As two of the best music streaming services, Spotify and Apple Music are close rivals when it comes to essential music listening. Although Spotify has the largest share of the music streaming market worldwide, when it comes to the total number of subscribers in the U.S., the two streaming services are more closely matched. This doesn't mean, though, that one service isn't better suited to everyday music listeners than the other.
To find out why Apple Music is my go-to music streaming service for testing and personal listening right now, read on. And be sure to check out our full Apple Music vs Spotify face-off.
1. Better sound quality
Apple Music's sound quality is top-notch. When it comes to resolution and bit rate, Apple Music's "lossless" delivers full “CD-quality” at 16-bit/44.1kHz and up to 24-bit/192kHz for true Hi-Res Audio. The only slight downside is that hi-res output is not supported on Windows desktops.
The Apple Music mobile app sounds consistently excellent, with a natural sounding balance across every genre of music. It's my go-to music provider for reviewing headphones on the move, and it sounds pretty great through the various Sonos speakers and components dotted around my home, and is a great alternative to hi-res streaming services such as Tidal and Qobuz.
You may think that all music streaming services sound the same. They don't, of course, but the differences can be remarkably subtle. Generally speaking, any differences come down to the file format being supported by providers and the streaming data rates used. These have a direct effect on the levels of detail that can be heard in tracks, and most listeners should be able to tell a compressed music file from Spotify, say, over a CD-quality one streamed via Apple Music.
You don’t need to be an audiophile with golden ears or have spent a fortune on a pair of headphones to hear the benefits streaming music in lossless audio can bring. You just have to listen.
2. Easy to use interface
Spotify appears to be going through something of an identity crisis following a redesigned TikTok-like home feed introduced last month, along with AI DJ that attempts to enhance the 'personalized feel' of its user experience by inserting computer generated commentary between tracks.
Meanwhile, ever since Apple Music’s big redesign for iOS 10, Apple Music has been focussing on a traditional music experience. The interface looks smart, and the clean and easy to navigate tabs do an excellent job of bringing together artists and genres of music I like. It's a long way from Spotify's new scroll through cards UI that appears to be more focussed on podcasts, audiobooks and video content that I have no interest in.
Apple Music's Browse tab feels perfectly tuned to my music tastes with an excellent mix of playlists, hit songs, new releases, and spatial audio content, which is what it's about after all.
Speaking of which, Music Library Tracker is a third-party app for iPhone and iPad that has been developed to integrate with the Apple Music library to track spatial audio content changes. As an Apple Music subscriber, it will automatically find out which of the tracks and albums in your music library are also available in spatial audio without having to carry out lengthy searches of your favorite artist's back catalog. It costs $3.99 / £3.99 via the iOS app store — but if you don't want to pay, you can follow the developer's Twitter account to keep track of new spatial audio releases.
3. Apple Music Sing karaoke
Apple Music Sing karaoke is a blast! It builds on the streaming service's lyrics feature to make it easier to sing along. The feature adds an independent volume control for the song's vocals, so you can sing by yourself (almost, there's no fully silent option) if you want, or with the original singer in the background at full or reduced volume as you like. Some songs have the ability to split the words between multiple singers to allow for duets, or enabling a friend, say, to sing the backing vocals while you take the main vocal.
As you might expect, Apple Music Sing enhancements aren't available for every track. Compatible songs are arranged into playlists, so you can easily find tracks that will work perfectly with the new feature.
Despite Spotify Karaoke offering a more competitive experience with its built-in scoring system, its implementation doesn't seem quite as robust as what Apple Music Sing offers.
4. Apple HomePod 2 integration
No other music streaming service has its own range of audio components. Although AirPods headphones don't actually support lossless audio, Apple's HomePod speakers do and are among the best smart speaker music systems on the planet. The newly launched HomePod 2 sounds just as good as the original, while adding a few more smart home capabilities. Like the original, the HomePod 2 uses built-in microphones to sonically "map" the room it’s placed in and adjusts the audio output to sound best for that room. It’s all done automatically, without you needing to do anything.
As part of Apple's perfectly tuned ecosystem, the HomePod 2 is an ideal model for making the most of Apple's Lossless 16-bit/44.1kHz (CD-quality), and spatial audio content. However, I should also point out that if you have an AirPlay-capable speaker, you can also hear lossless audio when using Apple Music connected to a playback device via AirPlay.
What's more, though, there's some suggestion that HomePod speakers may actually be able to go beyond lossless resolution support as they already share 24-bit/48kHz audio signals between other HomePod speakers in multiroom setups.
5. Apple Music Classical
Apple Music has been focusing on broadening its reach by introducing classical music lovers to its platform through a dedicated classical app, which is free to existing subscribers.
Many of the best music streaming services have a good selection of classical music content in their libraries, but they can often make searching for classical works feel inaccessible. That's because most streaming service searches use metadata that catalogs content by artist, genre, song title, and album title, and isn't capable of handling the complex way classical music is cataloged.
Searches often miss the mark when it comes to finding specific classical content, but the dedicated Apple Music Classical app (available from the App Store) uses stronger metadata to enable searches by composer, work, conductor, and even catalog number to find specific recordings instantly.
The app claims to offer more than 5 million classical tracks and complete works from new releases to celebrated masterpieces, and favorite playlists integrate seamlessly with your music library for easy playback from the regular Apple Music app.
If, like me, you've spent far too much time searching for a particular recording or version of a piece of classical music, you'll appreciate how stronger metadata can help deliver more accurate search results. As music libraries are continually expanding, other streaming services could learn a thing or two from Apple Music Classical's stronger metadata implementation to help every kind of music lover find the exact content they desire.
More from Tom's Guide
Get the BEST of Tom’s Guide daily right in your inbox: Sign up now!
Upgrade your life with the Tom’s Guide newsletter. Subscribe now for a daily dose of the biggest tech news, lifestyle hacks and hottest deals. Elevate your everyday with our curated analysis and be the first to know about cutting-edge gadgets.
As a former editor of the U.K.'s Hi-Fi Choice magazine, Lee is passionate about all kinds of audio tech and has been providing sound advice to enable consumers to make informed buying decisions since he joined Which? magazine as a product tester in the 1990s. Lee covers all things audio for Tom's Guide, including headphones, wireless speakers and soundbars and loves to connect and share the mindfulness benefits that listening to music in the very best quality can bring.
Unless you have top tier studio headphones you won't notice the difference of sound qualityReply
What about Spotify's interface is that confusing? You have a section for home, search, and your playlists
Who cares about karaoke, look up instrumentals if you need it that much
If you have the apple homepod you're already using apple music, who chooses to buy the more expensive Alexa and not already in the apple ecosystem
Spotify has a huge library of classical, but i guess if you need the most niche of niche classical songs that i guess you got me there, even though you can download the songs of YouTube (they're royalty free so it's legal) and use local files on Spotify (which you cannot do on apple music)
I would never ditch spotify who is lights years ahead of others music apps. but especially apple... their service and ability to connectto other devices is pathetic. even apple iphone users use spotify and we all know how its a sin for iphone users not to use services or apps that dont come directly from the mothershipReply
Did you know that Spotify has a $12.99 "couples" plan? Apple Music doesn't offer this.Reply
Apple Music is not as good as Spotify when it's about browsing and providing recommendations. Also the search of Apple Music really sucks. It's ages behind Spotify. The interface of Spotify is pretty amazing whatever they are definitely lacking is PLAY NEXT option which is absolutely ridiculous. They are never listening to their subscribers.Reply
Apple Music also is missing the stunning, incredible's Spotify "Go to Song Radio". Basically proving a full song playlist similar to current played song. Instead they have that blank "Station" that don't allow the user to choose only the songs they want to play. So bad....
But the only reason to recommend Apple Music is to line your pocket by advertising the service under the guise of giving tech advice. Nice one.Reply
How much did apple pay for this advertisement?Reply
I'll give you sound quality and classical music. Those are compelling reasons for a Classical Music enthusiast. Not many people are that deeply into classical music, though.
Your link was further proof, this was basically a paid advertisement. It takes one to the apple sales home page, not to place where I can try apple music out for $4.99 a month. In fact there is no such offer on the apple page linked.
Shame on you Toms Guide.
Five years ago I would have agreed with your opinion but ever since Apple got rid of their playlist making department they’ve been totally outdone by SpotifyReply
Selection of playlists, artists is much better on Spotify.
Apple is coasting…and not just with Apple Music.