I drove the Volkswagen Atlas and Kia Telluride for a week — here’s the mid-size 3-row SUV I recommend

I’ve tested more 3-row SUVs this year than any other type of vehicle, and the market appetite for them is only growing. While full-size SUVs like the Infiniti QX80 and Chevrolet Tahoe are classic examples of three-row haulers, more and more mid-size crossovers are now engineered to offer that exact same versatility.

That’s why I drove the Volkswagen Atlas and Kia Telluride for a week each to find out which of these mid-size 3-row SUVs has the better value. Both offer expansive interiors, distinct rugged-leaning trim options, and standard all-wheel drive, but after spending a week with each one, clear differences emerged.

I specifically tested out the 2027 Kia Telluride X-Pro SX-Prestige AWD and 2026 Volkswagen Atlas Peak Edition, with as-tested prices of $59,580 and $50,230 respectively. There’s roughly a $9,000 spread between them, but these top-of-the-line trims showcase two very different philosophies — so I’ll tell you exactly which one I recommend.

Volkswagen Atlas vs. Kia Telluride: Specifications

Volkswagen Atlas vs. Kia Telluride: Design

Image 1 of 8

Both designs lean heavily into rugged, road-dominating stances that set them apart from standard family haulers, but it’s a dead heat in my opinion. The Volkswagen Atlas Peak Edition embraces a more contemporary look, featuring dark 18-inch wheels with all-terrain tires, gloss-black exterior trim, and illuminated front and rear lightbars that make the glowing VW emblems pop.

With the Avocado Green Pearl paint job, it definitely adds to its rugged style, while the interior follows a similar modern look with black leatherette seats accented by grey panels, vibrant orange contrast stitching, and stainless steel pedal caps.

By comparison, the Kia Telluride X-Pro SX-Prestige delivers an almost stealth-fighter visual presence that very much reminds me of the BMW XM Label — but in a boxier frame. Its wide-body proportions, vertical LED headlights, and Terrain Brown Matte finish really accentuate its militaristic look.

On the inside, it leans heavily into executive luxury with a sprawling cockpit anchored by dual 12.3-inch panoramic displays, engineered wood accents, and SynTex suede seating with heated and ventilated captain’s chairs in the first two rows.

Ultimately, both designs excel at turning heads in completely different ways — the Atlas with its sharp, no-nonsense German utility, and the Telluride with its urban, minimalistic aesthetic.

Winner: tie

Volkswagen Atlas vs. Kia Telluride: Fuel economy

On paper, the EPA gives a slight edge to the 2026 Volkswagen Atlas Peak Edition with its 21 MPG combined rating compared to the 2027 Kia Telluride X-Pro’s 19 MPG combined. In my real-world testing, however, both mid-size 3-row SUVs delivered virtually identical efficiency over hundreds of mixed miles, averaging a nearly indistinguishable 22.5 mpg in the Atlas and 22.6 mpg in the Telluride.

The Atlas proves more consistent on quick stop-and-go trips, reaching a best short-distance run of 17.3 mpg versus the Telluride's 14.1 mpg. Meanwhile, the Telluride nudges slightly ahead on highway cruising, topping out at 26 mpg compared to the Atlas’s 25.9 mpg.

What’s really remarkable when testing them is just how responsive the Atlas feels on the road. With its snappier throttle response and sports car-like dynamic performance, I thought it’d be more of a gas guzzler — yet it manages to stay right on par with the Telluride.

Winner: Tie

Volkswagen Atlas vs. Kia Telluride: Driving performance

Image 1 of 6

Under the hood, both SUVs take different paths to deliver four-cylinder power. The Kia Telluride X-Pro relies on a turbocharged 2.5-liter engine pushing out 274 horsepower and 311 lb-ft of torque, while the Volkswagen Atlas Peak Edition uses a 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder making 269 horsepower and 273 lb-ft of torque. While the Telluride technically holds a slight advantage on paper, my experience driving them tells a completely different story.

The Atlas takes the victory here thanks to its surprisingly agile, sports car-like handling and lively power delivery. It accelerates with ease, offering a snappier throttle response that makes merging, overtaking, and tackling local roads feel effortless. What makes the VW's performance even more impressive is cabin refinement — the engine operates noticeably quieter under load compared to the louder to its rival.

While the Telluride delivers a smooth and easy drive, it does feel like it lumbers around curves due to its heavier weight. It’s simply not as agile.

Winner: Volkswagen Atlas

Volkswagen Atlas vs. Kia Telluride: Comfort

Image 1 of 7

While both SUVs offer plenty of space for families, including 2nd-row captain’s chairs, sunshades for the rear windows, and sprawling panoramic glass roofs, the 2027 Kia Telluride X-Pro SX-Prestige gets my vote for being on an entirely different level.

Upfront, the driver’s seat features Ergo Motion tech that initiates a light massaging function after extended periods of driving, a crisp head-up display, and a dedicated lane-centering assist button right on the steering wheel for effortless highway cruising. Backing up or navigating tight spaces is equally simple thanks to its digital rearview mirror and a 360-degree surround view monitor, which includes a blind-spot view monitor that projects a live feed right into the instrument cluster when I activate the corresponding turn signal.

Meanwhile, the 2026 Volkswagen Atlas Peak Edition certainly holds its own with a comfortable layout, a bright 12-inch touchscreen, and heated and ventilated front seats. It also includes an adaptive front lighting system with headlights that physically swivel in the direction I steer. However, it falls noticeably short on high-end tech features. For example, it relies on just a standard backup camera rather than a full 360-degree surround camera system, and it lacks advanced luxury touches like an HUD or digital rearview mirror that make the Telluride feel like a premium cruiser.

Winner: Kia Telluride

Volkswagen Atlas vs. Kia Telluride: Value

Image 1 of 10

When comparing sticker prices, the 2026 Volkswagen Atlas Peak Edition appears to have the price advantage at $50,230. But while the Atlas delivers a comprehensive set of daily necessities, you’re getting more value with the Telluride despite costing more.

That’s because you aren't just paying for the cosmetics, you’re getting luxury-tier equipment like massaging driver's seats, digital rearview mirror, 360-degree cameras, and everything else I’ve mentioned already.

On top of that, Kia backs the Telluride with an industry-leading 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranty (compared to VW’s 4-year/50,000-mile coverage), offering long-term peace of mind that bridges the price gap and makes the Telluride feel like a much better investment.

Winner: Kia Telluride

Volkswagen Atlas vs. Kia Telluride: Verdict

Image 1 of 8

I can’t deny how these family haulers are excellent at offering outstanding utility with their 3-row seating, especially with how easily you can fold down the 3rd-row bench seats to expand trunk space. If driving dynamics are high on your priority list, the 2026 Volkswagen Atlas Peak Edition is easily the more engaging choice. Its sports car-like responsiveness, nimble handling around curves, and quieter cabin under acceleration make it a genuine pleasure to drive every day.

However, when I consider the total package, the 2027 Kia Telluride X-Pro SX-Prestige AWD earns my recommendation. While I personally prefer the Atlas's livelier driving performance, the Telluride's overwhelming luxury tech suite simply seals the deal. You’re definitely paying more, but that price difference is well worth it.

Follow Tom's Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds.

More from Tom's Guide

• I'm not anxious that it's getting darker earlier with this thermal camera for my car — here's why
• I just test drove the new Nissan Leaf — and it's irresistible at under $30,000
• CrabWalking with the GMC Sierra EV is the weirdest thing I’ve ever done with a car — and it’s actually pretty useful