3 best Prime Video shows of 2024 with 90% or higher on Rotten Tomatoes

Features
By published

Here are the best new shows on Prime Video according to Rotten Tomatoes

Lady Jane (Emily Bader) wearing the crown and sitting on the throne in Prime Video's "My Lady Jane"
(Image credit: Jonathan Prime/Prime Video)

'Tis the season to park your butt on the couch, queue up Prime Video and catch up on all of the great shows that you might've missed this year. (And, sure, spend time with your loved ones, give back to your community, yada yada yada.)

This year, the best streaming services were a treasure trove of new TV shows and films to add to your watch list, so it's understandable if you're overwhelmed with all of the binge-watching potential. To help, we've rounded up three of the best shows of 2024 on Prime Video, all with a Tomatometer score of 90% or higher on Rotten Tomatoes. That marker means that it's been given kudos from both professional critics and casual TV watchers, so you know that every show on this list is worth watching.

'Fallout'

Based on the beloved role-playing video game franchise of the same name, this sci-fi Western is set two hundred years after the apocalypse and follows a young "Vault Dweller" named Lucy MacLean (played by "Yellowjackets'" Ella Purnell) as she ventures out into the wasteland of a devastated Long Angeles to look for her kidnapped father.

With its vast and vivid world-building, darkly comic sensibilities and characters to really root for (the cast also includes Aaron Moten, Kyle MacLachlan, Moisés Arias, Xelia Mendes-Jones and Walton Goggins), "Fallout" has been a hit both critically and commercially. According to Amazon, the action drama cleared 65 million viewers in its first 16 days of availability, making it the platform's second most-watched title ever after 2022's "The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power."

Episodes: 8
Genre: Action/Drama/Post-apocalyptic
Rotten Tomatoes score: 94%
Watch on Prime Video

'Mr. and Mrs. Smith'

YouTube YouTube
Watch On

Prime Video's "Mr. and Mrs. Smith" had a high bar to clear: inspired by the 2005 action blockbuster of the same name, the series had to match the excitement and allure of that fan-favorite flick while also conjuring up Brangelina-level chemistry between its leads Donald Glover and Maya Erskine. Thankfully, the show built upon that source material and the starring duo vaulted over those expectations, playing two lonely strangers paired up as spies and posing as a married couple.

The spy dramedy was one of Prime Video's top five series debuts ever and went number one on the platform in more than 130 countries. It was also nominated for a whopping 16 Emmy Awards this year, including Outstanding Drama Series, Outstanding Lead Actor for Glover and Outstanding Lead Actress for Erskine.

Episodes: 8
Genre: Action/Dramedy/Spy
Rotten Tomatoes score: 91%
Watch on Prime Video

'My Lady Jane'

YouTube YouTube
Watch On

Adapted by Gemma Burgess from the 2016 novel of the same name by Cynthia Hand, Brodi Ashton, and Jodi Meadows, "My Lady Jane" is set in an alternate 16th-century England where Lady Jane Grey (Emily Bader) and her husband Guildford (Edward Bluemel) all survive their real-life deaths — oh, and where humans can turn into animals.

Described by Prime Video as " a soupçon of magical realism and oodles of yearning, banter and undeniable chemistry," the fantasy romance adds humor, heart and plenty of heat to all that history. Sadly, it's a one-season watch, as Amazon canceled the critically acclaimed series shortly after its premiere. The cancellation inspired backlash and a petition from the show's passionate fanbase, which includes famed "Game of Thrones" author George R.R. Martin.

Episodes: 8
Genre: Historical fantasy/Romance
Rotten Tomatoes score: 95%
Watch on Prime Video

Christina Izzo
Christina Izzo
Writer

Christina Izzo is a writer-editor covering culture, food and drink, travel and general lifestyle in New York City. She was previously the Deputy Editor at My Imperfect Life, the Features Editor at Rachael Ray In Season and Reveal, as well as the Food & Drink Editor and chief restaurant critic at Time Out New York.