thighs!


Thanks Ro53ben, great advice about the microwave. It is likely an old machine. :)

The powerscroll function worked for me, but it still requires the gesture of scrolling, which can get tiresome, I found, If I was making a long list of songs.

Tomsguiderachel 08/05/2008 2:22 PM
Hide
-0+

Avee :
On the price comparison: With Logitech yet get two unamplified Zones for $599, to compare with the Sonos bundle you need to figure in the cost for an amp as well, which is included in the ZP120


Thanks Avee. If you do another read of my review, you'll see that I did factor the amp into the price comparison. I said you'd need to pay (at the absolute least) $200 for an amp for your extra SqueezeBox unit, which would bring the price difference down quite a bit. I am assuming the consumer owns at least one amp (Sonos makes the same assumption with its bundle).

-Rachel

Anonymous 08/05/2008 4:44 PM
Hide
-0+

I know that this is a Sonos review, but since you brought up SB and Roku, I would like to see a more detailed comparison between them. SlimServer is a very powerful piece of (free!) software that is open source and has several plug-ins available for it. I haven't used SqueezeCenter yet. I don't know how the Sonos server compares. Also, since Roku can connect to SlimServer, it can reap all the rewards of it *at a much lower cost*...

Anonymous 08/05/2008 7:12 PM
Hide
-0+

I agree, you are giving Slim Devices the short end of the stick when overlooking its openness. There are alot of plugins. At least a year ago, this was not the case with sonos. This along with price is why I choose it over the Sonos. I am using a wireless PDA to control the slimserver. You can use your cell phone too. Why bother carrying another control when you cell is always right there?

nukemaster 08/06/2008 1:05 AM
Hide
-0+

ro53ben :
Get your microwave checked out, the magnetron really shouldn't leak that much interference and may be unsafe. Getting a unit with better shielding won't just improve your wifi signals, it will help protect your husband's fertility more than getting that laptop of his thighs!


I have yet to see ANY microwave(high and low powered) not have some amount of impact on wireless B and G. A would have been a better choice(unless I missed it in there somewhere). We have gone through many a microwave so I can confirm that this is a normal behavior for a 2.4 GHZ device. 2.4 GHZ phones will static if they are analog skip if they are digital unless they are extremely powerful units.

Even the manual on many wireless routers warns about 2.4GHZ interference from phones/bluetooth and microwaves.

I can sit my laptop between 2(Yes 2) microwaves running and music is fine, but video is a lost cause. The router is fairly high powered.

Bottom line, you should have have to worry. Getting your access point higher may help. Changing the channels and seeing whats best is also a good idea.

nukemaster 08/06/2008 1:06 AM
Hide
-0+

Oppsy

you should NOT have have to worry

ro53ben 08/06/2008 11:21 AM
Hide
-0+

Just realised that you never mention how the Sonos controller is splash proof. I took the testing of this to the extreme...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aqHdxVK9cvI

Anonymous 08/06/2008 7:13 PM
Hide
-0+

I have had Sonos for three years now. I have two Russound whole-house audio systems that are tied together giving me 12 zones throughout the house. I added a Sonos zone controller and have four hand held Sonos units. I could not be happier with the setup. I have Siruis radio and it streams in all 12 zones if I want. Also, I have found Sonos' customer support to be one of the best. It will be interesting to see if they keep it up as they grow.

Anonymous 08/09/2008 11:29 PM
Hide
-0+

Software in Sonos is pretty boring. eJukebox is better for parties.

Anonymous 01/20/2011 4:11 AM
Hide
-0+

I see that these reviews are all from the year 2008. It is now 2011 but I hope someone will respond. I am reading many reviews and all are very positive aboout the Sonos system except two. One said that the 55 watt per channel outpu is somewhat weak and will not allow speakers to crank very loud. The other negative was that the remote allows only the artist to be searched (on i-tunes I suppose) but not all of the individual songs, Are these complaints valid ? Any thoughts or advice ? I currently have four "zones" (living room, basement, deck, and family room) all wired to a very old receiver/amp/CD player. I need to upgrade and Sonos seems like my ticket. Should I bust a move or look around. You guys seem like you'd help me decide. Thanks.