With AI browsers suddenly everywhere, I have held my stance that Chrome with Gemini is all anyone needs. But I decided to do a hands-on test to see if my opinion held up with nine real world searches.
ChatGPT Atlas, the new web browser from OpenAI, is built directly around the ChatGPT assistant and is designed to combine web browsing with AI‑driven tasks like page summarization, research and actionable automation. It's currently only available on macOS.
Gemini in Chrome embeds the AI‑power of Gemini 3 directly into the Google Chrome browser, meaning you can ask questions, summarize articles or compare open tabs without ever leaving your browsing session.
So I stress-tested both tools the way real people actually use them: hunting for Black Friday deals, planning travel, finding events, researching news, cooking dinner and more. What I discovered is that these two assistants have fundamentally different personalities. Atlas tries to think with you: it remembers context, shapes decisions and guides you toward an outcome. Chrome, on the other hand, works more like a turbocharged search engine — incredibly fast, detailed and structured, but sometimes stopping short of the finish line.
After nine hands-on tests, clear strengths emerged on both sides — and some surprising weaknesses.
1. Shopping Black Friday deals
Prompt: Find me a Black Friday deal on a 55-inch smart TV under $400
ChatGPT Atlas curated a list of deals and included a “Top 3” list with clear pros and cons for each, plus, actionable guidance to support different needs and budgets.
Chrome with Gemini 3.0 presented a comprehensive but somewhat overwhelming list of options without a clear prioritization and no guidance whatsoever. It gave me info like a product search engine rather than an assistant.
Winner: ChatGPT wins because it took a product list and turned it into a concise, easy-to-use buying guide, directly helping me make a decision.
2. Summarizing news
Prompt: Summarize the latest news about OpenAI in 3 bullet points
ChatGPT Atlas offered a longer list of recent developments, but the information provided was less cohesive, mixed major strategic moves with minor trademark issues and exceeded my requested three bullet points.
Chrome with Gemini 3.0 delivered a concise, three-bullet summary that successfully grouped related developments under clear, high-level themes, providing a more strategic and digestible overview of OpenAI's current direction.
Winner: Chrome wins for adhering precisely to my request for three bullet points and synthesizing the information into a clearer, more strategic summary.
3. Recipe help
Prompt: Find a 30-minute dinner recipe I can make with broccoli, rice, and eggs
ChatGPT Atlas was more thorough by including helpful tips (like using day-old rice), offering ingredient alternatives and breaking the instructions into clear, distinct steps.
Chrome with Gemini 3.0 gave me a functional recipe with clear, concise instructions, making it a solid, no-fuss option.
Winner: Chrome wins because the recipe was much easier to follow and did not require extra steps. The images of the recipe on the side were a helpful addition.
4. Local things to do
Prompt: What’s a fun holiday event happening in NYC this weekend?
ChatGPT Atlas focused on a single, classic event with helpful logistical tips, but this narrow scope is less helpful for someone looking for options. This makes me wonder if ChatGPT was going off of memory, knowing that I have young children that may not enjoy sitting through holidays shows in a theater.
Chrome with Gemini 3.0 delivered a wide-ranging list of diverse events across multiple categories (theater, markets, family activities), providing specific venues, times, and dates, which is far more practical for planning a weekend.
Winner: Chrome wins for offering a variety of concrete options, allowing me to choose rather than just assuming what I would want. The options allowed for me to pick based on who I was with and our interests, rather than just highlighting one.
5. Research and information
Prompt: Open the official website of MoMA in New York, identify the current exhibitions listed on the homepage, and summarize the three most prominent ones in one short paragraph each. Include: exhibition title, artist(s), theme, and closing date.
ChatGPT Atlas provided three distinct, well-crafted paragraphs that fully include the requested elements — exhibition title, artist(s), theme, and closing date — with richer descriptions of each exhibition's concept and significance.
Chrome with Gemini 3.0 correctly identified the three exhibitions with their titles and closing dates in a single, concise paragraph, but it lacked the thematic depth and descriptive detail requested.
Winner: ChatGPT wins for delivering more comprehensive and insightful summaries that better fulfill the user's prompt.
6. Trip planning
Prompt: Compare flights from NYC to Miami next month — what’s the best deal?
ChatGPT Atlas delivered a superior, multi-faceted comparison by breaking down options into clear categories (cheapest vs. best value), explicitly comparing airports (MIA vs. FLL) and providing crucial context about trade-offs like baggage fees and comfort.
Chrome with Gemini 3.0 correctly identified the cheapest airlines and general price range, offering a solid starting point for a budget-conscious traveler like me.
Winner: ChatGPT wins because it offered a more nuanced and practical guide that helped me make an informed decision based on my specific priorities, not just the lowest sticker price.
7. History lesson
Prompt: Tell me the origin of Thanksgiving in the U.S.
ChatGPT Atlas offered a well-written, engaging narrative that covered the key historical points, including modern context, in a flowing, conversational style.
Chrome with Gemini 3.0 delivered the information in a more organized, textbook-like structure with clear thematic sections (Early Observances, Becoming a National Holiday, Modern Holiday), making the historical progression and key figures easier to follow and reference.
Winner: ChatGPT wins because it presented the information in a more engaging way without feeling like a history lesson with a structured format.
8. Creating an Amazon wishlist
Prompt: Help me build a holiday wishlist on Amazon — add 5 gift ideas under $25
ChatGPT Atlas immediately fulfilled my request by providing five specific, on-budget gift ideas with brief, appealing descriptions. With memory enabled, it provided a list that makes sense for me.
Chrome with Gemini 3.0 correctly explained the mechanics of how to create an Amazon wishlist but failed to provide the requested gift ideas, making the response incomplete and unhelpful. This was surprising considering I have personalization enabled.
Winner: ChatGPT wins because it directly answered my core request for gift ideas, whereas Chrome only addressed the procedural aspect of the task.
9. Book suggestions
Prompt: Find 3 well-reviewed books by female sci-fi authors and show Goodreads ratings
ChatGPT Atlas offered a solid list of famous, highly-rated books, but included The Handmaid's Tale, which is often debated as dystopian fiction rather than core sci-fi, and The Power, which has a noticeably lower rating.
Chrome with Gemini 3.0 curated a list of three undisputed sci-fi classics that are not only all highly-rated (all above 4.1) but also represent a diverse range of subgenres and thematic depth, from sociological exploration to space opera.
Winner: Chrome wins for selecting a more cohesive and consistently top-tier list of science fiction novels, with stronger and more uniform ratings.
Overall winner: ChatGPT Atlas
| Row 0 - Cell 0 | ChatGPT Atlas | Chrome with Gemini 3.0 |
Black Friday deals | X | Row 1 - Cell 2 |
News summary | Row 2 - Cell 1 | X |
Recipe help | Row 3 - Cell 1 | X |
Local things to do | Row 4 - Cell 1 | X |
Research and info | X | Row 5 - Cell 2 |
Trip planning | X | Row 6 - Cell 2 |
History lesson | X | Row 7 - Cell 2 |
Amazon wishlist | X | Row 8 - Cell 2 |
Book suggestion | Row 9 - Cell 1 | X |
TOTAL | 5 | 4 |
After spending several weeks using both tools side-by-side, my view has changed more than I expected. Chrome with Gemini is still powerful, fast and incredibly convenient — especially because it lives inside the browsing environment most of us already rely on.
But in real-world, task-driven use, ChatGPT Atlas proved itself more frequently capable of guiding me to an actual decision, not just giving me information. Atlas remembers context, adapts to my needs and shapes the results into something usable far more often than Chrome does.
That said, Chrome is still more widely available, while ChatGPT Atlas requires me to switch computers and I can't use it on my phone yet. Plus, Chrome excelled at structure, speed and breadth, particularly when I needed a high-level view of news or options. In a few cases, it even outperformed Atlas by being more focused and concise.
But when I look at the nine tests as a whole, a pattern emerges: Chrome is a brilliant information engine; Atlas is a proactive assistant. And depending on what you need, either could be the better pick.
More from Tom's Guide
- I just tested ChatGPT-5.1 vs. Grok 4.1 with 9 prompts — and there's a clear winner
- Meet Claude Opus 4.5 — the next‑gen AI model that beats the competition on reasoning, code and productivity
- I just tried Flow's 4 new AI editing tools — and I can't believe what it can do now
Follow Tom's Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds.
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.
