Netflix's new Christmas movie just hit the top 10 list — but you should stream these 3 instead

That Christmas on Netflix
(Image credit: Netflix)

Netflix has continued to count down the days to Christmas with the release of yet another holiday feature: "That Christmas".

Now that we're into December, clearly, plenty of families are getting into the spirit of the season, as this new release has shot straight to the No. 2 spot on Netflix just days after it's December 4 release. The problem? I just don't think it's destined to become a Christmas classic.

"That Christmas", for those who've yet to check it out, is an animated Christmas comedy caper that's based on a collection of stories penned by Richard Curtis (yes, the same Richard Curtis behind "Love Actually" and "About Time").

To put it bluntly, "That Christmas" is sort of... fine, as festive entertainment goes. It's a collection of entwined small-town Christmas tales about family and friendship and hits all the expected emotional beats.

Even though it boasts a starry voice cast containing the likes of Brian Cox, Fiona Shaw, and Jodie Whittaker and is serviceable for some family viewing, I found it to be a fairly bland watch, and don't think it's got much to offer beyond being disposable holiday fodder. That's not just my opinion, either: the movie's split critics, and currently holds a less-than-stellar 57% critics' score on Rotten Tomatoes.

With that in mind, if you were planning to stream "That Christmas" but are now in need of some fresh festive inspiration, I've put together a small list of great Christmas movies that you can stream on Netflix and listed them below.

'A Boy Called Christmas'

A Boy Called Christmas | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube A Boy Called Christmas | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube
Watch On

Before helming "Ghostbusters: Frozen Empire", director Gil Kenan brought us a solid dose of holiday cheer with his 2021 live-action festive adventure, "A Boy Called Christmas.

The movie follows an ordinary young lad, Nikolas (Henry Lawfull) as he sets out to find his father, Joel (Michiel Huisman), who's embarked on a quest to find Elfhelm, the village of the elves. No prizes for guessing that this Nikolas will eventually become the Saint Nick.

Accompanied by a talking mouse and, later, a reindeer, the 13-year-old sets off on his search and soon ends up on a much grander adventure. Framed as a bedtime tale told to three kids, it's a cozy, comforting watch, one which stand above many other holiday movies you'll find on Netflix at this time of year.

Watch 'A Boy Called Christmas' on Netflix now

'Klaus'

Klaus | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube Klaus | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube
Watch On

"Klaus" hit Netflix way back in 2019 and, in my humble opinion, this Oscar-nominated animated feature is still one of the streamer's best-ever holiday releases.

It might be another Santa origin story, but it's a very different affair to my first recommendation. "Klaus" revolves around the unlikely partnership that forms between Jesper, a selfish, 19th-Century Norweigan postman (voiced by Jason Schwartzman), and Klaus, a reclusive woodsman and toymaker (JK Simmons). Together, the pair transform Smeerensburg from a town dominated by feuds and establish the age-old tradition of sending letters to Santa Claus in exchange for toys.

Beautifully animated and full of charm, "Klaus" is one of my go-to Christmas movies, and is absolutely worth seeking out if you've not experienced it before.

Watch 'Klaus' on Netflix now

'The Christmas Chronicles'

The Christmas Chronicles | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube The Christmas Chronicles | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube
Watch On

"The Christmas Chronicles" is a predictable holiday watch, and sure isn't award-worthy fare (few holiday movies are), but it has one big selling point: Kurt Russell's enthusiastic performance as Santa Claus.

In Clay Kaytis' festive flick, we meet Kate and Teddy Pierce, two children who hatch a plan to capture Santa Claus while he's busy delivering presents on Christmas Eve.

When their scheme goes wrong, the kids end up causing Santa's sleigh to crash, and they're forced to work with the big man in red and his helpful elves to save Christmas before it's too late. Yes, "Chronicles" has its low points, but I really do think this is a movie Santa worth seeing in action.

Watch 'The Christmas Chronicles' on Netflix now

If you've already seen all three Christmas movies on this list, or you're not sure they're right for you, fear not; we've got tons more holiday recommendations on-site. For more inspiration, check out our guides to the five classic Christmas movies you need to watch this year, or the five best Christmas flicks that are totally underrated.

More from Tom's Guide

Staff Writer, Streaming

Martin is a Streaming Writer at Tom’s Guide, covering all things movies and TV. If it’s in the theaters or available to stream somewhere, he’s probably watched it… especially if it has a dragon in it. Before joining the team, he was a Staff Writer at What To Watch where he wrote about a broad range of shows that stretched from "Doctor Who" and "The Witcher" to "Bridgerton" and "Love Island". When he’s not watching the next must-see movie or show, he’s probably still in front of a screen playing massive RPGs, reading, spending a fortune on TCGs, or watching the NFL.

Read more
Dominic Sessa and Paul Giamatti in The Holdovers
5 best Christmas movies with 90% or higher on Rotten Tomatoes
Wes Brown and Lacey Chabert in Haul Out the Holly
7 best Hallmark Christmas movies on Netflix, ranked
(L-R) Jude Law as Graham Simpkins and Cameron Diaz as Amanda Woods in "The Holiday"
There's 8 Christmas movies in Prime Video’s top 10 — here’s the 3 worth watching right now
Dwayne Johnson and Chris Evans star in Red One
7 Christmas action movies like 'Red One' but better
Bill Murray in Scrooged
5 best Christmas movies to watch on Prime Video now
Isabela Merced and Shameik Moore in "Let It Snow" on Netflix
One of the most underrated romantic comedies on Netflix is the Christmas movie I watch every year
Latest in Netflix
Tsuyoshi Kusanagi as Kazuya Takaichi in "Bullet Train Explosion" on Netflix
Netflix just dropped first trailer for new action thriller — and it looks like a must-watch
Maria Debska in "Just One Look" now streaming on Netflix
Netflix’s new Harlan Coben mystery thriller has arrived — and it should be your next binge watch
Rachel Weisz as Marlee in "Runaway Jury"
This overlooked legal thriller just crashed the Netflix top 10 — and now is the perfect time to watch
Lee Kwang-soo as Han Sang-hun and Gong Seung-yeon as Lee Yu-jeong in "Karma" coming soon to Netflix
Netflix’s new crime thriller is one of my most anticipated shows of 2025 — watch the first trailer now
Kate Hudson as Isla Gordon in "Running Point" now streaming on Netflix
Netflix's new No. 1 comedy show is perfect for 'Ted Lasso' fans — and viewers rate it 95% on Rotten Tomatoes
Resident Alien
5 best sci-fi shows to stream on Netflix right now
Latest in News
Mac Studio M4 Max
Apple announces Mac Studio with M4 Max and M3 Ultra — here's what's new
Tsuyoshi Kusanagi as Kazuya Takaichi in "Bullet Train Explosion" on Netflix
Netflix just dropped first trailer for new action thriller — and it looks like a must-watch
OneUI 7 on a phone and a Samsung rep on stage
Samsung confirms full One UI 7 release is happening in April — here’s what you need to know
Maria Debska in "Just One Look" now streaming on Netflix
Netflix’s new Harlan Coben mystery thriller has arrived — and it should be your next binge watch
SwitchBot Roller Shade
SwitchBot's new customizable roller shade will bring style to your smart home
A phone showing the Strava app
Good news for Strava users — the app just reversed a hugely unpopular decision