Cashing In: Google Sued For Patent Infringement

By Christian Zibreg, published on August 19, 2008 at 8:30 AM
Source: Tom's Guide US | Keywords: , ,
Syndication: Add to your Google homepage Add to My Yahoo!

Mountain View (CA) - GraphOn, a software company that offers remote application access software, said it has filed a patent infringement suit against Google. If GraphOn is right, the Google’s Google Base, AdWords, Blogger, Sites and YouTube services could be colliding with four patents, forcing the search giant to pay GraphOn damages as well as license fees for past and future usage.

Google has built an empire on web applications and just this fact could cost the company big. GraphOn said that Google infringes four patents the company obtained when it acquired Network Engineering Software (NES) in February 2005. According to the suit filed at the United States District Court in the Eastern District of Texas, alleges that Google Base, AdWords, Blogger, Sites and YouTube illegally use a patent-protected method of "maintaining an automated and network-accessible database".

The same four patents were the subject of nine lawsuits that GraphOn filed against IAC/InterActiveCorp, Yahoo, Match.com, Classified Ventures, eHarmony.com, Juniper Networks, and AutoTrader.com. The AutoTrader.com lawsuit, which only covered two GraphOn patents, was settled with a technology license agreement.

According to a press release GraphOn suit seeks "permanent injunctive relief along with unspecified damages". Google is expected to defend itself against GraphOn in court; a favorable outcome for GraphOn could not only be very expensive for Google, but also enable GraphOn to expand its suit to possibly thousands of websites.

"The number of patents now owned by GraphOn as a result of the NES acquisition has increased to twenty three, a number that is expected to continue to increase as patent applications on file at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office mature into issued patents," said Robert Dilworth, GraphOn’s chief executive officer. "Aggressively protecting the technology represented in these patents is an important part of maximizing their value to GraphOn."

Comments | Print | Send to a friend
Slideshows related to this news

Google Ads

Comments

sandmanwn 08/19/2008 3:22 AM
Hide
-0+
sandmanwn

Quote :"Aggressively suing the technology sector with patents is an important part of maximizing their value to GraphOn."

Fixed. :)

GraphOn, another fine example of if you can't beat them or develop it, then sue till you can.

Anonymous 08/19/2008 4:38 AM
Hide
-1+

Come on, PLEASE. It appears another company has patented a concept, instead of a product. I think I'm going to patent 'scratching ones own body,' and make you all pay royalties everytime you have an itch.

I don't know who's more at fault, companies making these outragious lawsuits, the courts, or the patent office for letting this crap through.

Anonymous 08/19/2008 5:12 AM
Hide
--1+

@ Bombastic

I think the answer is America in general is at fault. People in all those fields come from American homes, American churches, American schools, American universities, and American businesses.

This kind of BS is what Americans have to offer.

Anonymous 08/19/2008 6:05 AM
Hide
-1+

We, Microsoft, the board of directors of the "Frivolous lawsuits from idiot Americans and the EU" welcome Google to our realms with open arms. We hope you enjoy your inevitable stay here.

Next we look forward to bringing Apple into our group.

Anonymous 08/19/2008 8:16 AM
Hide
-2+

Um Bob F, it's greedy people that make this possible. And from what I can see it's not just americans but greed is all over...Europe, Asia, South Africa, don't be so niave.

killerb255 08/19/2008 10:09 AM
Hide
-1+
killerb255

Is this the next RAMBUS?

Antilycus 08/19/2008 10:09 AM
Hide
--1+
Antilycus

so lets have a bunch of people, that dont understand a single thing about patients, approve and deny companies of things they have no control over. the patient lawsuits are completely redic.

eklipz330 08/20/2008 3:01 AM
Hide
-1+
eklipz330

my ancestor invented letters, your all screwed.

Niva 08/20/2008 7:10 AM
Hide
-0+
Niva

An automated database which is network accessible... this was patented? I think any website out there which uses a database and allows network access to the database is liable to be sued under this patent, including Tom's Hardware.

invlem 08/21/2008 2:34 AM
Hide
-0+
invlem

When a company's primary method of turning a profit is suing the rest of the world into oblivion, you know the system is broken.

If you patent an idea, then you should have to follow up on it and build/do something with it, if you don't show initiative to do something with your patent, then it should be nullified. Too many companies these days are just sitting on concepts they'll never actually bring to the light of day, but will happily sue someone else who tries.

Comments are closed on this page.

Google Ads