John Mulaney's new Netflix live talk show gets this one thing right

John Mulaney in "Everybody's Live with John Mulaney" at The Sunset Gower Studios on March 12, 2025 in Los Angeles, CA.
(Image credit: Ryan West/Netflix)

Netflix debuted "Everybody's Live with John Mulaney" last night, so I had to watch it. I'll frankly watch the standup comedian read the dictionary, but after last year's "Everbody's in LA," I was excited to see what he had cooked up.

So, I was a bit surprised to see how much remained unchanged. I'm not disappointed — I'd have been distraught if Richard Kind wasn't back doing his best Ed McMahon impression. But I thought going into it that it would be more like a brand-new show.

Instead, we got something more akin to season 2 of last year's weeklong talk show, which Mulaney as much as admitted in his opening monologue.

But there is one massive change between "Everybody's Live with John Mulaney" and "Everybody's in LA." It's now weekly instead of nightly, and it's the one thing above all else that this show gets right.

Weekly episodes can fix rookie mistakes

Michael Keaton, Joan Baez and John Mulaney at "Everybody's Live with John Mulaney" at The Sunset Gower Studios on March 12, 2025 in Los Angeles, CA.

(Image credit: Ryan West/Netflix)

Despite hosting a six-episode talk show last year, Mulaney is essentially new to hosting a live talk show. In his opening monologue, he admits that 10 months is "just enough time" to forget how to do the show.

The good news is he doesn't seem to have missed a step. In terms of quality and feel, the new show feels like a continuation of the old one.

Joan Baez dancing to Cypress Hill performing "Hits from the Bong" with a 17-piece orchestra should go down in the annals of TV history.

The bad news is that talk shows often miss bits, whether they're live or taped. Unless it's "Last Week Tonight," a show so perfect nobody should even try to replicate it, a bit or two is likely to fall flat.

And last night a bit or two definitely fell flat. The opening monologue was a bit meandering, the first interview segment with Michael Keaton and Jessica Roy didn't pop and while I love Tracy Morgan, the "King Latifah" bit teetered frequently between absurd and unhinged.

But some things worked, and they worked in the old show, too. The "Willy Loman Focus Group" segment will be talked about like a great "Saturday Night Live" sketch.

I definitely want more live music, too. Joan Baez dancing to Cypress Hill performing "Hits from the Bong" with a 17-piece orchestra should go down in the annals of TV history.

By going weekly, Mulaney can take a step back and see what worked and what didn't, getting a whole week to set things right and work out the kinks. That's a huge boon for the show and it's the biggest thing Mulaney and Netflix got right for a show that so far is getting more things right than not.

More from Tom's Guide

Malcolm McMillan
Streaming Editor

Malcolm McMillan is a Streaming Editor for Tom's Guide, covering all the latest in streaming TV shows and movies. That means news, analysis, recommendations, reviews and more for just about anything you can watch, including sports! If it can be seen on a screen, he can write about it.

Before writing for Tom's Guide, Malcolm worked as a fantasy football analyst writing for several sites and also had a brief stint working for Microsoft selling laptops, Xbox products and even the ill-fated Windows phone. He is passionate about video games and sports, though both cause him to yell at the TV frequently. He proudly sports many tattoos, including an Arsenal tattoo, in honor of the team that causes him to yell at the TV the most.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

Read more
Everybody Live With John Mulaney
Netflix top 10 shows — here's the 3 worth watching right now
Charlotte Nicdao and Rob McElhenney in Mythic Quest season 4
‘Mythic Quest’ season 4 is as delightful and dysfunctional as ever — it’s my happy place
Long Bright River; John Mulaney; The Wheel of Time
6 top new TV shows to stream this week on Netflix, Prime Video and more (March 10-16)
Charlie Cox as Matt Murdock / Daredevil in "Daredevil: Born Again"
I just watched ‘Daredevil: Born Again’ and it has one serious problem
Maria Debska in Harlan Coben's Just One Look
Netflix top 10 shows — here's the 3 worth watching right now
Adam Scott in "Severance," now streaming on Apple TV Plus.
'Severance' season 2 premiere was worth the wait — and has a shocking Keanu Reeves cameo
Latest in Netflix
Tom Hiddleston as Robert Laing in "High Rise" now streaming on Netflix
5 best Netflix movies in March you haven't watched yet
Maria Debska in "Just One Look" now streaming on Netflix
3 best Netflix shows in March you haven't watched yet
Park Ji-hoon in "Park Ji-hoon" now streaming on Netflix
Netflix just added this action-packed drama ahead of season 2 — and viewers rate it 96% on Rotten Tomatoes
Max Rockatansky (Tom Hardy) stands on the hood of a car with an explosion behind him in a promotional still for Warner Bros. "Mad Max:Fury Road"
One of the best action movies ever made is leaving Netflix very soon — here's your last day to stream 'Mad Max: Fury Road'
Garrett (Sebastian De Souza) and Alex (Sofia Carson) (L-R) holding hands in Netflix's "The Life List"
New on Netflix — 5 new shows and movies I’d stream this week (March 24-30)
L-R: Claude (Marco Calvani), Danny (Colman Domingo), Kate (Tina Fey) and Jack (Will Forte) have their bags packed for Netflix's "The Four Seasons"
Netflix just teased a new comedy series starring Tina Fey, Steve Carrell and Colman Domingo — and we already have a release date
Latest in Opinion
The Amazfit T-Rex 3 shown close-up on a user's wrist with the snorkeling and surfing workout tracking modes displayed; colorful flowers are out of focus in the background
7 reasons why this budget-friendly smartwatch is my new go-to for surfing and swimming
Apple maps logo on iPhone screen
I avoided Apple Maps for trip planning — but these iOS 18 features are changing my mind
Adam Scott in "Severance," now streaming on Apple TV Plus.
'Severance' season 3 officially greenlit — but I may not watch after that season 2 finale
Woman has taped her mouth shut with a blue I shaped mouth tape
I tried I-shaped mouth tape to fall asleep faster but now I'm more tired than ever — here's why
An angled view of the distraction-free desk setup I built around the Oakywood Standing Desk Pro
I built a completely distraction-free desk setup with these 10 gadgets — and now I’m truly locked in
A Samsung DU7200 LED TV on a side table
I'm a TV reviewer — here's the one type of TV I wouldn't buy