Video Performance: Hulu and YouTube

By Mary Branscombe, published on May 29, 2009
Source: Tom's Guide US | Keywords: , , | Themes: Software, Smartphones

8. Video Performance: Hulu and YouTube

Watch clips and full-length TV shows on Hulu.

You may not have to load the Hulu front page very often, as Hulu is one of the video feeds that shows up on the Skyfire start page, so you can click to go straight to a video.

When you do load it, it’s fast. This isn’t a complex screen, but it has a lot of images and CSS to build the layout. It loads very quickly in Skyfire on a 3G connection because the images are compressed on the server rather than resized in the mobile browser. The iPhone screen shows more of the Hulu page so it has more images to load, which also slows it down. On the BlackBerry, rendering layout and scripts takes up a lot of the loading time. With Opera, the page loads slow–and instead of the large image banner at the top of the page, it shows a warning that the browser can’t play the Flash videos on the site.

We couldn’t compare the speed of watching videos as few other mobile browsers support Hulu, but opening the front page gives consistent results.

Few mobile browsers open the full YouTube site; again Skyfire loads the full page and loads it consistently fastest.

Hulu relies on streaming and buffering the streaming content for a good experience when playing longer video clips. With Skyfire, the buffering happens at the Skyfire server, but this manages the connection to the Skyfire browser so you still get a good streaming experience if your connection is fast enough (you need to be on WiFi or 3G). The video quality is also extremely impressive.

 YouTube video quality depends much more on the original video quality, and the intelligent zooming is more useful on YouTube if you don't want to bother clicking the tiny full-screen button; you can just zoom in to the video.

Comments | Print | Send to a friend

Sponsored links

Comments

pocketdrummer 05/30/2009 6:44 PM
Hide
--1+

Now, if only they would release an iPhone app for this...

I'm not much for windows mobile after I used the BlackJack. It tends to slowly turn to crap as time progresses. It would be really nice to see this technology on a phone that's already championed as the best phone ever (generally).

bujcri 05/30/2009 8:15 PM
Hide
-0+

This browser looks great and does great, except for smth. that is important for a phone like mine (Nokia E51) with a smaller screen: it cannot rotate the page which is annoying esp. when watching video...

apache_lives 05/31/2009 6:35 AM
Hide
--1+

somehow i cant see a third-party app beating a native browser, then again we have firefox....

Anonymous 06/01/2009 8:31 AM
Hide
-0+

@pocketdrummer; Skyfire can't produce a version for iPhone (keen as the team would be to do it) as Apple doesn't allow other browsers on the iPhone.

apache_lives 06/01/2009 9:37 AM
Hide
-0+

MaryBranscombe :
@pocketdrummer; Skyfire can't produce a version for iPhone (keen as the team would be to do it) as Apple doesn't allow other browsers on the iPhone.



there are alternatives im sure of it but there more based on the integrated safari?

konjiki7 07/30/2009 11:01 PM
Hide
-0+

I wonder how skyfire stacks up against bolt? It would be nice if this worked on my 8230...

o0RaidR0o 10/19/2009 7:17 PM
Hide
-0+

pocketdrummer :
Now, if only they would release an iPhone app for this...I'm not much for windows mobile after I used the BlackJack. It tends to slowly turn to crap as time progresses. It would be really nice to see this technology on a phone that's already championed as the best phone ever (generally).



Sorry to hear of your WinMo experience. I have the 2yr old Tilt on AT&T and haven't looked back since. Had to replace only once after having dropped it...Oop's! Waiting till my November date to get my discounted TP2. Of course my WinMo is XDA hacked running SPB Shell 3.0 :)

Sponsored links