'True Detective: Night Country' season finale — can it stick the landing and become 2024's first great show?

True Detective characters find evidence in season 4
(Image credit: HBO)

"True Detective" season 4 hasn't been flawless, but it's undoubtedly been a hit for HBO and the streaming service Max. Jodie Foster's performance as Liz Danvers has largely been masterful, showing a command of the script and the room. Kali Reis has also been impressive as Trooper Evangeline Navarro in what is her first TV appearance ever.

The critical reviews have largely matched this assessment. The season has received a 93% "fresh" rating on Rotten Tomatoes, with nearly all critics praising the performance and the hints of horror around the show's majestic, dark setting.

That's not to say things have been perfect. Audiences have largely been split on the season, with most either loving or hating the season. The cosmic horror vibes work for me and fellow Tom's Guide writer Ryan Epps but haven't landed for everyone.

Then there are the fans of the previous three seasons, which were helmed by former showrunner Nic Pizzolatto. Fans have criticized season 4, helmed by new showrunner Issa López, for not being like the previous three seasons, and Pizzolatto joined them in disparaging the show online.

Here's the thing — "True Detective" is an anthology series and I don't care that season 4 doesn't match seasons 1-3. Max didn't even need to attach the "True Detective" branding, as it's irrelevant as to whether the show is good or not. It is good.

Here's the thing — "True Detective" is an anthology series and I don't care that season 4 doesn't match seasons 1-3. I think that perhaps the show didn't even need to attach the "True Detective" branding to the show, but it's honestly irrelevant as to whether the show is good or not. And it is good. Episode 4 was admittedly a rough one, but then episode 5 bounced back with an incredible ending.

There is a problem with this show though, and if episode 6 doesn't manage it appropriately, the season finale of this show could fail to stick the landing. Simply put — we're running out of time to land the plane.

'True Detective: Night Country' could fall through the ice if it runs out of time

While I've enjoyed season 4 a lot so far, it's not flawless. And one of its biggest flaws is its pacing. At times it almost feels like this show was written to be longer than six episodes — the previous three seasons were eight episodes each — but at other times it feels like this was originally thought of as a movie.

That leaves a fair amount of loose threads that still need tying up at the end of the season finale. 

Some of these may never get tied up, and that's okay. I don't think the show needs to lay out exactly what the oranges mean or why teal/turquoise blue is important, and if the one-eyed polar bear is a mere spirit animal then that's fine.

But some questions do need to be answered before the show wraps up in episode 6. We need to know how Silver Sky Mining was involved in these killings, even if we now have an idea of how the company was involved in the killing of Annie Kowtok. We need to know more about what happened with Liz's son Holden and we need at least some level of resolution with Liz and her daughter Leah (Isabella Star LaBlanc), whether for good or ill.

And most importantly, we need to know who actually killed all these people. The show almost seems intentionally in a holding pattern, drawing things out until the right time for the reveal arrives. Will the killer be human? Or something more cosmic? Have we met them already? Is it Blair, the redheaded Ennis resident who seems to be everywhere despite having little to do with the story of the gruesome murders at Tsalal Station?

I'm personally open to any direction that the show goes with the answers to these questions. But it does need to answer them in an intentionally satisfying way, and managing that in just 60 or so minutes could be a tall order.

If "True Detective: Night Country" succeeds, it'll become the clear best show of 2024 so far. Yes, it's February, but that still means something. But if it fails to stick the landing, what once showed such promise could go down as another show that came up short of greatness. One way or another, we'll know after Sunday.

More from Tom's Guide

Malcolm McMillan
Streaming Editor

Malcolm McMillan is a Streaming Editor for Tom's Guide, covering all the latest in streaming TV shows and movies. That means news, analysis, recommendations, reviews and more for just about anything you can watch, including sports! If it can be seen on a screen, he can write about it.

Before writing for Tom's Guide, Malcolm worked as a fantasy football analyst writing for several sites and also had a brief stint working for Microsoft selling laptops, Xbox products and even the ill-fated Windows phone. He is passionate about video games and sports, though both cause him to yell at the TV frequently. He proudly sports many tattoos, including an Arsenal tattoo, in honor of the team that causes him to yell at the TV the most.

Read more
Billy Bob Thornton as Tommy Norris in season 1, episode 4 of "Landman" streaming on Paramount Plus.
'Landman' season finale could make or break this show for me — here's why
Star Wars Skeleton Crew full cast
I liked 'Star Wars: Skeleton Crew' a lot more than I thought — but there's one big unanswered question
L-R: Michael Fassbender as Martian and Hugh Bonneville as Richardson in "The Agency," episode 10, season 1, streaming on Paramount Plus with Showtime.
This new spy thriller on Paramount Plus just wrapped up an epic first season — and it literally gave me chills
Gary Oldman as Jackson Lamb in "Slow Horses" season 4 on Apple TV Plus (2024)
I've streamed 53 shows in 2024 — here's my 10 favorite episodes
Adam Scott and Britt Lower in "Severance."
'Severance' season 2 episode 9 sets the stage for an epic season finale — here's why
James Marsden and Sterling K. Brown in Paradise
'Paradise' season finale officially makes Hulu's political thriller the best show of the year so far
Latest in HBO Max
Poster for The Sex Lives of College Girls
'The Sex Lives of College Girls' canceled by Max after 3 seasons
(From L to R) Rohan (Nik Dodani), Josh (Brandon Flynn), Dorothy (Edie Falco), John (Dean Norris), and Liddie (Lisa Kuthrow) in The Parenting
Max top 10 movies — here’s the 3 worth watching right now
In court in Dedham, Massachusetts. (From left) Attorney Emily Little, Karen Read and attorney David Yannetti
How to watch 'A Body in The Snow: The Trial of Karen Read' from anywhere online
Joaquin Phoenix as Beau in Beau is Afraid
Joaquin Phoenix's divisive dark comedy arrives on Max — and I can't stop thinking about it
Hugh Grant as Mr. Reed in "Heretic"
Max top 10 movies — here’s the 3 worth watching right now
Hugh Grant in "Heretic"
Hugh Grant’s terrifying villain turn just landed on Max — and it’s got 91% on Rotten Tomatoes
Latest in Opinion
iPhone 12
A port-free iPhone is fine with the EU — and if it happens, I’m ready for it
Sony UBP-X700 on stand in living room
Forget streaming — I think Sony's new 4K Blu-ray player is coming at just the right time
Jesse Eisenberg as Simon / James in the film "The Double"
One of the best psychological thrillers I’ve ever seen is streaming free on Prime Video — and it’s still stuck in my mind
Daniel Craig in Knives Out 2, Glen Powell as Gary Johnson in Hit Man and Jennifer Lawrence in No Hard Feelings
There’s been 136 Netflix No. 1 movies in the last 4 years — here’s the 15 you need to watch
Choi Min-sik in Oldboy
You’ll never believe the twists in this cult classic Korean thriller — watch it now before it leaves Netflix
March Madness games on YouTube TV using multiview
This is how I've streamed March Madness for the past 2 years — and it's the only way to watch every second of all 67 games
  • jefflessenberry
    Perhaps you should take a look at @screencrush YouTube breakdown on the series. The season 4 actually wraps completely back around to season one.
    Reply
  • annisarsha
    Surely you're joking or getting HBO kickbacks. This series has been an absolute hot mess. One last episode won't be enough to redeem it.
    Reply
  • jefflessenberry
    I do find it funny that people jump to the conspiracy theory that if someone has a different opinion they must be on someone's payroll. I was not commenting on the season and how it compares. It was on the fact that the story lines wraps back around and I was educated in that fact after watching the screencrush youtube videos. Anyway ... i need to get back to my job at HBO and I should be careful since alot of my coworkers are lizard people and the drive back takes me near the edge of the flat earth. FYI ... that was me joking unless you believe all of those things.
    Reply