Download the
Tom's Guide App from the AppsStore
News and trends on internet
/ mobile / "sound & picture" / IT
Yes No

MPAA Calls SOPA Blackout Day Dangerous and Irresponsible

- By - Source : Tom's Guide US

The MPAA is slamming sites that are participating in Blackout Day, calling the protest an abuse of power.

As of this writing, numerous sites plan to participate in Blackout Day in protest of the still-not-dead pro-censorship SOPA legislation. These sites include Destructoid, Facebook, Google, Mozilla, Reddit, Tuscows, Wikipedia, WordPress, XDA-Developers and many others. The protest, which will span from linked anti-SOPA material to complete website blackouts, depending on the site, will last from 8AM EST to 8PM EST.

On Tuesday the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) had the nerve to strike out against those expressing Free Speech (PDF), calling the protest "dangerous" and "irresponsible" although there's no indication that any harm will come to surfers who come across a link or a blank page. The letter, written by Senator Chris Dodd, Chairman and CEO of the MPAA, went public on Tuesday, and arrives after the White House blasted both the SOPA and PIPA legislation to the point of near-death.

According to Senator Dodd, "technology business interests" are resorting to stunts that punish their users or turn them into corporate pawns rather than coming to the table to find solutions. "It is an irresponsible response and a disservice to people who rely on them for information and use their services," he writes. "It is also an abuse of power given the freedoms these companies enjoy in the marketplace today."

Let's stop right there. Isn't that like the pot calling the kettle black? Isn't it an abuse in power of sorts when the MPAA dictates how and where consumers can watch movies and TV purchased with their own hard-earned money? Why is it that consumers can't buy a digital movie or TV and watch it on a device of their choosing? The general public is seemingly treated like pirates by default, even if a good portion is honest and only want to watch their favorite episodes of Glee on multiple platforms without harsh legal repercussions.

Of course, an opinion like that posted on a popular website will likely be purposely misinterpreted by content owners and their representative to appear as an abuse of power in itself, a diabolical scheme Senator Dodd points out in his letter. "It’s a dangerous and troubling development when the platforms that serve as gateways to information intentionally skew the facts to incite their users in order to further their corporate interests," he writes.

"A so-called 'blackout' is yet another gimmick, albeit a dangerous one, designed to punish elected and administration officials who are working diligently to protect American jobs from foreign criminals," the Senator continues. "It is our hope that the White House and the Congress will call on those who intend to stage this 'blackout' to stop the hyperbole and PR stunts and engage in meaningful efforts to combat piracy."

There's no question that Washington need to find a way to legally prevent piracy without violating the Constitution or the rights of those living outside the States. Shooting first and asking questions later is not the way to solve the issue -- it will just make things worse. Loosen the grip Hollywood, and maybe consumers won't feel the need to download digital content from BitTorrent because DRM has it locked to just a handful of devices.

But to Hollywood's credit, UltraViolet may be a step in the right direction in regards to video content: one purchase, and one app that can play the video across multiple platforms. Still, the format has a long way to go before it even comes close to solving piracy.

Read our stance on SOPA here.

Share:
92
Comments
X

Comments

memadmax 01/18/2012 12:36 PM
Hide
-20+

Lol, abuse of power?
The hypocrisy is mind boggling....
We know the MPAA is throwing buttloads of cash at politicians in order to woo them to their side...

Besides, it's THEIR website, NOT THEIR'S... they can do whatever they FRICKIN WANT!

cappinhoff 01/18/2012 12:36 PM
Hide
-20+

Ironic the MPAA is calling this "an abuse of power". Though these black outs will have the same effect as the gas outs people are doing.

De5_roy 01/18/2012 12:39 PM
Hide
-20+

if anyone abuses power it's organizations like mpaa and riaa.

DSpider 01/18/2012 12:46 PM
Hide
-20+

They're just giving us a little taste of what's to come. If the bill passes, entire websites will go down because of what their users did (knowingly or unknowingly, that's the problem here). Just read Wikipedia articles from Google's cache pages for now... Good thing finals are usually held in February else a lot of students would be affected. Hahahaha.

lightzy 01/18/2012 12:46 PM
Hide
-20+

You idiots made this idiot a senator?

And you stand by this? complaining on some tech website instead of sending letters to congress and your state?

kinggraves 01/18/2012 12:47 PM
Hide
-20+

This just in:

Cockroaches disapprove of bug spray.

rantoc 01/18/2012 12:49 PM
Hide
-20+

I think its GOOD that they do it, showing what happens when our politicians give out the "kill switch" to organizations that have a sole interest of making more money at _any_ cost.

And i "love" when the politicians have side interests that "don't" influence their political work "Senator Chris Dodd, Chairman and CEO of the MPAA". When politicians start to work for the industry the common mans rights get thrown out of the window - It have to stop!

danjimaru 01/18/2012 12:51 PM
Hide
-20+

In soviet russia internet's abusive power killed the VCR; it's true!!

Anonymous 01/18/2012 12:54 PM
Hide
-20+

I think we just found the achille's heal of America's crooked government. This reeeeeeaaaaalllly seems to bother them.

Imagine if all of the IT workers of America all formed a single labor union, and all agreed to strike on the same day if congress doesn't agree to outlaw lobbying, impose term limits, restore civil liberties, and quit spending trillions on pointless wars.

LLJones 01/18/2012 1:07 PM
Hide
-20+

I swear that people who become politicians are, for the vast majority, a different species. They may look and talk like humans, but there is no way they are. OK maybe a different race.

jescott418 01/18/2012 1:25 PM
Show
anony2004 01/18/2012 1:29 PM
Hide
-18+

memadmax :
Lol, abuse of power?The hypocrisy is mind boggling....


It surely is, mind-boggling and saddening at the same time because it comes from such high powers...

jrharbort 01/18/2012 1:31 PM
Hide
-20+

So shutting down your own website that you own isn't fine. That's power abuse.

But granting them the power to shut down and block websites against our will is fine. That's not power abuse.

*brain explodes*

unther 01/18/2012 1:47 PM
Hide
-17+

politics is another world on to itself, and lets face it politicians will be politicians. There are no statesmen in politics these days anyway. A true statesmen is able to take a step back and do what is right for the country, not what is in the best interest of their political career.

christop 01/18/2012 1:49 PM
Hide
-14+

Google is already doing the black out on their logo and link to the anti SOPA. I hope this crap doesn't pass cause the net will be screwed.

unther 01/18/2012 1:52 PM
Hide
-4+

Google for me is fine, but wikipedia is blacked out. Maybe because I'm from Canada?

edvinasm 01/18/2012 1:52 PM
Hide
-4+

Technology age and freedom of the word me arse. Sorry for my Irish.. Seems like politicians will do whatever they want unless it would anger the public to the point where everyone will march to throw them out. We'll be on 80s level in no time in terms of publicity and freedom of word.

watcha 01/18/2012 2:05 PM
Hide
-12+

unther :
Google for me is fine, but wikipedia is blacked out. Maybe because I'm from Canada?



I've been using Google cache to work around this - it's all English speaking countries.

jrharbort :
So shutting down your own website that you own isn't fine. That's power abuse.But granting them the power to shut down and block websites against our will is fine. That's not power abuse.*brain explodes*



+100000

cappster 01/18/2012 2:12 PM
Hide
-11+

The blackout is in full effect. This is an example of how powerful computer nerds can be when we unite! We can take over the world pinky!

gtvr 01/18/2012 2:13 PM
Hide
-4+

Technically, he is a former Senator. He couldn't serve as MPAA president & be in congress at the same time.

Darkerson 01/18/2012 2:13 PM
Hide
-7+

Wow, thats rich, coming from them. Such audacity...

codefuapprentice 01/18/2012 2:30 PM
Hide
-16+

Definately Pot calling the kettle black, they're willing to dish out censorship left right and center, but they oppose it if someone else does it in protest, IDIOTS!!

Anonymous 01/18/2012 3:01 PM
Hide
-10+

LOSERS!

LORD_ORION 01/18/2012 3:04 PM
Hide
-3+

unther :
Google for me is fine, but wikipedia is blacked out. Maybe because I'm from Canada?



From reading the Wikipedia entry on this event (lol) it seems the entire English version of the site is on Blackout.

wild9 01/18/2012 3:04 PM
Hide
-16+

Let me tell you what I think is "dangerous" and "irresponsible".. letting corporations dictate politics and law. You end up with things like the Obama administration, the Council on Foreign Relations, the offshore banking interests. These forces are so powerful they have the capacity to start wars at the drop of a hat, the capacity to drive economies into the ground, and force billions of people into starvation. They are capable of destroying much that our forefathers fought to protect, including our rights, our land, and our freedoms. They are the driving force behind Capitol Hill, they control what Obama says and what Obama does, not Obama and not the American people. Why do you think all signs are pointing to a war in the Middle East? Why do you thin illegal immigration is so rife in the US? Why do you think so many Americans are losing their rights? It's not by accident.

This cabal, this bast8rdised form of democracy, is behind it all. Everything. It does not happen by accident. They will use one thing (piracy) as a pretext to achieving something else, something far more sinister than looking after the interests of copyright holders.

"protect American jobs from foreign criminals"? Folks this is a family site, a global family. I could really say in all the gory detail just how utterly hypocritical a statement like that is, but I won't. I'll just say this: protecting American jobs from criminals also means protecting Americans from the enemy within.

video_master 01/18/2012 3:08 PM
Hide
-16+

When are we as a nation going to pull our heads out of our butts and finally do something about this travesty of a government that has been let to happen. We need to step up and get rid of all of these idiots in our government so we can get real people in there that will make our nation great again.

Anonymous 01/18/2012 3:13 PM
Hide
-20+

This A$$ Dodd was also neck deep in the whole Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac debacle. This guy is a walking, talking, dumpster fire. That is is now a hired thug for the MPAA is not a suprise.

msgun98 01/18/2012 3:20 PM
Hide
-3+

I loved the Dodd/Frank Bill to help re-regulate the financial system, but this is not the good fight for Chris Dodd. It's impossible to get someone to see the truth when their paycheck requires them not to.

spookyman 01/18/2012 3:21 PM
Hide
-14+

What amazes how many folks who complain refuse to use their political power and vote. Why do we only vote Democrat or Republican? Either party is the same evil 2 headed snake. Vote third party. It would send a message we are tired of both parties.

Another tactic some states use on governors now is recalling them. Any Senator or Representative that would vote for this should be recalled and replaced. recalling takes a grass roots approach and should be used liberally.


wild9 01/18/2012 3:26 PM
Hide
-6+

Quote :Shooting first and asking questions later is not the way to solve the issue.


Pity someone didn't say that before American lives were lost in Iraq. Not to mention the million plus dead civilians, and the millions still living in abject poverty. I think this administration is well versed in shooting first and asking questions later, why stop when it's so profitable for them? Why stop when it can achieve so many objectives? Without the Iraq war th US would have zero business being in that region, save for oil.

Seems that Congress does not really answer to the American people, more so it answers to offshore banking interests who have sailed this country - economically and socially - up the creek without a paddle. Worse, America is indebted to these interests for years to come. It's like trying to pay off a debt you can never pay off, no matter how much money you can print. Just about the only growth industry in the US is war, debt, and the often ruthless seizure of assets including land. That is, until there is NOTHING left to take.

Funny how wars always seem to start in dire economic times.

Anonymous 01/18/2012 3:27 PM
Hide
-10+

Wait a minute.... A Senator AND Chairman and CEO of the MPAA?? Umm.. conflict of interest much?