What Are the Best Prepaid/Value Plans?
If you’re looking to save money on your monthly cellphone bill, opting for prepaid wireless service may be the way to go, especially as carriers offer a wider selections of phones to their prepaid customers. Should you opt for prepaid service, we recommend MetroPCS’s plans for individuals, whether you opt for a tiered data plan or need unlimited data each month. The T-Mobile-owned discount carrier offers the best performing network and a range of plans that appeal to users with different data needs.
Families will find lots to like about the discounts MetroPCS and Cricket offer on multiple prepaid lines. But Boost’s discounts make it our choice for a family of four, at least while that plan remains available.
How We Picked the Best Prepaid Plans: Data allotments vary widely among prepaid carriers. To make the best comparison, we looked at the plans closest to 3GB of data each month. We also looked at the range of plans available, including unlimited data plans as well as plans for low-data users. Now that Virgin has dropped its Data Sharing Done Right plans, only four carriers — Boost, Cricket, MetroPCS and T-Mobile — offer prepaid family plans, so we focused on discounts available as you add lines to a prepaid plan. As with other categories, network performance, including our own 4G speed testing, figured into our choices.
Best Prepaid Plan for Individuals: MetroPCS
Best Plan: 3GB, $40 a month
Who Should Get It: Prepaid customers who want the best network performance
MetroPCS’s 3GB plan for $40 a month is the best prepaid option, thanks in large part to the fact that MetroPCS uses T-Mobile’s network. That helped MetroPCS score the best network performance among the prepaid carriers we tested. Boost and Cricket offer less expensive plans, but MetroPCS’s better performance makes up for the few dollars of difference.
If your data needs aren’t quite as extensive, MetroPCS’s $30 1GB plan offers a decent amount of data for a nice low price. (You’ll only get half that data for the same money at Virgin.)
Best Alternative Prepaid Plan: Boost
Best Plan: 2GB, $30 a month
Who Should Get It: People who stick with one carrier and pay their bill promptly
Prepaid customers who can live with Boost’s performance — the prepaid carrier uses the network of its parent company Sprint — may find plenty to like with Boost’s plans. A 2GB plan will cost you $35 a month, and you can knock $5 off the cost by enrolling in autopay. As added incentive to pay your bill promptly, Boost adds 500MB to your data plan when you make three months of on-time payments. After a year-and-a-half, that 2GB plan can grow into a 5GB plan while still costing you $30 a month. It’s an attractive offer, but only if you don’t plan on switching carriers.
If that sounds good to you, jump on the plan now. At the end of September, Boost is phasing out its current plans for new Unlimited Unhook’d plans, where a plan with 1GB of LTE data will cost $30 a month. (You can read more about Boost’s unlimited offering below.)
Low-Cost Alternative: Cricket
Best Plan: 2.5GB, $35 a month
Who Should Get It: Bargain hunters who want more than 2GB and will use autopay
Cricket splits the difference between MetroPCS and Boost with a 2.5GB data plan that costs $40 a month. Enroll in autopay, and that brings the cost down to $35. It saves some money from MetroPCS’s plan and gives you more data than Boost’s, but it also means you’ll have to use Cricket’s network, which fared the worst in our testing. (Cricket is an AT&T subsidiary.)
Cricket’s higher data plans offer 5GB and 10GB for monthly rates of $45 and $55, respectively. You can save $5 off your monthly bill by using automatic payments.
Best Unlimited Prepaid Plan: MetroPCS
Best Plan: Unlimited Data, $60 a month
Who Should Get It: Data-hungry cell phone users who want the fastest network
Prepaid carriers have expanded their options for heavy-data users, with Boost, Cricket and MetroPCS all offering unlimited data plans to prepaid customers. Of this trio, MetroPCS’s $60 unlimited plan is the best choice. It’s cheaper than Cricket’s $70 plan, and we’ve found MetroPCS’s performance to be better than what Boost and Cricket offer on their networks.
Boost currently offers a $60 unlimited plan ($55 with auto-pay enrollment), but its days are numbered. The carrier has a new Unlimited Unhook’d plan that costs less — $50 — but features what Boost calls “optimized” video, meaning it will stream at 480p resolution. Similarly, music streams at 500 Kbps on this new unlimited plan.
Other Heavy Data Options: Virgin
Best Plan: 4GB, $40
Who Should Get It: Heavy data users
Virgin’s best plan seems appealing to users who demand a lot of data, but don’t want to pay up for unlimited data. You can get 4GB for $40 a month — exactly what MetroPCS charges for 3GB. But Virgin, like Boost, uses Sprint’s network, so you won’t get the performance that you do with MetroPCS.
Other Virgin offerings aren’t as appealing. The carrier’s $30 monthly plan offers only 500MB of high-speed data, while a $50 plan provides 6GB. Other carriers — notably Boost and MetroPCS — have unlimited options for just $10 more each month.
Limited Options: Straight Talk
Best Plan: 5GB, $60
Who Should Get It: Heavy data users who make international calls
Straight Talk doesn’t have much to offer people who consume around 3GB of data each month. The provider’s lowest-priced prepaid plan — excluding $30 plan with a paltry 100MB of data — offers 5GB of high-speed data for $45 a month. For $15 more, you can add unlimited mobile-to-mobile calling to Mexico, Canada, China and India. Straight Talk also added $55 monthly plan with 10GB of data, which doesn’t compare favorably to unlimited data plans from MetroPCS and Boost that cost just $5 more and rely on better networks.
Best Prepaid Family Plan: Boost
Best Plan: Boost's 2GB plan for four lines of data, $100
Who Should Get It: Families with more than three lines to take advantage of Boost’s discounts.
Boost follows the lead of Cricket and MetroPCS by offering discounts for each additional line. Under Boost's current offering, you start with a single line of 2GB LTE data for $35 a month. Add a second line, and Boost knocks $5 off the cost of that 2GB line. Adding a third line saves another $10 off the total cost while Boost cuts $25 off the cost of the fourth line. We'll save you the trouble of doing math: four lines with 2GB each will cost $100 a month at Boost. (You can add a fifth line for free, in essence, as Boost will wipe out the $35 cost.) You can save an additional $5 by enrolling in auto-pay, bringing your monthly bill down to $95.
Boost also offers discounts on multiple lines for its 5GB and unlimited data plans, though these plans are slated to disappear at the end of September in favor of the Unlimited Unhook’d plans which start at $50 a month, with additional lines available for $30 a month. That will make Boost a far less attractive option for families, but so long as the discounted tiered data lines for families remain, it’s still our top choice.
Cricket also uses escalating discounts for adding more lines, knocking $10 off a second line, $20 off a third, $30 off a fourth, and $40 off a fifth. So a family of four that signs up for a 2.5GB plan will just $100 a month. That's more data per line than what Boost offers for its $100 plan, but Boost has a better network in our tests. Also Cricket's autopay discount doesn't cover group plans.
MetroPCS also offers discounts for additional lines — a comparatively stingy $5 for each line for up to five lines. With MetroPCS, a family of four would pay $140 each month for 3GB of data per family member. We’d recommend MetroPCS for a family of two, since the difference in discounts for multiple lines between MetroPCS and other carriers isn’t as stark.
T-Mobile is the only major carrier to offer prepaid family plans. The first line of a T-Mobile plan with 2GB of data costs $50, while the second line costs $30, and each additional line costs $10. That means a family of four would pay $100 each month in exchange for 2GB each of data.
Prepaid Service from Major Carriers
The major U.S. carriers — AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile and Verizon — all have prepaid offerings. But you’ll pay more for data each month with the Big Four than you would with most of the discount carriers mentioned above. You’ll get better network performance, but you won’t enjoy the pricing advantages associated with prepaid service.
Among the major carriers, T-Mobile has the best offerings, with prices identical to its MetroPCS subsidiary, starting at $40 a month for 3GB of high-speed data. Sprint’s $35-a-month prepaid plan for 1GB of data may appeal to users who don’t need much in the way of data. AT&T’s prepaid plans are fairly pricey — 3GB of data will cost you $45 a month, though you can save $5 by enrolling in autopay — but you can rollover unused data. Instead of saving money by enrolling in autopay with Verizon, you get more data: Verizon's $45 prepaid plan gives you the same 3GB of data as AT&T if you make automatic payments but only 2GB if you don't. If you place a lot of calls to Mexico or Canada, consider Verizon's $60 prepaid plan, with offers 6GB of data with autopay (5GB without) along with unlimited texting and calling to those two countries. (The $45 plan only offers unlimited texting to Canada and Mexico.)
- Tested: Cricket, MetroPCS Much Slower Than Parent Networks
- Wireless Carriers - Rankings, Ratings and Reviews
- How to Find a Lost or Stolen Phone