HTC Sues Apple Over Patents, Again
HTC has launched another lawsuit against Apple, claiming that Macs, iPhones, iPads, Apple TV, AirPort, Time Capsule, and the iPod infringe three of its patents.
As it is common for such suits, HTC wants Apple to be banned from violating its patents, which would include an order that would force Apple to halt making, selling, or importing any infringing devices. There is also the usual request for Apple to pay damages for willful infringement, as well as compensation for HTC's attorney fees.
HTC lists three patents, two of which were granted in 2008 and one in 2010. The documents refer to (1) a circuit and operating method for integrated interface of PDA and wireless communicating system, (2) multipoint-to-point communication using orthogonal frequency division multiplexing and (3) a method for orderwire modulation. The suit is just another chapter in an ongoing smartphone patent war that was, in this case, started by Apple with a suit against Apple that affected a total of 20 Apple patents. According to the International Trade Commission, HTC may have infringed on two Apple patents and we were under the impression that HTC was in talks with Apple to settle the claims.
This most recent lawsuit suggests that Apple and HTC may be negotiating for quite a while.
- China's Fake Apple Stores Become Smart
- This Optical Disc Stores Your Data in "Rock"
- These $500 Glasses Simulate a 75-Inch Screen
- This is the World's Largest Stop Motion Animation
- Adobe Announces WYSIWYG HTML5 Design Tool
- Google Attacks Lodsys Over Android App Suits
- The Next Particle Collider is Taking Shape
- Pimp Your Bike With This Flashy Safety Lighting
- Asus Releases Specs on Eee Pad Slider Tablet
- Redbox is Testing Higher Movie Rental Prices
- Facebook Wants to End Anonymity on Internet
- Businesses Complain of .xxx "Blackmail"
- Mozilla Moves Thunderbird to Rapid Release Cycle
- New Goodyear Tires Keep Themselves Inflated
- Samsung Galaxy Tab Injunction Lifted Across Europe
- Microsoft Announces the End of its Reader Application
- Wake Up to a Sunrise Anytime with the LUMI Sleepmask
- Apple Accused of Altering Galaxy Tab Image for Lawsuit
- Matte is In: Xbox 360 to Lose its Glossy Finish
Can someone explain the part "started by Apple with a suit against Apple that affected a total of 20 Apple patents.", I'm confused, did apple sue themselves?
Scenario: HTC lawyers and Apple lawyers get together over lunch. Both want bonuses. They agree to sue each other visibly, loudly. Nothing comes of the lawsuit AT ALL. The patent cross-licensing agreement which was in the works happens as expected. Except for some reason, the lawyers get big checks where they wouldn't have before.
The name for this kind of "stir up trouble just to get paid" practice "barratry". I'm just hoping the Boards of Directors of both HTC and Apple realize their own lawyers are playing them for chumps.
Yeah! Apple now sues Apple for infringing on Apples copyrights!
Thumbs up if you think Tom's should be renamed "iTom's Hardware"!
brain explodes
Oh how happy Id be if apple products were halted! something I know isnt going to happen...
@weaselsmasher
Or may be one of them (most likely apple) wants to play hardball hence the spiraling legal dispute?
Yeah! Apple now sues Apple for infringing on Apples copyrights!
JA JA JA JA JA JA !!! WOW PEOPLE ON APPLE ARE "SMART" !!
How about they just stop...I mean suing erryone doesn't seem to ever get anyone anywhere.
Props to the comments about apple suing apple...that just made me lol so hard.
I'm sure of one thing: Lawyers couldn't be happier.
4 spams in row Time to feed your site to the sharks!!!
Even though it is using Apple tactics, I still think it is wrong. Unfortunately this is the only thing they can do with the broken system. Apple shoved them in this corner and they face an import ban. Any company would do anything to get out of this.
Damn Apples amazing marketing team for making the company be able to draw out court proceedings with their vast accumulation of $$$.
I hope the only thing that comes out of this is a patent reform.
Yeah! Apple now sues Apple for infringing on Apples copyrights!
Apple just couldn't leave a company in the list "un-sued", it was too tempting not to make ipods based on iphones tech and then even further blatantly making ipads - that was the last straw.
Jobs should pay for this... I mean to his employees.
Apple can't lose in anyway. If Apple loses the case, Apple will sue the judge for not letting them win the case. Apple wins either way!
Hope HTC wins, it will be intresting to see how many products are left on the shelf if all these where banned from import into the EU and the USA.
Apple already got one product banned, so they have set the presadent. Its only safe to assume that if someone else where to try the same thing it would follow through with less resistance.
JA JA JA JA JA JA !!! WOW PEOPLE ON APPLE ARE "SMART" !! LOL
Really? I mean honestly.. you're on tomshardware(guide) U.S. What this means is, we speak English. It's "HA HA HA HA HA HA" not "JA JA JA JA JA JA" and here you are trying to make people "ON" Apple look ignorant?!?
that makes a total of 8 spams in one article and I bet the numbers will simply skyrocket in time.
Frankly speaking, it's an eyesore, one that shouldn't be present in a website that's all about tech news.
Come on tom's, shouldn't you at least do something to make the reading experience less painful than it already is? err..please?
Thank you.
At the rate crapple is xxxing off companies they will have a hard time defending themselves against the tons of companies that make android phones, android pads and other hardware used in their.
Any bets how long it will take before apple is baned from the markets due to the legal battles they pretty much started?
Well considering that Apple often launches attacks first, I'd say this is just a pre-emptive strike by HTC.
Does too much apple make you green out? Because that would make sense.
Well considering that Apple often launches attacks first, I'd say this is just a pre-emptive strike by HTC.
Isn't Apple already suing HTC and trying to stop import of their products? If so then this is HTC retaliating and trying to defend itself and not a preemptive strike.
i guess apple better brace itself. now that Google got all moto's patents i bet apple is infringing on tons of them
how to tell when reporters are submitting half truths in their articles that favor their side of view point and false claims to stir up controversy like politicians
#1 listed the description of what the patents is about, not the actual patent or listing of the patent or even the patent number for people to research themselves with the library of congress.
#2 a company sues itself
here is a little advice that still holds true from a man that's been dead for over 200 years.
Thomas Jefferson
Do not bite at the bait of pleasure, till you know there is no hook beneath it.
Thomas Jefferson
Thomas Jefferson
He who knows nothing is closer to the truth than he whose mind is filled with falsehoods and errors.
Thomas Jefferson
Great Apple has began self destructing by suing itself.