Bose QuietComfort 35 II vs. Sony WH-1000xM3: Face-Off

The Bose QuietComfort 35 II and the Sony WH-1000xM3 currently stand as the market's top noise-cancelling headphones, offering phenomenal quality and versatile performance at a sub-luxury value. If you're seeking an audio solution to block out your surroundings, on the ground or in the air, then owning one of these gadgets is a must.

But which one is right for you? We've pitted these two goliaths against each other to determine the real winner of the active noise-cancelling war.

Bose QC35 II vs Sony WH-1000xM3: Specs Compared

  Bose QC35 IISony WH-1000xM3
Price$349.95$349.99
ColorsBlack and SilverBlack, Silver, Midnight Blue and Triple Midnight
What's In the BoxAux cable, carrying case, micro USB cableAux cable, carrying case, travel adapter and USB-C cable
Battery Life20 hours (NC on); 40 hours (NC off)30 hours (NC on); 38 hours (NC off)
Size7.1 x 6.7 x 3.2 inches10.4 H x 2.9 W x 7.3 inches
Weight8.2 ounces9 ounces

Design

The Bose QuietComfort 35 IIs retain the overall aesthetics of the original QC35, but they are built from glass-filled nylon that gives them a sturdier build. The headphones' leather-padded outer headband combine with soft earpads to provide pleasant comfort for long-term listening. The reflective Bose logo on each ear cup adds flair to an already handsome pair of wireless cans.

With the WH-1000xM3, Sony updated the design of its next-generation headphones, but not for the better. Removing the faux-leather earcups in exchange for a plastic shell takes away from the WH-1000xM3's premium presence and makes them prone to scuffs. Despite their clunky feel, the improved ergonomics do form a gentler fit on the ears and head. You can wear the headphones for hours and not feel fatigued. The 9-ounce WH-1000xM3 is a bit heavier than the 8.2-ounce QC35 II.

Both headphones are available in different colors, but, Bose offers more bold options: Black, Silver, Midnight Blue and Triple Midnight. You can also customize your own QC35 II's for $50 extra. The WH-1000xM3 keeps it simple with two finishes: Black and Silver.

Winner: Bose QC35 II

Controls

Sometimes you just have to reward ingenuity, and that's the case with the WH-1000xM3. Its touch panel is especially responsive to swipe gestures and performs commands seamlessly. You can tap the sensor to control calls and playback, plus swipe up/down for volume, and left/right for track navigation. Two physical buttons are located below the touch panel, each assigned for listening modes and power. It doesn't get more practical than that.

While not as ultramodern, the QC35 II takes on the series' signature control scheme, which sits on the right side. On the ear cup is a power/pairing switch that offers a strong recoil when pressed. The right rear is where you'll find the volume and play/pause buttons, while the left ear cup hosts the new dedicated Action button to enable noise-cancelling modes.

The button layout does make functionality easy, and the tactility on each button is superb, but the touch controls on Sony's cans are too impressive to overlook.

Winner: Sony WH-1000xM3

Setup

Pairing either headphone to a device is simple and can be done in three ways: connecting via Bluetooth, downloading the accompanying app, or using NFC by tapping your compatible smartphone against the right ear cup. It saves time to do it directly from the app and allows you to personalize the QC35 II or WH-1000xM3 for enhanced listening. I did find the pairing process faster and more reliable on the QC35 II due to the Sony app's consistent crashing. The Bose Connect app also does a better job of picking up connection signals.

Winner: Bose QC35 II

Active Noise Cancellation

There's no denying that each headphone delivers premium ANC performance. Sony's made some significant strides with its noise-cancellation technology, and it shows in the WH-1000xM3. However, these improvements are outmatched by the QC35 II's greatest hallmark.

Bose programmed the QC35 II with two different noise-cancelling modes: Low and High. Both are remarkably effective and suited for different listening occasions, as Low tweaks the noise-cancelling levels in quieter or windy environments, while High takes it to the max and optimizes audio. The latter mode remains the preferable choice, blocking out everything without compromising audio. You can ride a plane or walk through the Village Halloween parade with these babies on and not be distracted by environmental fracas.

The WH-1000xM3 does a solid job of replacing ambient noise with amazing sound quality – just not as thoroughly. The headphones are powerful enough to hush loud TVs, rowdy pedestrians and train engines, while also letting in just the right amount of sound to hear what’s transpiring around you via Ambient Noise mode. Unfortunately, wind proves to be its Kryptonite, as outdoor drafts and passing winds hinder the sound quality.

Winner: Bose QC35 II

Audio Performance

Sony knows sound just like Bose knows noise cancellation, so it should come as no surprise who the victor is this round.

The WH-1000xM3 boasts a detailed and open soundstage that lets instruments and vocals breathe on every record. Sony's signature bass profile, along with the all-new QN1 processor, enhances fidelity and reduces distortion for cleaner, harder-hitting audio. These headphones definitely don't skimp on the low end and pack serious oomph that's most felt when listening to bass-heavy content. Live music recordings sound airy and immersive as well. Mids and highs are slightly richer when compared with the QC35 II.

The QC35 II carries over the audio qualities of its predecessor, which results in crisp, wide sound. Highs and mids are handled well to create plenty of balance. You'll be able to pick up on such distinct sounds as cymbal crashes and high-pitched synths. Bass still dominates much of the sound profile, presenting impactful lows that don't sound muddled but still lack depth. Astute listeners might notice some unevenness in treble, too.

MORE: Best Headphones - Top Earbuds and Headphones for the ...

An auxiliary cable comes bundled with both headphones, which increases the volume a notch on the QC35 II and higher still on the WH-1000xM3. Sony's headphones produce sharper clarity in wired mode.

Winner: Sony WH-1000xM3

Apps

Each pair of headphones has its own companion app that offers multiple ways to enhance the listening experience. Bose Connect and Sony Headphones Connect allow for adjusting the active noise-cancelling, auto-off timers and playback controls. However, Sony provides more utilities, such as room effects and multiple sound-customization settings.

Calibrating noise cancellation through Sony Headphones Connect is easier and more intuitive. Features like Adaptive Sound Control and NC Optimizer do all the work by analyzing your movements and settings to advance noise neutralization. Being able to emphasize sound in different positions using Sound Position Control is another cool way of personalizing output.

Bose Connect might lack an equalizer, but it has other unique functions such as Music Share to let you stream music to two pairs of Bose headphones, along with firmware support for future updates. That still isn't enough to compete with Sony's app.

Winner: Sony WH-1000xM3

Digital Assistant Support

Bose and Sony have embraced the digital assistant trend and integrated Google Assistant into their headsets. While Google's AI bot runs smoother on the WH-1000xM3, the QC35 II supports more platforms, including Alexa. Siri is also accessible on each pair, but it's not built-in.

Pressing the QC35 II's dedicated Action button instantly fires up Google Assistant with the slightest touch. Bose's built-in mics help register commands and vocals in loud environments, which can be attributed to Bose's unbeatable noise-neutralizing circuitry. Updating the headphones to version 6.2.2 and downloading the latest firmware earns you Alexa support.

MORE: 14 Alexa Speakers, Ranked from Best to Worst

Google Assistant functions similarly on the WH-1000xM3; press the listening mode button to hear your latest mobile notifications and hold it down to activate the feature. Command response is quicker on Sony's headphones, although the QC35 II gains the edge for having Alexa at its disposal.

Winner: Bose QC35 II

Connectivity

It's disappointing to see that neither pair of headphones supports Bluetooth 5.0. The QC35 II and WH-1000xM3 operate on Bluetooth 4.1 and 4.2, respectively. Range is set at 30 feet for each device. Based on pairing and reliability, Bose wins this round.

The QC35 II's power switch automatically puts them in pair mode and connects them instantly to your last synced device. Being able to pair to two devices simultaneously is a cool bonus. Media streaming runs smoothly on laptops and smartphones. On occasion, the headphones will extend connectivity past its standard range and get up to 35 feet without any interference.

MORE: Buying Headphones: Pros and Cons of Every Type

The WH-1000xM3 does offer steady connectivity, but also drops in range; interference is noticeable around the 25-foot mark. Latency is another issue, as you'll notice lag in sound when starting videos.

Winner: Bose QC35 II

Battery Life

What sounds better: 20 of playtime, or 30 hours? Therein lies the difference in battery life between the two headphones, with Sony leading the charge. No pun intended.

The WH-1000xM3 has a massive rechargeable battery that permits 27 hours of listening time on NC mode, at best. That translates to about 6.5 hours daily for four days of use. Playing music at high volumes and wireless calling can affect performance. Having USB-C integration is huge and generates quicker charges. Five hours of play-time can be achieved on a 5-minute charge, whereas a full battery takes somewhere between 2.5 and 3 hours. The headphones have a sleep function as well to preserve juice when inactive.

Bose' headphones surpass their advertised length in use, generating about 22 hours of playtime, which is surprising, but still shorter. However, you can get 40 hours when disabling noise-cancelling and Active EQ. The QC35 II  requires only 2 hours for a full battery, and quick-charging support allows for 2.5 hours on a 15-minute charge. The headphones also have a timer function to put the headphones into sleep mode.

Winner: Sony WH-1000xM3

Call Quality

The QC 35 II's built-in mics do a fine job of blocking ambient noise and producing clear vocals. Whether you're at home or walking outside in drafty conditions, call quality remains solid. Most callers had the impression I was speaking directly into my smartphone.

I don't recommend  taking calls on the WH-1000xM3, as the mics struggle with background interference, especially wind. Volume is low and voices sound even lower, making calls nearly inaudible.

Winner: Bose QC35 II

Value

On top of sharing similarities in performance, the QC35 II and WH-1000xM3 have the same price tag at $399.


On paper, the WH-1000xM3 looks to offer more bang for your buck. We're talking class-leading audio, killer battery life, smart controls, stellar noise cancellation and one of the coolest sound-customization apps out. However, noise cancellation is the name of the game, and the QC35 II is a master at it, while also delivering the goods in other areas.

Winner: Sony WH-1000xM3

Bottom Line

    Bose QuietComfort 35 IISony WH-1000xM3
Design (10)✔️  
Controls (5)  ✔️
Setup (5)✔️ 
Active Noise-Cancelling (20)✔️  
Sound Quality (20)  ✔️
Apps (5)
✔️
Battery Life (10)  ✔️
Digital Assistant Support (5)✔️  
Connectivity (5)✔️

Call Quality (5)✔️  
Value (5)  ✔️
Total Score5045

The QC35 II and WH-1000xM3 are two of the best-sounding, most feature-rich headphones money can buy. With that said, the victory goes to Bose for outperforming Sony in the one category that matters most here: noise cancellation.

Now, don't get me wrong – the WH-1000xM3 is an astounding pair of sound-silencers. Sony has made its noise-cancelling technology so adaptive and neutralized that listeners can enjoy the headphones' dynamic soundstage on any sound profile. The QC35 II just happens to beat it in more categories and has the better noise-cancelling experience.

Choosing between the two is still a win-win scenario, as the decision comes down to personal preference. Naturally, if class-leading sound takes precedence over everything else, add the WH-1000xM3 to your wish list. If having the best noise cancellation in the business means more to you, then stock your cart with the QC35 II, ASAP.

Credit: Tom's Guide

Create a new thread in the Audio forum about this subject
1 comment
Comment from the forums
    Your comment
  • falagund
    Connectivity (5) how can the Bose win when it doesn't support AptX or LDAC (or even Aptx HD)