Review: Microsoft SideWinder X4 Keyboard

Conclusion

It’s clear that Microsoft had one goal with the SideWinder X4: to make an affordable gaming keyboard that removes enough ghosting so no one gaming on it will miss a keystroke, even accidentally. Our tests prove that if you have ghosting issues when gaming, the X4 is an excellent and inexpensive solution at $59.95 (available in March). However, as gamers ourselves, we’ve found it difficult to even run into ghosting issues on most of today’s games, and truthfully most gamers will probably never notice ghosting on any keyboard.

That doesn’t mean it doesn’t happen, and as we discovered with the SideWinder X6, some users are undoubtedly very prone to ghosting. Logitech has a simple solution with the G19: any six keys and all modifiers, for a total of nine. The X6 is much more restrictive with which keys those are. The X4, with the required software, is twenty keys, plus the six macros. At nearly half the price of the SteelSeries 7G, it’s a steal.

The downside is that the design, especially compared to the X6, is a downgrade. The wrist rest is irritating and all the features are dumbed down. Right now, anyone can purchase a brand new X6 for under $45. So, unless you’re a pro gamer who must press at least six buttons at a time when gaming, stick with Microsoft’s flagship X6. On the off-chance you are a pro gamer, you’ve now got a budget keyboard option.

Create a new thread in the Streaming Video & TVs forum about this subject
This thread is closed for comments
19 comments
Comment from the forums
    Your comment
  • scione
    thats actually pretty cool I might be tempted to buy one if my current one dies
    -2
  • nicklasd87
    I thought the DAS keyboard also had a ludicrous amount of simultaneous key-types.
    -1
  • Anonymous
    Nice that it can register 11 to 15 keystrokes at once.
    Shame humanity lack fingers to use all of those at once.
    2
  • micky_lund
    stupid razer and their lack of support for win7...makes the lycosa ghost on like every game: Crysis, CWars, MW2, BF2, anything...even on google chrome, it ghosts
    -1
  • davendork
    I want to know how it is to type on it. I work on the same machine I game on. My favorite keyboards are in this order DasKeyboard, Logitech Illuminated, a Cherry brand keyboard with brown Cherry MX switches and an old DSI left-handed keyboard with ALPS switches.
    -1
  • jamezrp
    davendork, typing on keyboards is extremely personalized...for instance, I love the old IBM clicky laptop keyboards, that you find on T42's and older models. They don't make them anymore.

    The X4 is good to type on, slightly higher profile than the X6, but much lower profile than the G19. Unfortunately, I'm not familiar with the DAS keyboards or the Logitech Iluminated, but I can say that the X4 isn't a keyboard you should buy if you want the best typing experience. It's a keyboard you buy if you have a great need to defeat ghosting.
    -1
  • memeroot
    I love my SteelSeries 7G - probably the best keyboard in history (if you want mecanical without the clicky)

    due respect to the DAS I trialed it and it was nice also.
    -1
  • memeroot
    point of note - cash spent on a decent keyboard will be an investment that benefits every day for many years and builds.
    -1
  • jamezrp
    I don't know memeroot, I couldn't stand the 7G. The keys were way too high profile (I like low profile keys), and I felt like I was pressing the "big red button" for every keystroke. It was a pretty basic keyboard too, so for $150 it felt like I was stolen from. I like mechanical keyboards, but the key height really makes a big difference for speed typing.
    -1
  • memeroot
    not sure how many low-profile mechanical keyboards there are... the 7g has 2/3rds movement compared to most (ie the das) - though having said that the clicky keyboards mean that its easier to pull a half stroke.

    What keyboard did you go for in the end?

    regardless for speed typing yes you're correct a clicky keyboard is the way forward.
    -1
  • Supertrek32
    I still don't understand why there aren't any ergonomic gaming keyboards.

    Gamers are typically on the computer for hours - the perfect targets for ergonomic gear. Then add in the fact there's a PERFECT slot for macro buttons in the middle of the keyboard...

    I just don't understand why no one's made one yet... Until they do, I'm staying away from gaming keyboards.
    -1
  • memeroot
    http://images.google.co.uk/images?um=1&hl=nl&tbs=isch:1&sa=1&q=gaming+pad&btnG=Zoeken&aq=f&oq=&start=0

    I have the Belkin n52te - its ok if you're lazy but to be honest you're better off with a decent keyboard
    -1
  • E71
    damn it. every time we come close to finding a good anti-ghosting keyboard, our hopes are destroyed by design flaws.

    a wrist-rest that doesn't come off being this keyboard's flaw.

    bulkiness and redundant gimmicky features (at least to me) such as lcd screens on logitech ones...

    heavy and lack of basic multimedia keys on das keyboards. i admit das is still in the lead for design now that the x4 has a permanent wrist-rest.
    -1
  • Anonymous
    The term "ghosting" isn't being used properly. Ghosting is when you press 2 keys, and a 3rd key appears on the screen that you didn't press. That's the ghost key. It's extremely, extremely rare to find ghosting on any keyboard at all; controllers are designed to block all possible combinations of keystrokes that would result in a ghost key being sent.

    The term that refers to how many keys you can press at once is rollover. But the reason that companies like MS, Logitech, and Razer don't use it because it's defined by the FEWEST number of keys you can press. Even if you can press up to 20 keys at once, if there's another combination of just 2 keys that results in blocking, it's still called 2-key rollover.

    There are plenty of boards with full n-key rollover (as in, you can press every single key on the keyboard at once), but they are all mechanical. NKRO requires that either a diode is placed in series with every keyswitch, which isn't feasible on a membrane sheet. It requires a PCB.
    1
  • anamaniac
    Hmm, I'm still considering getting a Macintosh aluminum keyboard (the one without the numpad).
    How sexy a keyboard is comes into factor, and while I dislike Mac laptops, I do like the keyboard and its laptop keys (not all of us care to have a loud click or deep key).

    The Saitek Eclipse II is also a contender for my desk space. =)
    Sorry Microsoft, I'll use your OS, but nothing else...
    -1
  • blackmancer
    what melon head presses 6 keys at once anyway??
    1
  • olavxxx
    blackmancer: some people do :-)

    You have split screen games, you have NBA-games that use a lot of keys, etc.

    On the cheaper OEM-like keyboards, you can even have problems with as little as 3 keys(!). It's because it works in a grid.. eg. if you try the ghost-test on W + E + D, some keyboards will fail.

    Others have made a higher resolution grid below the keys, but many producers only move it to another place, to minimize problems.

    I have tested the x6 today and it really works as advertised.. It looks a bit cheap maybe, but I think it will perform well.. I'd like shorter stroke on the keys.. but hey, cant get it all for this low sum :-)
    0
  • Anonymous
    I say this is a good keyboard if your new to gaming and can barely think of 6 macros let alone 30!
    0