‘Jeffrey Dahmer Story’ just shot to No. 1 on Netflix — and it’s causing a backlash

Evan Peters in Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story
(Image credit: Netflix)

Ryan Murphy, the co-creator of American Horror Story, has a new crime thriller on Netflix recounting the life and horrific crimes of Jeffrey Dahmer. And while the show is pulling plenty of interest, it’s also receiving criticism for a perceived attempt to romanticize the actions of a serial killer. 

The show is called Dahmer — Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story, and it sees Murphy reunite with Ian Brennan. The duo also co-created Glee and Scream Queens alongside Brad Falchuk (who isn’t involved in this project). And as the name suggests the 10-episode limited series follows the murders of American serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer, who is portrayed by Evan Peters in this instance. 

This is far from the first time Dahmer’s story has been told, as there are dozens of  documentaries on the subject. There's even a theatrical movie, My Friend Dahmer, which was released in 2017. However, the latest adaptation of the true crime tale comes courtesy of Netflix (which is putting on a huge live stream this weekend, so check out our Netflix Tudum live blog) and is generating both significant interest and a sizable level of backlash. 

While the show currently enjoys a 91% audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes, and critics have been quick to praise Peters’ committed performance as the serial killer, concerns that the show romanticizes the killing of 17 innocent men have been raised. A tweet imploring viewers to remember the victims rather than Dahmer has amassed more than 100,000 likes.   

The casting of Evan Peters could be partially responsible for the online enthusiasm surrounding the show. Peters is a highly popular figure on the internet and has attracted a very devoted following over the years. As the below tweet notes, it’s okay to praise Peters’ performance but Dahmer himself deserves nothing but condemnation. 

Concerns have also been raised around Netflix potentially profiting off the victims of Dahmer’s murderous spree. Whether the streamer has made any form of financial commitment to the families of the victims is currently unknown. 

There have been additional calls for Netflix’s Jeffrey Dahmer Story to be the last fictional adaptation of his life. Of course, the show is currently trending on social media and is highly likely to crack the Netflix top 10 in the coming days, so there is clearly a lot of audience interest in content about Dahmer making this request perhaps rather unlikely. 

If you’re looking for a new crime thriller to binge watch you might want to check out Dahmer — Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story on Netflix (also, Murphy's got a new Netflix series called The Watcher that will debut its first trailer at Netflix Tudum 2022). By most accounts, it’s a tightly crafted series with a remarkable leading performance from Peters. But make sure to remember the characters on screen were real people that tragically lost their lives to a cruel and evil man. It’s important that we don’t lose sight of that in the name of entertainment. 

Next: Looks like Dahmer is now the second-highest viewed English-language show on Netflix, and there's still room to grow. Netflix’s 'Lou' with Allison Janney is a twist on Taken — should you watch? The Red Sox vs Yankees live streams feature Aaron Judge chasing home run history.

Rory Mellon
Entertainment Editor (UK)

Rory is an Entertainment Editor at Tom’s Guide based in the UK. He covers a wide range of topics but with a particular focus on gaming and streaming. When he’s not reviewing the latest games, searching for hidden gems on Netflix, or writing hot takes on new gaming hardware, TV shows and movies, he can be found attending music festivals and getting far too emotionally invested in his favorite football team.