Prime Video’s new romantic drama is unexpectedly good — and it’s the perfect guilty pleasure movie

Asha Banks as Noah in "My Fault: London" on Prime Video
(Image credit: Olly Courtney / Prime Video)

Anyone familiar with the premise of “My Fault: London” knows it’s a bit controversial since it leans heavily into the forbidden romance trope. But here’s the thing, I actually think it’s a surprisingly good movie, especially if you love YA romances where the leads start off as enemies. Is it of high quality? Absolutely not. But that hasn’t stopped it from becoming my latest guilty pleasure watch.

And I’m clearly not alone. “My Fault: London” hit Prime Video on February 13 and wasted no time cracking the top 10 list, currently sitting at No. 2 at the time of writing. Plus, audiences have given it an 89% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, so it’s safe to say plenty of people are enjoying it, obvious flaws and all.

“My Fault: London” is actually an English-language remake of the 2023 Spanish movie “Culpa Mía.” The original Spanish adaptation was highly popular, leading Prime Video to produce “My Fault: London” to appeal to a broader audience. While the core story remains the same (centering on Noah and her forbidden romance with her rebellious stepbrother, Nick), the remake relocates the setting to London and features an English-speaking cast.

If you’re in the mood for a new YA romantic drama or have seen “My Fault: London” making the rounds online, here’s everything you need to know about it (and why it’s my new guilty pleasure movie).

What is ‘My Fault: London’ about?

My Fault: London - Official Trailer | Prime Video - YouTube My Fault: London - Official Trailer | Prime Video - YouTube
Watch On

“My Fault: London” centers on 18-year-old Noah (Asha Banks), who relocates from America to London with her mother, Ella (Eve Macklin), following Ella's marriage to wealthy British businessman William (Ray Fearon).

In her new home, Noah encounters her rebellious stepbrother, Nick (Matthew Broome). Despite initial tensions, an undeniable attraction develops between them, leading to a complex and forbidden romance. As Noah adapts to her new environment, she must confront her troubled past, especially with her estranged father recently released from prison and seeking to reconnect.

‘My Fault: London’ nails the forbidden romance trope

Forbidden romance can be challenging to pull off, especially since the topic itself can be a bit controversial. But “My Fault: London” handles it surprisingly well, and that’s largely thanks to the strong chemistry between its two leads. Asha Banks and Matthew Broome play step-siblings who form a deep connection, something that, on paper, might sound odd to anyone who hasn’t seen the movie. But after finally watching it myself (after being bombarded with videos about it online), I was genuinely surprised by how well they handled the subject matter.

Noah (Banks) and Nick (Broome) are just two teenagers thrown into each other’s lives while dealing with their already fractured families. As the movie unfolds, we get a deeper look into Noah’s trauma, and her reserved nature makes it easy to see why she connects with Nick once they move past their initial tension. Instead of just relying on the shock factor of their relationship, the movie leans into their individual struggles, making their bond feel more natural.

That said, if you’ve seen Nicole Kidman’s latest movie, “Babygirl,” then you’ll know “My Fault: London” is a much tamer take on the forbidden romance trope. But it’s still the perfect little flick for YA fans or anyone looking for a spicy, easy-to-watch drama, which is probably why it’s become my latest guilty pleasure (judgment-free zone, please).

Matthew Broome as Nick and Asha Banks as Noah in "My Fault: London"

(Image credit: Amazon MGM Studios)

Another thing worth mentioning without spoiling too much (for anyone that cares) is that “My Fault: London” starts off as a drama, shifts into a juicy romance, and then goes full action-thriller by the end. It’s an unusual genre mix, but it works because the early drama hints at Noah’s dark past. That said, fair warning: the last quarter of the movie leans into cheesiness, and the acting slips at times. Still, it’s an easy, no-fuss watch.

Now, don’t get me wrong though, this is my guilty pleasure movie, but I’m not calling it great, and it definitely won’t be for everyone. There are plenty of romantic dramas that deserve way more praise and attention. To put it simply, “My Fault: London” is an easy watch for YA fans and anyone who enjoys a little controversy. Yes, it’s cringey, the script is weak, and the romance feels rushed at the beginning, but it’s still an entertaining flick on Prime Video.

You can stream ‘My Fault: London’ now

Enva Lewis as Jenna and Asha Banks as Noah in "My Fault: London"

(Image credit: Kevin Baker / Prime Video)

You don’t have to wait to check out “My Fault: London” since it’s streaming now on Prime Video. Whether you’re in the mood for a forbidden romance, some unexpected thrills, or just an easy YA drama to pass the time as background noise, this one delivers all of the above.

While it’s far from perfect, it’s undeniably entertaining, especially if you enjoy a mix of drama, romance, thriller elements, and even racing cars (plenty of that). So, if you’re curious to see what all the buzz is about or just want a guilty pleasure watch like me, stream “My Fault: London” on Prime Video now.

If it’s not for you, see what else is new on Prime Video in February 2025. You can also check out our guide on the best movies to watch on Prime Video this month.

More from Tom's Guide

Alix Blackburn
Staff Writer, Streaming

Alix is a Streaming Writer at Tom’s Guide, which basically means watching the best movies and TV shows and then writing about them. Previously, she worked as a freelance writer for Screen Rant and Bough Digital, both of which sparked her interest in the entertainment industry. When she’s not writing about the latest movies and TV shows, she’s either playing horror video games on her PC or working on her first novel.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

Read more
Simone Ashley and Hero Fiennes Tiffin in "Picture This" now streaming on Prime Video
Prime Video’s new romantic comedy is now streaming — and it’s the ultimate mood-booster
Kyle Allen and Kathryn Newton in "The Map of Tiny Perfect Things"
One of the best romantic comedy movies is streaming free on Prime Video — and it’s a charming watch
Katherine Heigl and Josh Duhamel in "Life as We Know It" (2010)
Prime Video just got one of my favorite romantic comedies — and you can stream it now
Anya Taylor-Joy in "The Gorge," premiering in 2025 on Apple TV Plus
Apple TV Plus’ new action-thriller is now streaming — and it’s already one of my favorite movies of 2025
Mia McKenna-Bruce as Tara in "How to Have Sex" now streaming on Netflix
Netflix just added one of the most impactful drama movies I've ever watched — and it's 97% on Rotten Tomatoes
Heart Eyes killer in "Heart Eyes" movie (2025)
One of my favorite movies of 2025 so far is now streaming — and it’s Certified Fresh on Rotten Tomatoes
Latest in Prime Video
Twisters movie (2024)
Prime Video's newest No. 1 movie is an action-packed thriller starring Glen Powell — stream 'Twisters' now
Enemy of the State
5 best Prime Video movies to stream before they leave this month
Simone Ashley and Hero Fiennes Tiffin in "Picture This" now streaming on Prime Video
Prime Video top 10 has 3 must-watch movies — including a bubbly romcom starring 'Bridgerton's' Simone Ashley
The Creator poster
Prime Video is about to lose one of my favorite sci-fi movies of the past 5 years — stream it before it’s too late
(L-R) Akiva Schaffer as Lawrence, Andy Samberg as Conner and Jorma Taccone as Owen in "Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping"
Prime Video just got one of my favorite comedy movies of the past decade — and you can stream it now
Rosamund Pike as Moiraine Damodred in "The Wheel of Time" season 3
Prime Video top 10 shows — here’s the 3 worth watching right now
Latest in Opinion
March Madness games on YouTube TV using multiview
This is how I've streamed March Madness for the past 2 years — and it's the only way to watch every second of all 67 games
woman shopping for TV with retail worker giving advice
I've been testing TVs for a decade — 5 things to avoid when shopping for a cheap TV
Adam Scott as Mark S and Britt Lower as Helly R in Severance, standing by an elevator
'Severance' season 2 finale — here's my wild theory based on episode 9
Woody Harrelson as Duncan Allcock in "Last Breath"
The most intense survival thriller of 2025 so far is now streaming — and viewers rate it 92% on Rotten Tomatoes
Two women sit on the Nolah Natural 11 Mattress
I'm a sleep editor and I'm ditching my memory foam bed for an organic mattress — here's why
De'longhi la specialista touch first look
I got a first look at De'Longhi's new La Specialista Touch — 3 things I love, and 1 thing I don't