Will The Sandman be canceled or renewed by Netflix? Here’s what Neil Gaiman says

om Sturridge as Dream, Kirby Howell-Baptiste as Death in The Sandman
(Image credit: Netflix)

Fans have been concerned about whether The Sandman will get picked up for season 2 or if it will be canceled and return to The Dreaming. Netflix has been shockingly silent on the matter, though it's been over six weeks since the show debuted.

Luckily, for fans of the legendary DC Comics series, executive producer Neil Gaiman is not as silent as Netflix. In a recent tweet, Gaiman laid out exactly why The Sandman has not been picked up for a second season: You’re not watching it.

Or rather, you are not watching it the way Netflix wants you to watch it.

Netflix is famous for its full-season binge model. Even in the case of Stranger Things season 4, which split the full season into two volumes, they were just mini-seasons that Netflix expected you to binge. 

Gaiman seems to have info that fans of The Sandman, however, are spreading out the series rather than binge-watching it. This data is apparently what has made Netflix so hesitant to pick up the seemingly successful series.

Interestingly enough, we called out this issue in our early coverage of The Sandman. Even after just one episode, it felt odd that Netflix would want viewers to binge The Sandman. The series is deep and leaves you excited for what is coming in the next chapter, or in this case, episode. So, it's not much of a surprise that viewers are wanting to savor it just as much as we did. 

The Sandman: Critical and audience response 

A graphic showing The Sandman as the number one show for Netflix the first week of August 2022.

(Image credit: Netflix)

By most metrics, The Sandman has been a hit. According to the Netflix Global Top 10, the show has been one of the top TV shows for Netflix since its August 5 debut. It was the No. 1 show for the first three weeks it was out, and has yet to leave the Top 10. So, even if fans are not bingeing the episodes, it seems they are certainly watching.

The comic book adaptation was also a critical success out of the gate. It started at 85 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, a number that has since increased to 87 percent and a "Certified Fresh" rating

One of the reviews further highlights the issue that Netflix is having with the show. Steve Murray from ArtsATL says, “The lavish, 10-episode Netflix version is a good example of Gaiman’s strengths and weaknesses ... though I’m enjoying it, I don’t feel rushed to reach the finish line. The atmosphere and the immersion are often better than the payoff in Gaiman’s stuff.” Yet another example of people simply not wanting to binge the show.

Audiences are also largely positive about the show, though they are a bit down on it compared to critics. Right now, the audience score sits at 80 percent, which is still pretty high. There are a lot of comments about the pacing of the show, and at first glance, audiences seem to want a bit quicker, faster-paced show. Some might even say — more bingeable. 

The Sandman season 2: Outlook  

Tom Sturridge as Dream, reading the book of Rose Walker, in The Sandman

(Image credit: Netflix)

Ultimately, Netflix should renew The Sandman season 2. It would be a shame for them to throw away a critically liked, commercially successful (at least in terms of viewership numbers) comic book adaptation that separates itself from some of the recent stale Marvel fare. Netflix was also spending a rumored $15 million per episode, so it would be odd to just write that off unless it was an unmitigated disaster.

But for now, we and Gaiman will be left waiting to see what the streaming service decides. Luckily, there are tons of other shows to watch on Netflix, including Fate: The Winx Saga: Season 2 and the return of The Great British Baking Show

Read Next: Netflix just canceled this other comic book show before a single episode even aired

Malcolm McMillan
Senior Streaming Writer

Malcolm McMillan is a senior writer for Tom's Guide, covering all the latest in streaming TV shows and movies. That means news, analysis, recommendations, reviews and more for just about anything you can watch, including sports! If it can be seen on a screen, he can write about it. Previously, Malcolm had been a staff writer for Tom's Guide for over a year, with a focus on artificial intelligence (AI), A/V tech and VR headsets.

Before writing for Tom's Guide, Malcolm worked as a fantasy football analyst writing for several sites and also had a brief stint working for Microsoft selling laptops, Xbox products and even the ill-fated Windows phone. He is passionate about video games and sports, though both cause him to yell at the TV frequently. He proudly sports many tattoos, including an Arsenal tattoo, in honor of the team that causes him to yell at the TV the most.