Apple is Watching Palm Pre for IP Infringement

By Jane McEntegart, published on January 22, 2009 at 8:50 AM
Source: Tom's Hardware UK | Keywords: , , , , | Themes: Smartphones, Business
Syndication: Add to your Google homepage Add to My Yahoo!

All of our gushing about the Palm Pre aside (or the Palm Pretty as some of us in the office have taken to calling it), it looks like Apple might not be so hot on Palm’s latest addition to the touch screen smartphone race.

The Pre was launched at CES in the first week of January and it impressed pretty much everyone at the conference. Sure, not all of us liked it, but most conceded that Palm deserved kudos for coming up with something so different to what it had before. Palm said it was going after the “fat middle market” that is the people who want to use a smartphone for both work and play (as opposed to the iPhone’s mostly play reputation and RIM’s mostly work history) but people immediately started comparing it to the iPhone.

It seems Apple is none too pleased about this. Gizmodo points to remarks from Tim Cook, the man Steve Jobs has left in charge, and says that Apple is hinting that the Pre is ripping off the iPhone IP. Uh oh.

Tim Cook said the company welcomed competition as long as the other team doesn’t play dirty and if they do, Apple won’t be taking crap from anyone.

"We like competition as long as they don't rip off our IP. And we're going to go after anybody that does."

That said, when an analyst asked if he was talking about the Pre, because you know, everyone assumed he was talking about the Pre, Cook replied that he was just making a general statement about how much Apple hates to be ripped off.

"I'm making a general statement...We will not stand for having our IP ripped off," and Apple will use any "weapons at our disposal."

Hmm, is someone a little bitter that iPod God, Jon Rubinstein, is now leading Palm’s research, development, and engineering? Wait and see, I suppose.

Read our coverage of the Palm Pre here.

Comments | Print | Send to a friend
Slideshows related to this news

Sponsored links

Comments

PrangeWay 01/22/2009 3:20 PM
Hide
-6+

God forbid Palm produces products in the market IT invented. People talk about Microsoft as a corporate bully, but Apple really sets the standard in both competetion bullying, and locking customers into proprietary formats. Bleh.

neiroatopelcc 01/22/2009 3:27 PM
Hide
-1+

"I'm making a general statement...We will not stand for having our IP ripped off," and Apple will use any "weapons at our disposal."
Kind of a hypocretical comment from a company with a huge track record of playing dirty and ripping off competitors.
Guess they're so afraid of competition that they don't have a choice. Poor rotten apple.
Well actually not poor - appearently quite wealthy in fact.

deredita 01/22/2009 3:30 PM
Hide
-6+

I am getting very disgusted by Apple. I am getting annoyed, as I want a new desktop to go with my aging Macbook, which at the moment is my primary computer. The only desktops Apple offer are exceptionally overpriced units with outdated and obsolete hardware, and the Mac Pro, which would cost me over $3000.

Now this - instead of them seeing some competition as a way for them to spark some further innovation, they seek to get rid of competition at all costs by legal means. I used to hate Microsoft, but to be honest, I think Apple is a far far dirtier player. If they ever become the majority in the computer industry - I think that computer hardware innovation would slowly grind to a halt based on how infrequently they update their desktops.

I am disgusted enough by Apple's shady tactics, and lack of any sort of modern desktop hardware, that I am considering switching back to Windows soon. I can't deal with the lack of quad-core desktops, lack of 8GB ram, lack of innovation, etc... I want a powerful computer, not an overpriced decoration that happens to be able to do some light computing.

I've also had a miserable time with Leopard. Kernel panics, instability, slower performance, etc... How was that any better than Microsoft switching from XP to Vista? Apple went from a rock solid platform 10.4, and went to 10.5, which took forever for them to get working stably. I upgraded from 10.4.11 to 10.5, then after 10.5.4, downgraded back to 10.4.11. I have upgraded a few Windows machines I have at work to Vista, and have yet to downgrade them back to XP.

JMcEntegart 01/22/2009 3:31 PM
Hide
-0+

Too true. Making a lot of money these days...

Anonymous 01/22/2009 3:38 PM
Hide
-0+


Small typo...good article. "It seems Apple is none too please(d) about this."

JMcEntegart 01/22/2009 4:01 PM
Hide
-1+

Oops, sorry. Should be all fixed. Thanks for the heads up.

Curnel_D 01/22/2009 4:31 PM
Hide
-2+

@deredita
Heh, finally a mac user that's had the same experience with apple that I've had. :P Though they do offer quadcore desktops, but nothing under the 3k range. Infact, I regularly use an 8 core mac pro for some work.

captaincharisma 01/22/2009 6:09 PM
Hide
-0+

LOL thats funny. Apple offers a quadcore desktop for 3K+ and yey you can go get a quad core PC now for under 1K LOL. just go get a quadcore PC and get a copy of Mac OSX that will work for PC's. I know it can be a pain getting Mac OSX to run on a PC but i rather the pain then wasting an extra 2k on the MAC quadcore

frozenlead 01/22/2009 6:15 PM
Hide
-0+

Another grand statement from our old friend, Big Brother.

I wonder if the iFans ever hear about this kinda stuff.

BallistaMan 01/22/2009 6:40 PM
Hide
-0+

I usually tell the variety of iFans I meet. Most could care less. :(

TheCapulet 01/22/2009 6:43 PM
Hide
-0+

If I remember right when the company that has the mac pro 8 core zeon machine bought it, it was somewhere in the range of 9k. And they're relitively underpowered zeons. Though it does have 32GB ram and 4TB of HD space. But either way, I could build the same machine for as little as 2-3k at the very most.

Total Waste. I could have talked them out of it, if they didnt need it for some proprietary apple format. Who would have guessed. :P

tayb 01/22/2009 7:28 PM
Hide
-1+

Apple has some pretty funny business practices.

Like their "innovative" keyboards they use on all their notebooks... that they borrowed/stole from Sony.

Or their iPods, iPhones, and now notebooks that cannot be opened for repair, upgrade, or battery replacement by anyone except Apple themselves.

And people honestly complain about Microsoft.

kamkal 01/22/2009 8:40 PM
Hide
-0+

mac diehards are what we call fanatics

they are no different than any other fanatic whether it be religious, political, etc etc

ive done tech support for macs and some of the ideological crap that comes out of these customer's mouths is disturbing...

like buddy its just a computer, get over it

kamkal 01/22/2009 8:43 PM
Hide
-1+


adding to my above post

on the flip side, i have also done tech support for dell computers, and the customers are completely different

its just a computer to them, they just want it fixed, no secret obsession with michael dell

Anonymous 01/22/2009 9:38 PM
Hide
-0+

Yes, have your pc and your worms, trojans, spyware, flaky windows, keyloggers and viruses and see how far you get before you throw your pc out the window. Mac users are famous for getting things done and not having the system down while redoing the whole system because of viruses.

Anonymous 01/22/2009 9:50 PM
Hide
-0+

I bet there are more people that have never had a large issue running anything MS than Mac owners. If Mac had the same sales as MS you would hear about all the retards out there with their busted macs blaming apple. Every issue you stated has more to do with the number of idiots using the product rather than the product itself.

zodiacfml 01/23/2009 5:21 AM
Hide
-0+

virus or worm makers are not that stupid to make something for macs.

truthbetold :
Yes, have your pc and your worms, trojans, spyware, flaky windows, keyloggers and viruses and see how far you get before you throw your pc out the window. Mac users are famous for getting things done and not having the system down while redoing the whole system because of viruses.


justjc 01/23/2009 7:40 AM
Hide
-0+

@truthbetold: There is actually trojans for the Mac, so you should probably strike that one of your list. Proff can be found right here on Toms http://www.tomshardware.com/news/T [...] ,5730.html and by searching the web with the words mac trojan.
That Macs can't be targeted by viruses is a myth, truth is rather that it, like Linux, has to few users for most virus programmers to bother.

Humans think 01/23/2009 8:40 PM
Hide
-0+

captaincharisma :
LOL thats funny. Apple offers a quadcore desktop for 3K+ and yey you can go get a quad core PC now for under 1K LOL. just go get a quadcore PC and get a copy of Mac OSX that will work for PC's. I know it can be a pain getting Mac OSX to run on a PC but i rather the pain then wasting an extra 2k on the MAC quadcore



It's not so difficult, I have a customized quad-core efix built which runs authentic retail Leopard, I am writing this post using this computer. The whole system cost me 1250 Euros with a 24" Samsung screen

xTalent 01/25/2009 2:35 AM
Hide
-0+

QQ

Comments are closed on this page.

Sponsored links