Dell Smartphone Deemed Boring, Says Analyst

By Jane McEntegart, published on March 23, 2009 at 2:50 PM
Source: Tom's Hardware US | Keywords: , , , , | Themes: 3GSM, Smartphones
Syndication: Add to your Google homepage Add to My Yahoo!

Anytime a new product is a success, you see a whole bunch of “me too” products in the months after. If the original manufacturer is making buckets of money from one device, every other company under the sun wants to get in on it.

It happened with netbooks and it happened with smartphones. The iPhone was a hit and suddenly every company was endeavoring to bring out the one that would slay the beast. None have come close (although the hype surrounding the Storm was significant) and while many are putting all their eggs in Pre-brand baskets, it turns out the market doesn’t have room for entries from just any old company trying its luck.

A while back, reports said that Dell was well on its way to producing a smartphone. Our reaction was the same as the one we had when we heard about that lightbulb company (Sylvania) and its netbook. Amusement with a dash of fatigue. The Wall Street Journal was the first to report the rumors back in January and word on the street was Dell could put two smartphones on the market as early as February. February came and went and we saw no smartphone. Not that we noticed, mind you.

Today we found out where those two smartphones (one with Android, one running an unnamed OS) went -- nowhere. According to MarketWatch, the Dell smartphones have been put on hold because of lack of interest from carriers. While it could easily be argued that the phone companies are already offering enough smartphones and don’t feel like taking on another, analysts say carriers felt Dell’s prototypes were too boring and didn’t offer anything wasn’t already possible with another device.

MarketWatch cites Kaufman Bros. analyst Shaw Wu who says Dell's devices, designed to run software from both Microsoft and Google, have so far failed to distinguish themselves from a growing field of competitors. "From our conversations with supply chain and industry sources, it appears that it ultimately came down to lack of carrier interest," Wu wrote.

Wu went on to say that Dell has gone back to the drawing board with regards to a smartphone. What do you guys make of Dell trying to squeeze its way into the market? Would you like to see something from Dell or are you getting tired of this smartphone trend?

Comments | Print | Send to a friend
Content also available in : Dell Smartphone Deemed Boring, Says Analyst
Slideshows related to this news

Sponsored links

Comments

tayb 03/23/2009 9:20 PM
Hide
-0+

Boring? From Dell? Nah...

If they could use the Adamo design team and the XT Tablet technical team from they might make a device that doesn't suck but I wouldn't have high hopes for it.

SneakySnake 03/23/2009 9:20 PM
Hide
-0+

Make something new and better, not a copy that apparantly is "the best thing since sliced bread". If you make a new ground up phone that is awesome, the iPhone will fall

lire210 03/23/2009 9:41 PM
Hide
--1+

I hate dell. their gaming desktop are in not horrible................. when no just horrible.

RiotSniperX 03/23/2009 9:51 PM
Hide
-2+

Its dell...what else is new?

The Schnoz 03/23/2009 11:27 PM
Hide
-0+

Maybe an Alienware phone or DellPhone XP.

JMcEntegart 03/24/2009 9:44 AM
Hide
-0+

I actually thought of the prospect of an Alienware phone too! But then thinking about it, gaming phones have pretty much never been a huge hit. All an Alienware phone would bring is a nifty design.

Still, I can understand Dell's dilemma. Coming up with a phone that can do something no other phone can is difficult. Add in the fact that the company is not in the business of designing phones and it makes it seem like Dell was just chancing it's arm in the first place.

norbs 03/24/2009 5:16 PM
Hide
-1+

SneakySnake :
Make something new and better, not a copy that apparently is "the best thing since sliced bread". If you make a new ground up phone that is awesome, the iPhone will fall



Jebus why does everyone compare itself to the iPhone? I love how everyone with a new phone calls itself an iPhone killer because it has better hardware. Nothing about the iPhone's hardware is that special, it's all about the software... and the community of people making apps.

There are a lot of great HTC phones that do windows mobile and have some nice interface skins. These are not that publicly advertised as iPhone or the Storm but are very nice (especially compared to the storm).

Wonder if they will reduce themselves to making a phone with a built in hammer or tazer gun that pops out so it can really call itself an iPhone killer... =]

Comments are closed on this page.

Sponsored links