Editor's Note: Mixbook is having a promotion right now on its card printing service (and we think it is a good deal). Click here to check it out: Mixbook (From $0.69)

If you're looking for a highly personalized gift for Mother's Day, a photo book filled with cherished memories could be just the thing to preserve those memories of you and her over the years.

For consumers and amateur photographers, a book is also a great way to store photographs from baby's first birthday party, your vacation cruise to Alaska or your collection of best flower pictures. For serious and professional photographers, photo books are also important marketing tools, as well as products (to sell to the bride and groom). But among the many online photo book services, which one is the best?

We tested seven of the most popular photo book vendors: Apple Photos, Blurb, Mixbook, Montage, Picaboo, Shutterfly and Snapfish. We used photos taken by an amateur of her children, with the most minimal of editing to those photos.

  1. Mixbook (From $0.69)  - 9/10 stars, Read the Mixbook Review
  2. Shutterfly (From $15.99)  - 9/10 stars, Read the Shutterfly Review
  3. Picaboo (From $19.99) - 8/10 stars, Read the Picaboo Review
  4. Snapfish (From $34.99) - 7/10 stars, Read the Snapfish Review
  5. Apple photos (From $24.99) - 5/10 stars, Read the Apple Photos Review
  6. Blurb Bookify (From $14.99) - 5/10 stars, Read the Blurb Bookify Review
  7. Montage (From $29.99) - 5/10 stars, Read the Montage Review

For the second year in a row, our Editors' Choice Award goes to Mixbook, for its intelligent, versatile and creativity-enabling software and the excellent quality of its printed books. Shutterfly came in a very close second. Both services produced great books. However, Mixbook gets the edge for its superior photo reproduction, and easier-to-use interface that offers greater flexibility.

Mixbook is currently having a promotion which can get you up to 55% discount with the code TMNWBK when you click the below:

How We Tested and Rated

Our testing and analyses focused on two areas: the vendor's software for creating the photo book, and the printed photo books themselves. In tallying our results, we gave double weight to our rating of the printed books, since no matter how good the software is, the end result is what is most important.

Credit: Jeremy Lips / Tom's GuideCredit: Jeremy Lips / Tom's Guide

In testing and rating each service's photo-creation software, we paid particular attention to ease of use, as well as the quality and versatility of the software's themes, page layouts, clip art and more. We also focused on flexibility and how well the software enables your creativity. In particular, how easy it is to customize and personalize the page layouts, such as adjusting photo or text size, orientation, and placement on the page.

To rate the printed photo books, we created a blind test for our small jury of experts in photography, printing, art and book production. In other words, none of us knew which book came from which service.

Related Guides:
The Best Photo Card Services
The Best Custom-Printed Calendars
The Best Photo Editing Software
The Best Photo Management Apps
The Best Photo Storage Sites
The Best Filters for Your Lenses
Create a new thread in the Digital Cameras forum about this subject