Skip to main content

'Madden 25' Review: Subtly Improved But Not Quite Super

'Madden 25' has some much-needed tweaks and expanded creation and management options, but EA is saving the revolution for next-gen consoles.

Our Verdict

'Madden 25' has some much-needed tweaks and expanded creation and management options, but EA is saving the revolution for next-gen consoles.

For

  • Familiar gameplay, making it easy to jump in
  • Expanded creation/management options increase ways to explore the game
  • High replay value – if you like NFL Football, you can get through five seasons during your real team's one

Against

  • Revolutionary features touted by EA being saved for next-gen consoles
  • Defense considerably harder for lighter players
  • Change to "precision" running only improves top-tier NFL players
  • PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360: $59.99

Overview

The end of summer means a few things: back to school, colder weather on the way, and a new edition of "Madden NFL Football." That's the way it has been for 25 years now, as "Madden 25" celebrates its silver anniversary right on the cusp of a new console generation. The annual upgrade this year ($59.99 for Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3) unfortunately saves the revolutionary new features for the edition coming later this fall to next-generation consoles in the Xbox One and PS4 — both due in November, also for $59.99. The game for the PS3 and Xbox 360 largely relies on the "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" philosophy.

Features

With an annual sports game, there are a few things that will keep players coming back every year. Honestly, there are fans that will pick up each edition of "Madden" just for roster updates, play their own seasons, and never touch the rest of the game. For those players, you'll find a similar set of options to last year, with the Connected Careers from "Madden 13" replaced by Connected Franchise, which opens you up to controlling a player, a coach, or now even an owner as you try to lead your team to the Super Bowl. 

MORE: 10 Cool Things You Can Do in 'Grand Theft Auto V'

The owner mode has the most new features, with what is essentially a management simulator built into the game – something EA has had success with in Europe with its "FIFA" franchise. It's not for everyone, but if you've ever been dying to set merchandise prices, you're covered. For those who like every aspect of their games to allow for their own hand in creation, the owner mode does allow you to relocate your team (a Brooklyn NFL team? Yes, please!), choose a name, logo, uniform and stadium. It's like having a bit of EA's other behemoth franchise, "The Sims," inside your Football game. Basically, if you want a story in "Madden 25," you can make it all your own.